6 ms·
I guess I don't see any way a dockless bike/scooter rental scheme can be compatible with privacy. Their need to know where available bikes are, and to be able t
by michaelt 7y ago
I guess I don't see any way a dockless bike/scooter rental scheme can be compatible with privacy. Their need to know where available bikes are, and to be able to detect thefts makes it hard to imagine they could work without GPS tracking.
And as soon as you know who rented what bike when, and where each bike went, you're going to start knowing customers' homes, workplaces and places of worship.
Although the government and uber knowing this data is less private than uber alone knowing, we all know uber doesn't give a shit about customer privacy. Personally I'd be much more worried about uber having the data in the first place than about the government also having the data.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoAlmost every possible transportation service is like this. If you really need privacy, don't use public or paid transport.
- pasiaj 7y agoI expect Uber to care a lot about privacy. They’ve burned themselves badly before disrespecting privacy and I assume they’ve improved in that area immensely. Uber’s and their employees’ own interests are aligned with strong data privacy. The same cannot be said for the government.
- shakna 7y ago> I assume they’ve improved in that area immensely. Why would you assume that without significant reason? This is a company that has, as you said, had problems with privacy. 2015, tracking concerns hit the news. [0] 2017, there's a class action. [1] And FTC auditing. [2] 2018, there's massive fines. [3] We're in 2019, years on from actual problems being raised, and then being forced to confronted. How are Uber doing on that front? > By focusing on global hiring, you will have people on the ground in other regions who can better understand the local laws, better understand the culture that drove the laws and how a new law is likely to be enforced, and build better relationships with regulators and other influencers. Sounds more like they're interested in controlling the laws, not actually improving themselves overall. (And none of this is to suggest the government is any way a better caretaker - they're worse in almost every way.) [0] https://www.wired.com/insights/2015/01/uber-privacy-woes-cautionary-tale/ https://www.wired.com/insights/2015/01/uber-privacy-woes-cau... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/apr/24/uber-hell-program-driver-privacy-lyft-spying https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/apr/24/uber-hell... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/15/technology/uber-agrees-to-privacy-audits-in-settlement-with-ftc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/15/technology/uber-agrees-to... [3] https://techwireasia.com/2019/08/uber-chief-privacy-officer-advises-on-building-strong-compliance-teams/ https://techwireasia.com/2019/08/uber-chief-privacy-officer-...
- jacquesm 7y agoI would assume they don't give a damn. I would also assume they will do everything to give the opposite impression.
- forgottenpass 7y ago>I expect Uber to care a lot about privacy. Uber cares about the confidentiality of their business records. They will continue to not give a single fuck about privacy. There is a difference.
- Jakob 7y agoWithout GPS or internet: put the bike at a cross road and tell the app (or call center) at which cross road you put it. Every now and then they get serviced, if the bike is not where you put it as the last owner, you pay a fine. That’s how it worked for years in Munich, Germany. That way the bike doesn’t even need internet. To unlock the bike it generates a code with a key which is on the bike. I don’t see how GPS prevents theft for small items like a bike. There is a lot of bigger farming machinery stolen despite their GPS.
- michaelt 7y ago> if the bike is not where you put it as the last owner, you pay a fine How do they tell the difference between the last user not returning it, and the bike being stolen with bolt cutters after the last user returned it properly?
- ForHackernews 7y agoMaybe you snap a pic of the bike where you parked it and upload it as part of the park/lock/check-in process?
- candu 7y agoNot sure how they do it exactly, but one possibility is CCTV cameras watching drop-off locations. You can then compare footage at the timestamp it was reported on-location if there's a dispute. Combine this with a few anti-theft procedures that don't involve GPS / internet (as commonly used by bikeshare programs in various municipalities) and you've got something that might work.
- sneak 7y agoCCTV video files are just a less efficient form of GPS and time stamp logging. JSON from a GPS receiver is more straightforward.
- heavenlyblue 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- the_mitsuhiko 7y ago> I guess I don't see any way a dockless bike/scooter rental scheme can be compatible with privacy. Their need to know where available bikes are, and to be able to detect thefts makes it hard to imagine they could work without GPS tracking. I fail to understand why it's an issue if the government has this data but people are okay with Uber having it. Surely trusting the government is a more reasonable policy?
- ekianjo 7y ago> Surely trusting the government is a more reasonable policy? Looks like you have not really read about what governments do to their people when it's convenient for them to do so. Current examples: check China. Of course the US is not China, but that should be an ample warning enough that trusting government with data + power is a bad combination.
- AlexandrB 7y ago"China" (as in the CCP) does not, in fact, have the data. They're leveraging a network of mostly-private companies to do the dirty work for them. So there's really no difference. If the US government became a dictatorship tomorrow, all the data collected by US private companies would end up in the government's hands. Neither private companies nor government entities can be trusted, and the only right answer is to demand that the data is not collected in the first place.
- ekianjo 7y ago> "China" (as in the CCP) does not, in fact, have the data. They're leveraging a network of mostly-private companies to do the dirty work for them The difference is that the CCP has every right to shut down businesses and they make the Law directly. No provisions can be made by external parties, there is no separation of power. So in practice all companies work in accordance with the CCP and will bend to their requests. In the US there are still companies which can and do refuse the federal government's requests to provide data without sufficient reason.
- 7y ago
- mtgx 7y agoThis will also be true of self-driving cars. You won't be able to go anywhere and not have the government know about it (forever for all future governments). Of course they're already moving in that direction anyway with automatic license plate scans and video surveillance everywhere. I think more people need to wake-up to these things happening and how it could be bad for the future, because it won't be long until these will be virtually irreversible (save revolutions).
- mdorazio 7y agoDo you worry about Google having that same data? If you use google maps on a regular basis they know where you live, work, eat, travel, hang out with friends, and which routes you take when.
- epistasis 7y agoI avoid using Google Maps for precisely this reason. I'm less concerned about Uber or a local government having that data, far far less concerned. Uber rates as slightly more concerning than a government, because Uber will likely try to monetize it when/if their current business model fails to deliver profits to Wall Street.
- icebraining 7y agoWhereas the government will just share it with private companies and leak it: https://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2019/07/10/data-breach-la-county-department-of-health-services-phishing/ https://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2019/07/10/data-breach-la-co...
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoGoogle lets you disable location history or limit collection to the last three months. Existing old data can be manually deleted.
- Angostura 7y ago> as soon as you know who rented what bike Except, as far as I can see, according to the article, the only required info is start and finish point and journey length.
- TrueDuality 7y agoThat's basically all it took to de-anonymise trips for celebrities using the NYC taxi data[1]. There was some poorly anonymized driver information in there but that wasn't used for tracking the celebrities themselves. [1]: https://gawker.com/the-public-nyc-taxicab-database-that-accidentally-track-1646724546 https://gawker.com/the-public-nyc-taxicab-database-that-acci...
- setr 7y agoReading your article, that doesn't appear to be a very correct description; The de-anonymization seems to have occurred through two primary aspects: 1. The taxi medallions were extracted due to poor crypto choice (and simple structure of medallion IDs), so you can map from reality -> dataset 2. The celebrities were photographed entering/exiting the taxi, with the medallion captured. If you broke the link -- the taxi medallion -- you wouldn't have de-anonymized trips. And NYC anonymization process clearly (and correctly) intended for that link to not exist. That is, start, end and length was not the key motivators in de-anonymization in this case. However, you can still imagine this data is sufficient to de-anonymize when usage is rare (and you've captured either start or end destination), but otherwise, the taxi data is not indicative of anonymization futility but rather implementation failure.
- morganherlocker 7y agoThis is not quite incorrect. Some of the NYC taxi re-id demonstrations relied on reversing the hash for medallions, but most have not. In particular, the celebrity tracking did not require the medallion, since each record contains an origin and a destination. The identity of the driver across trips is irrelevant, since it is the passenger who is being tracked. The way this attack worked was to match an origin in the trip dataset to the timestamp on the celebrity photo. This revealed the destination of the trip. In other cases, no photo is necessary (trips originating or ending at a residential address, linked to another sensitive location such as an abortion clinic). There is a lot of research available on this topic. "Unique in the Crowd"[1], published in 2013, found that it takes only 4 GPS locations/timestamps to de-anonymize 95% of the population, with no other metadata. With 2 GPS pings, 50% of trips can be de-anonymized. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/srep01376 https://www.nature.com/articles/srep01376
- bko 7y agoWould you feel the same way if Uber complied privately and the article read: "Uber shares real-time rider information with government agency"? It seems like Uber can't win. If they share information, they're violating the trust and privacy of their riders. If they don't they still don't care about privacy but they're now also flouting regulators.
- habnds 7y agoSeems like if Uber is going to use this data for their benefit society should be able to use it to ours as well for planning an infrastructure purposes for example. The way that society does stuff like this is through government bodies. The real problem here seems like a lack of trust or oversight of government bodies, which creates the impossible situation you identify.
- icebraining 7y ago> Seems like if Uber is going to use this data for their benefit society should be able to use it to ours as well for planning an infrastructure purposes for example. I don't necessarily disagree, but "data used for their benefit" covers all data used by all businesses, from your emails stored by your provider (assuming you don't self-host) to trade secrets, etc. So either we say the government should be able to access all data from everywhere (except the few that individuals store on their own) for planning purposes and such, or we must define why this data is different from other.
- habnds 7y agoFair point, I think there's a fundamental difference between the data collection done by a company like Uber or the FANG or whatever and the data that other companies collect in the normal course of business but it's hard for me to think of a good definition for the difference. There's also the idea that maybe we should have total access to a currently unthinkable amount of data [0] [0] https://www.wired.com/1996/12/fftransparent/ https://www.wired.com/1996/12/fftransparent/
- rhn_mk1 7y ago
- steve_gh 7y agoDepends on the granularity of the data. What's wrong with (say) 100m square blocks as spatial granularity, with ride time to the nearest minute or even 5 minutes. The city should be able to ensure regulatory compliance, while anonymity is preserved.
- SilasX 7y agoIn dense urban areas, there are probably a lot of scooters within a 100m x 100m block.
- sokoloff 7y agoI think that's the point of the suggestion.
- SilasX 7y agoThe "point" was to ensure privacy while satisfying the other desiderata of the the system, which includes ability to find a distinct scooter. I was disputing that it met the latter criteria by grouping too many scooters together (Scylla) in its attempt to avoid privacy violation (Charybdis). After all, why not just lump scooters into the east vs west coast? Though I grant the general point that making the drop-off location more granular could satisfy both criteria, but you would need some kind of varying size to account for scooter density.
- steve_gh 7y agoIf you can count how many scooters are in the system at any time (and how many belong to different providers) then you should be able to enforce your licencing regime. And if you know roughly where rides are going to / from and when, then that helps you integrate your different types of public transport - for example making sure that when the train arrives there are enough scooters there, or understanding how popular scooter ride paths interact with bike lanes, bus lanes, etc. Mobile phone cell size is generally a pretty good proxy for population density - modern micro-cell sectors can be pretty small, and 5G will make them even small in urban areas. (I work on this sort of stuff for a major engineering data science and asset management group in the UK).
- teslaberry 7y agoit cant. the company wants your information so the city cannot give it some other company. it's just that your privacy is being fought over. is it going to be the right of a private company to gather than keep it to themselves ( private to them, but essentially public as they can and DO seell it) or is it going to be forcibly shared ( that is supposedly the govenrment plan for 'open data' and i expect they will be open as they plan. )
- mindslight 7y agoOne could certainly design a least authority system for bike rental. Trusted hardware to compute trip length, psuedonymous account system, untraceable payments. Identity or payment escrow in case of theft. But really, the straightforward way is culturally. Like if there were a general expectation that a company would only use data for an immediate purpose and then delete it, employees confirmed the company culture and processes, their legal terms supported this, and there was a strong privacy law to backstop any bad actors. But our culture is not there. We've just generally accepted that Uber will act as an attacker, exploiting their surveillance data on us as much as currently possible, storing it indefinitely to do "better" in the future, and turning it over to other third party attackers for "business purposes". This article draws our attention because we're pretty sure if the city gets access to this data, they'll do the exact same things for their own ends - probably turning it over to the police to integrate with the ANPR data who will pass it to the feds for their own nefarious games. It's an environment of zero trust with its corresponding high costs, which are becoming more and more apparent as wider society is hit with the implications. This is the true damage that the Surveillance Valley ethos has done, and it's going to take a hell of a long time to recover.
- dwild 7y agoYour ISP have ALL your internet data. Would you be okay if they shared it with the government? Sure they hold it temporarily, but they NEED to hold it to carry their business, even for a short amount of time. The same is true for theses scooters. In the case of the ISP, you trust them to destroy that data once it's moved to the next node, in the case of the scooters, the same can be true. Thus, either you are fine with the government getting this data, simply because you don't trust Uber, or you are agreeing that the ISP should also share its data with the government in real time.
- x220 7y agoReal talk: you do not and are never going to have privacy if you have a mobile phone. You are carrying a tracking device and feeding data to at least a dozen different companies and government agencies. No mobile app is compatible with privacy because the phone itself disintegrates privacy.
- marcoperaza 7y agoAnyone with a cell phone in their pocket is giving their real time location data to private companies. And I’m very happy that the government can’t just access it without a warrant.