3 ms·
Assuming we want the total tax take to stay the same is a blatantly false assumption. Property taxes are a percentage of the assessed value. Repealing prop 13
by zepto 7y ago
Assuming we want the total tax take to stay the same is a blatantly false assumption.
Property taxes are a percentage of the assessed value.
Repealing prop 13 would definitely make them go up.
Nobody is saying you aren’t allowed to own a house in San Francisco.
You are saying that people who do own them should be forced out so that you can have them.
‘It’s just as cruel for me not to have it as for you not to have it’ is literally the logic of a thief.
- lmm 7y ago> Nobody is saying you aren’t allowed to own a house in San Francisco. You're saying that I should pay twice as much property tax or more as someone else living in an equally valuable house. That's unjust. > You are saying that people who do own them should be forced out so that you can have them. So charging me taxes is "no-one is saying you're not allowed", but charging them taxes is "force"? It's the same mechanism either way. > ‘It’s just as cruel for me not to have it as for you not to have it’ is literally the logic of a thief. "I took it years ago so it's mine now" is thief logic too.
- zepto 7y ago“I took it years ago so it’s mine now” is indeed thief logic too. But of course nobody is saying this because nobody took anything years ago. They bought it from someone who wanted to sell it to them. The only one suggesting forcing people out of their property here is you. I am not saying you should pay twice as much property tax as someone living in an equally valuable house. I am saying that increasing property taxes as prices go up is confiscatory and immoral. I am saying that anyone who wants to use this mechanism to displace people so that they can acquire their property is a thief. My personal view is that property taxes are the problem here. Not prop 13. If the city needs to raise revenue it should be via income, or a per person charge for services. Other countries do this and it works just fine.
- lmm 7y ago> But of course nobody is saying this because nobody took anything years ago. > They bought it from someone who wanted to sell it to them. I'm not proposing to take anyone else's house either. They are more than welcome to keep their house (as long as they keep paying their fair share of taxes, obeying the law, and doing all the other things that we expect of decent citizens). They still have a free choice over whether to sell their house or not. Once we remove the unfair subsidy they get because they happened to buy it a long time ago, a lot of them are likely to decide that the house is worth less to them than what they could sell it for, that's all. > I am not saying you should pay twice as much property tax as someone living in an equally valuable house. > I am saying that increasing property taxes as prices go up is confiscatory and immoral. How do you reconcile those two statements? If you're saying that people should be taxed based on the price they purchased that then you're saying exactly that I should pay twice as much as certain other people living in houses that have the same value. Of course property prices change; taxing everyone based on their current house value is equitable and nondiscriminatory. Taxing based on the price when they happened to buy is neither. > I am saying that anyone who wants to use this mechanism to displace people so that they can acquire their property is a thief. We live in a society, it's everyone's responsibility to pay their taxes. The thieves are the people who want to avoid paying their fair share so that they can keep living above their means. > If the city needs to raise revenue it should be via income, or a per person charge for services. Other countries do this and it works just fine. They do not work "just fine". Poll taxes are immensely regressive. Income taxes disincentivize productive work. Land is the one thing we can't produce more of when prices rise - those hoarding it should absolutely be shouldering a corresponding tax bill.
- zepto 7y agoLand prices rise as a result of people wanting to buy the land and competing with other people with means to buy it. You are proposing that the taxes of someone who owns a house should be based on the ability of other people to buy it. Nothing could be more regressive than that. It is absolutely discriminatory and in no way equitable. Living in the house you bought for yourself is clearly not ‘hoarding’. It seems like you are getting emotional now. There is nothing discriminatory about basing taxes on the purchase price. If you buy now, you will benefit from prop 13 the same as anyone else. Also, using taxes to force people out of their houses as you propose, is a terrible idea for the development of the economy since it disincentivizes the development of productive industry in other less developed areas.