3 ms·
Apple rarely removes public APIs without any deprecation warning that appears when you compile your app at least one version ahead of time.
by scarface74 7y ago
Apple rarely removes public APIs without any deprecation warning that appears when you compile your app at least one version ahead of time.
- BoorishBears 7y agoApple often straight up breaks the implementations of public APIs leaving developers scrambling to fix them. See modals in iOS 13, or title bar styling. I work at a development agency and on both macOS and iOS every release is a race to figure out which breaking changes have been sprung by Apple (including crashes caused by silent changes in behavior of existing APIs, people have had apps rejected for breaking on pre-general release OS versions when we didn't even have the tools to test them yet)
- scarface74 7y agoThere is a difference between breaking a public API which is a defect and that’s done unintentionally - that happens with every operating system and framework - and depending on private methods to behave appropriately. Decades ago, when Apple introduced 68040 Macs, a lot of programs broke because they were writing self modifying code and that didn’t work with the 68040 cache. Whose fault was that Apple’s or the developers?
- BoorishBears 7y agoIt is not a defect. It is literally intentionally broken! Do you actually know this space? The modal example, it's to support new design language Apple is pushing, straight up breaks modals designed a certain (valid) way. Catalina removed XML exports used by music apps. There was no deprecation warning. Apple's recommended fix? Don't update if you need one of those apps. These are not defects, they are literally breaking changes intentionally made with no warning. I don't understand why all of you seem to be operating underthe assumption apps using "public APIs" just work with each OS update. It just doesn't work like that. They break and crash not due to defects but due to intentional changes
- scarface74 7y agoIt was part of the first beta release that the new iTunes wouldn't support XML exports. So there was warning that it wouldn't work. Public API's doesn't mean "something will never change". It should mean that API's won't change between minor version numbers. The entire purpose of semantic versioning is that there might be major breaking changing when there is a major release. Apple did in fact provide a method to share music between apps and some apps do take advantage of it. Do you really think that Apple didn't need to do a major overhaul of iTunes? Of course it's Apple's advice and common sense not to upgrade your OS until the apps you use are updated to support it. This is all modern software engineering 101. As a developer there are a few expectations. - depending on private method may break your code with any point release. The vendor has no obligation not to break code if you depended on a private API. - If your code breaks calling a public method during a point release, it is a bug and the vendor has an obligation not to break public API's when releasing a point release. - If the vendor makes a breaking change during a major release (x.0.0). It's the vendor's responsible to communicate the breaking change and give enough notice to developers/users about breaking changes so that either the developer can fix their code, the user can find a replacement app, and/or the user not upgrade.
- BoorishBears 7y agoYou spent so many words to latch onto a single part of my entire comment, construct a strawman around it, and burn it down. But lo and behold something useful did come of it, I finally found the fundamental misunderstanding keeping you from understanding what the crux of the issue is. > If your code breaks calling a public method during a point release, it is a bug and the vendor has an obligation not to break public API's when releasing a point release. Not when the vendor is Apple. This whole time you've been operating on the set of rules that apply when your vendor considers you a partner of sorts, maybe in the vaguest sense of the word, but a partner nonetheless. iOS point releases break things literally all the time. Iirc we actually saw more fires on 13.1 than 13.0 This literally has nothing to do with semantic versioning or whatever else you want to confuse it with. It's a blatant disregard for developers that Apple has carried throughout it's operations, from APIs to app store rejections. If anything the only reason they get the slightest pass is they're not Google, who manages to make talking to a human, no matter how hard they stonewall you, a selling point in mobile developer relations now.