2 ms·
>> During the presentation, he asserted that physics was built and invented by men, and stated on a slide that “Physics is not sexist against women.” Well, the
by coldtea 7y ago
>> During the presentation, he asserted that physics was built and invented by men, and stated on a slide that “Physics is not sexist against women.”
Well, the first claim is statistically true (and people who are against e.g. sexism in physics also accept it as true and want to change it).
The second is their opinion, which one might or might not agree with. Don't know about physics, but the biology department in our university was mostly women, for example (contrast with CS, which was 90% men).
>So how does the content of the article justify your snark and imaginary irrational response?
I already covered it in the second part of my response, didn't I?
"if this particular study indeed turns out to be bad (not replicating, bad methodology, etc) that would validate the above truth even more. It would obviously be because no good science could ever come from studying such issues -- not because papers regularly turn to be bad, regardless of subject"
- danso 7y agoNo, you didn't, or at least I interpreted whatever you were trying to say as a red herring. Who in the article makes that insinuation? Who said anything about the paper's purported flawed methodology as automatically validating the "above truth"?
- coldtea 7y ago>Who in the article makes that insinuation? Many people in real life, forums, etc. Who said it had to be in the article? I'm pointing at a larger trend.
- danso 7y agoI don't see how personal grievances and perceptions of "many people in real life" are useful and relevant to the discussion. Just like my many real life experiences with guys being assholes is not useful to discussing this paper and its publication.
- coldtea 7y agoWe're not discussing some mathematical formula. The whole thread is about the political perceptions and opinions of whether such an article should be printed, based on perspectives on various societal issues, plus some meta-discussion on how journals should work. Check out the (at the moment at least) top voted comment: "In case anyone remembers the incident at CERN (...)" etc. And of course that meta discussion is much more useful than wether this individual article is correct or not.