3 ms·
How dare they let science interfere with politics? If the science doesn't agree with the current politics, it's obviously bad science. And if this particular s
by coldtea 7y ago
How dare they let science interfere with politics? If the science doesn't agree with the current politics, it's obviously bad science.
And if this particular study indeed turns out to be bad (not replicating, bad methodology, etc) that would validate the above truth even more. It would obviously be because no good science could ever come from studying such issues -- not because papers regularly turn to be bad, regardless of subject.
The only appropriate response is for non-scientific concerned groups plus a few politically-minded scientists to put pressure to their institutions to make sure such researchers don't work in the field again.
/s
- cjslep 7y agoI have an idea about quantitatively measuring git commits and associated names of a population in order to make to make qualitative statements about each individual's life experiences in subsets of that population, like "most of the men have no life", "the men need to go outside and smile more". I did technical things and some math. But it's an edgy conclusion. Can I be published in your journal? /s
- coldtea 7y agoIs that supposed to be making fun of people's strawman ideas of what this paper is (and can't be be, given its topic)? Else, it could very well serve as that.
- cjslep 7y agoI would like to think my response makes relentless fun of your position (and a mockery of your delivery) as well as chide the position of those that will inevitably strawman it. Neither such positions addresses the real crumbling core which is that the conclusions of the paper do not reasonably follow from the bibliographic methodology, and as such the paper's entire approach is quite illogical from the get-go. The positions I make fun of accept this insanity. Toodle-oo~
- thrower123 7y agoYou could get away with that, because it's generally accepted as okay to poke male nerds in the eye. Some would even applaud you for "punching up".
- danso 7y agoIt seems the brunt of the controversy around the author arose from non-scientific assertions he made during a guest lecture: > During the presentation, he asserted that physics was built and invented by men, and stated on a slide that “Physics is not sexist against women.” While the premise of the article is that the paper's publication is "a move likely to attract criticism", the person most critical of the paper, who is interviewed in the article, cites substantive non-political reasons why they dislike the paper: > One member of the editorial board of QSS, which is published by MIT Press and the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics (ISSI), gives Strumia’s paper poor reviews. The study is “methodologically flawed” and “fails to meet the standards of the bibliometric community,” says Cassidy Sugimoto, an information scientist at Indiana University in Bloomington... So how does the content of the article justify your snark and imaginary irrational response?
- coldtea 7y ago>> During the presentation, he asserted that physics was built and invented by men, and stated on a slide that “Physics is not sexist against women.” Well, the first claim is statistically true (and people who are against e.g. sexism in physics also accept it as true and want to change it). The second is their opinion, which one might or might not agree with. Don't know about physics, but the biology department in our university was mostly women, for example (contrast with CS, which was 90% men). >So how does the content of the article justify your snark and imaginary irrational response? I already covered it in the second part of my response, didn't I? "if this particular study indeed turns out to be bad (not replicating, bad methodology, etc) that would validate the above truth even more. It would obviously be because no good science could ever come from studying such issues -- not because papers regularly turn to be bad, regardless of subject"
- danso 7y agoNo, you didn't, or at least I interpreted whatever you were trying to say as a red herring. Who in the article makes that insinuation? Who said anything about the paper's purported flawed methodology as automatically validating the "above truth"?
- EthanHeilman 7y agoI don't know much about the study quoted but I wanted to make an general counter-argument to one of your statements. I often see this counter-argument made implicitly but for the sake of clarity I'd like to explicitly state it here. >And if this particular study indeed turns out to be bad (not replicating, bad methodology, etc) that would validate the above truth even more. Publishing bad-science and then saying other scientists will show it is wrong is both true and does not address the central complaint: it will cause harm to those outside the scientific community. This is because as far as the public is concerned publication functions as endorsement. For instance the Antivaxxer movement got an enormous boost when incorrect science was published that purported to show that vaccines cause autism. It is likely that publishing that study has resulted in many human deaths. If a paper makes a claim which could cause public harm, that study should be held to a significantly higher standard of evidence than a study which is unlikely to cause harm. Consider two papers: 1. A paper which argues that photons travel faster than the speed of light. 2. A paper which argues that diet coke cures cancer. They both might be sloppy research, they both make extraordinary claims but the second ones harm to society is higher and thus must have very strong evidence to be published.
- coldtea 7y ago>Publishing bad-science and then saying other scientists will show it is wrong is both true and does not address the central complaint: it will cause harm to those outside the scientific community. If "publishing bad science" was the issue people were concerned with, then 80% of published (peer-reviewed and all) papers should be met with the same or worse reactions for they are time and again shown to be bad science. But I fear that it's the "we don't like the conclusions" more than the "bad science" part. And I fear that the latter (which might very well be the case) is even a priori assumed given the conclusions. In you response you take for granted what oughta be proved: that the paper would cause "public harm".
- Vinnl 7y agoGP did not argue that "publishing bad science" was a concern, but the effects of the publication of bad science. Those are to be considered greater and worse here than with 80% of published research.