2 ms·
They are literally two very different types of data. This isn't an ambiguous issue: One is a continuous variable, the other categorical. Whether or not one or t
by ineedasername 7y ago
They are literally two very different types of data. This isn't an ambiguous issue: One is a continuous variable, the other categorical. Whether or not one or the other could erroneously flag someone doesn't change that, and doesn't mean they're the same. Because the nature of those differences means the use cases are different. A continuous score has much wider versatility than a black & white binary value, and allows for more nuanced use. Even if it's just in the realm of fraud detection, a continuous score allows for more safeguards, e.g., if it's low but not too low then it triggers further review rather than outright rejection.
- maxerickson 7y agoCategorization into groups that you will or will not do business with is scoring. Pedantically explaining what sort of scoring it is doesn't change that.
- ineedasername 7y agoExcept that sort of will/won't is the only possible result of binary variables, while continuous allow more possibilities, like assigning a continuous variable interest rate on the basis of a continuous input. I wasn't explaining some basic aspect of statistical variables for it's own sake, in this context it is not some pedantic hair splitting, it's a relevant aspect of the types of things that can be done with this data.
- CPLX 7y agoYou were replying to a comment that said "a binary score is still a score" The comment you appear to be arguing with, is completely true. A binary score is of course a score, and in fact that's almost always how credit and trust scores are actually perceived. From the company's perspective many scores are continuous, but from the consumers perspective that's mostly a distinction without a difference. Usually from the consumer side you're being told you got the job or didn't, or got the credit card, or loan, or apartment, or didn't.
- ineedasername 7y agoI never said it wasn't a score, my issue was the implications that, both being scores, they were somehow equivalent. They are not. A continuous score may be used with a threshold to perform the binary categorization. In fact that is all but guaranteed. But the continuous score, as I stated, has more possibilities for nuanced use. The binary score is derived from something continuous. And you aren't usually told you got the loan or not. That is one possibility, but the more likely one is the continuous score of the credit rating translates into a continuous score for the interest rate. This is why the distinction between a binary and continuous score is important: t This continuous assignment of interest rate isn't possible with a single binary variable.