4 ms·
Welcome to the new and shiny version of anti-intellectualism: where the only purpose of education is to get a job and the value of a job is determined by how lu
by keiferski 7y ago
Welcome to the new and shiny version of anti-intellectualism: where the only purpose of education is to get a job and the value of a job is determined by how lucrative it is. Now scale that up to the level of an economy and you have a basic idea of how we live in a materially-rich and intellectually-poor culture.
In some sense, this was inevitable when universities opened up to the general population, rather than their original limited participation among the upper classes and very academically-focused individuals. At this point, the best path forward is probably to entirely decouple "skills-based" (i.e. lucrative) training programs from "education-based" programs. Otherwise, anything that isn't economically-valuable will eventually lose funding - which has already happened for fields like philosophy or literature.
- irb 7y agoI think the reason that solely skills-based institutions never flourished is due to the kind of cronyism and old boy networks that the article strangely seems to see as one aspect of the current system that is worth preserving. The difficulty is in persuading those people who are hiring, who went to university, to value qualifications from skills-based courses, rather than assuming that the people who obtain them are lower class and too thick to go to university.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ForHackernews 7y agoThe problem with the decoupling you propose is that the elites will still want real education for their children, so those programs will also be filled with careerist strivers craving the stamp of upper-class signalling. Meanwhile, your "skills-based" programs will be devalued as a worthless trade school for wannabes (for an example of this, see employers who consider things like A+ cert a negative hiring signal).
- black_puppydog 7y ago> In some sense, this was inevitable when universities opened up to the general population, rather than their original limited participation among the upper classes and very academically-focused individuals. 1. Personally, I consider that step to be a good one. I'll put that off as poor phrasing, because otherwise I'd have to assume you'd prefer it to have stayed an elite game. 2. I don't see how that was inevitable. The opening-up of education to a broader audience inevitably led to an "intellectually-poor culture"? I don't buy that, there's a bigger story to tell here.
- keiferski 7y agoWell, I would make a distinction between “removing barriers to entry” and “discarding values in order to appeal to the user/customer.” I see the former as a good thing and the latter as a deeply bad one. There’s a difference between allowing anyone qualified to attend your institution _and_ restructuring the values of your institution to match the most lucrative market segment. Universities today are multi-billion dollar organizations that functionally treat students like customers. Ergo you have academic values being slowly replaced by “is this valuable in the marketplace?” Everything is framed in terms of economics because the average person just wants to get a good job. That’s understandable but doesn’t justify eliminating fundamentally important topics like literature or art or philosophy. Thus my decoupling suggestion. > there’s a bigger story here. Of course, but I can’t write a thesis on the past two centuries of western civilization in a HN comment.
- petra 7y agoIf there's demand to studying the humanities, why can't the students pay for it? You can say that the state should subsidize non-wealthy students. But why? shouldn't they, especially, focus on providing for their family, and learn interesting things on the side, like everybody else ?
- black_puppydog 7y agoCould you please phrase more clearly that only rich people should have a right to self expression?
- barry-cotter 7y agoMaking education available to everyone is a good thing. Lowering standards is not. If you go from having 10% of the population go to college to 40% average intellectual engagement probably goes up a little but the quality signal of a Bachelor’s degree becomes diluted to the point of non-existence.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoNot anti intellectualism, simple fact. Look at the history of education, then the later opening up of universities. Originally it was something more - to train the elite to be the elite that runs everyone's lives - i.e. run the world, get the attitude and to think. Philosophy is still a common choice here. Then wider education - and later university expansion was built on a different skill set, a different education for filling the factories. A worker, a (suitably compliant) citizen. Just about no one at all goes near philosophy. Same name of "education", two entirely different results. Politicians have occasionally aspired to equalise those two regimes, or aspire to something a little higher, but rarely has that played out, and has never lasted.
- buboard 7y agoI m not sure there is a lot of intellectualism coming out of universities nowadays. Rampant activist homoculture and the purging of all heresies have left little room for it. You d have to point out some important public intellectual functions that universities did recently. Indeed the idea that elite intellectualism is a good thing and not just a relic of old times needs to be proven
- notfromhere 7y agoThis whole comment is pretty telling, but not in the way you'd imagine.
- buboard 7y agocontent-less snarks are at least equally telling
- barry-cotter 7y agoFor someone who can’t distinguish between schooling and education to accuse others of anti-intellectualism is a bit rich. To read an article in which the author engaged with ideas and call him an anti-intellectual is practically self refuting. People who don’t care about ideas don’t think about them. They certainly don’t write about them. The idea we live in an intellectually poor culture is wildly at odds with the facts. Most people don’t care about ideas, they never did. But now those who do can learn about them with greater ease than ever before, discuss them with more people and reach more people if they have anything to say. You’re dismissing Byrne’s essay without being familiar with the economics literature on signaling in education and assuming that education can only happen in a university. Other people will learn about the signaling model of education[1] because of this. There’s an explosion of educational content on Youtube, free ebooks aplenty, edX, Coursera, the SEP. Most people don’t care but for those who do care about ideas this is probably the best time to be alive ever. [1] https://www.econlib.org/archives/2015/04/educational_sig_1.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2015/04/educational_sig_1.h... https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691174655/the-case-against-education https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691174655/th...
- keiferski 7y agoI don’t know how the availability of educational content online has anything to do what I said. And nowhere did I say that the only place one can get an education is within an institution. Your comment is a pretty big strawman. Educational institutions in the United States have become customer-focused corporations in all but name. While it’s nice that information is available for personal use via the Internet (although frankly most of it has already been available in public libraries for the last century), that’s a separate point. The discussion is about educational institutions, not the ability of one to self-educate. The point is: if you’re doing an economic analysis on the value of an education, you’ve already lost. Institutions which once were dedicated to timeless academic values are now mostly about making a buck. If you went to university a century ago, it was probably to pursue an academic career. If you go now, it’s probably to get a better job. The fact that you as an individual can watch a YouTube course doesn’t change the fact that influential institutions have a dramatic effect on popular culture, society and politics, and ergo graduates of those institutions will shape society.