3 ms·
Since this thread is about water splitting and woo, I thought I'd share my favourite example of using radio wave resonance to burn saltwater. https://www.popula
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
Since this thread is about water splitting and woo, I thought I'd share my favourite example of using radio wave resonance to burn saltwater.
https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a2840/4271398/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a2840/4271398/
Because that sounds so absolutely nutty, nobody seems to notice the published evidence that it actually works. The energy efficiency is so-so -- but the point is that the woo-connection creates a sort of forcefield around the topic, preventing scientific study.
You'd hope it would produce the opposite effect. E.g, "wow, this has public interest, let's test and disprove -- and maybe make a practical discovery"
- jodrellblank 7y agoIf you want it to be taken seriously, why do you - and Popular Mechanics - describe it in such woowoo terms? "using radio wave resonance to burn saltwater." ; "had discovered a seemingly impossible phenomenon: a way to burn salt water by exposing it to radio waves." - The salt water isn't burning, burning Hydrogen isn't seemingly impossible, separating Hydrogen from water isn't seemingly impossible. The description is nothing like what's actually happening. the effect can be achieved with a much lower energy catalyst: radio waves are present in everything from microwaves to televisions. - ??? is this trying to imply you can mine radio waves from a television and use them for this? What a bizarre sentence. "Nobody is claiming that you get more energy out than you put in," he says.; They even envision a future in which a vehicle can run off its radio's frequency waves. .. is that not getting more out than you put in? A vehicle which generates radio waves, uses them to split seawater, burns the gas, uses that power to generate the radio waves, and also motion? Then the burnt H and O turn into ash (H2O) and drip back into the "fuel" tank to be burned again? That's not water as a "fuel", that's an overunity machine, perpetual motion. If they're not claiming you get more energy out than you put in, stop claiming that. In the video the inventor is talking about how their Sterling Engine "could be a car engine if you wanted" but if you're putting in mains electric power to this, you'd be better off connecting that to an electric motor and saying "that could be a car engine" - it couldn't, it's mains electric powered. This is a neat electrolysis without electrodes idea, but why(??) is it being presented as the woowoo idea "water powered car"?
- dr_dshiv 7y agoI presented it in woo woo terms to make my point. Popular Mechanics put it in woo woo terms to sell copies. The point here is: holy crap, radio waves can provide electrodeless water splitting and physicists don't care because it sounds like woo. Of course the public and the press will see salt water burning and freak out -- but that excitement shouldn't be a reason for physicists to ignore the phenomena.
- yetihehe 7y ago> radio waves can provide electrodeless water splitting and physicists don't care Probably they don't care, because as soon as that water is split, it is ignited and burned again, so you can't have any hydrogen, you have just changed some rf energy into heat, losing some energy into heat in rf setup... It's easier to just heat something directly with elecrticity. Now if someone invented a way for oxygen and hydrogen split that way to remain split for more than milliseconds, physicists would be more interested.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoSounds like a good research question for physicists :)
- ChrisLomont 7y agoI suspect physicists look at it for a moment and realize: Converting electricity into radio waves with energy losses, sent through the air with energy losses, to bombard molecules, which then resonate with the waves to use electromagnetic forces to split molecules, will always be less efficient than simply using that original electric current to do the same thing directly with less energy loss. This will always be energy inferior to simple electrolysis.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoThat may be; I don't know the proof. There may be combined approaches, too, with potential for lowest system cost. Here is a patent from an Israeli company on this topic, granted just this year: https://patents.google.com/patent/EP2911976A4/it https://patents.google.com/patent/EP2911976A4/it