5 ms·
Ultimately the only way out of all this tracking is regulation.
by tinus_hn 7y ago
Ultimately the only way out of all this tracking is regulation.
- rexpop 7y agoI have little faith in such avenues, given the strength of regulatory capture we're seeing across industry.
- jrcii 7y agoThere is no avenue to escape the rich from creating profit at the expense of the masses. Digital privacy serves neither the government nor the wealthy executives helming these corporations so it will never happen. The public is apathetic and preoccupied with rising food and housing costs. The merits of digital privacy won’t fix any of this.
- pjmorris 7y ago"The three golden rules to ensure computer security are: do not own a computer; do not power it on; and do not use it" - Robert H. Morris
- snvzz 7y agoMight have been reasonable at some point. Unfortunately, even if you don't own a computer, power it on or use it, you're still under computer-based surveillance.
- Razengan 7y agoYou can still be tracked by other people's computers/devices, or via what they share/say on their accounts.
- DenisM 7y agoAnd (phone) cameras. Try dodging that.
- codedokode 7y agoWhy phone cameras? Credit cards. Mobile phones. Street cameras with face recognition. Security cameras. Do you know that many private-owned cameras are connected to a "cloud" (to save money on buying a video server) and cloud owners could see streams from all of them?
- DenisM 7y agoBecause your friends are likely to take a picture of you and other friends with good angle/exposure etc, and upload them to some network. There is no escaping that, unlike credit cards. I don’t know if security / street cams actually record anything for more than a day, and I don’t know anyone with home security camera, but friends are always there!
- cestith 7y agoYou have proposed a social solution to a technical problem. Why does JavaScript offer a way to enumerate things about the client cat the server has no need to know?
- jdnenej 7y agoBecause it is extraordinary difficult to have a useful programming language that can not be used for tracking. A social solution and technical solutions are needed. Firefox has put in a huge effort to prevent tracking but many useful features can also be used for tracking so a browser will not be able to determine useful and non useful code.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoWe have to make it less useful then. They were given the audio/canvas/whatever APIs and instead of using it to make great web applications they abused it by turning it into personal information to track us and exploit us for profit. We gave them this power and now we have to take it away. The site shouldn't be able to do anything without user's permission.
- baroffoos 7y agoI don't want a browser that comes up with 10000 popups asking if it has permission to render an image or permission to add 2 numbers together. I want a browser that can get the task done with the least friction possible and a legal system that prevents abuse. The website should be the one to inform me that they are actually using the audio api for tracking and not just playing audio. With a large penalty for lying. If we were talking about the issue of people being stabbed you don't suggest "Why should the stabber be penalized? The victim should have been wearing a Kevlar vest that doesn't allow them to be stabbed. If they weren't then they should simply expect that people will stab them."
- Mirioron 7y ago>The website should be the one to inform me that they are actually using the audio api for tracking and not just playing audio. With a large penalty for lying. The website can't do anything without your browser cooperating. The website can request the audio API as much as it wants but if your browser had a same configuration then it would just ignore it. You're asking for legislation on a problem with a global scope. Countries that ignore your laws will still do all of this as long as your browser lets them. >If we were talking about the issue of people being stabbed you don't suggest "Why should the stabber be penalized? The victim should have been wearing a Kevlar vest that doesn't allow them to be stabbed. This is such a poor analogy. The server doesn't do anything without a client asking for something. In your case the victim went to the stabber and started the interaction. Then the victim's electric scooter (browser) malfunctioned or was poorly configured and drove into the stabber's knife. Of course the server isn't blameless, because they are most likely knowingly exploiting this. But to suggest that the user has no control over this is foolish. It implies that the user can't be blamed for anything their computer does.
- mc3 7y agoAt what point on the line does tracking people based on side effects of running JS become illegal unauthorized access to a computer. For example if there is an exploit to read your local files and upload them to the server, that would clearly be illegal. What if you just got the names of the files? What if you just got the count, e.g. 33413 and stored it against a name? What about the count, but just used as a semi-anonymous tracking token? What about system information, as a tracking token? What about audio information specifically, as a tracking system? (Like this appears to be. Didn't read the article because it won't load for me).
- thenewnewguy 7y agoI don't know how well this would stand up in court, but the obvious difference here seems to be using "an exploit to read your local files" vs an intentionally designed API.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoUnless it's flipping bits via radiation, every exploit is (ab)using "an intentionally designed API". In this case, audio API may be intentionally designed, but the intention wasn't to allow fingerprinting.
- _ink_ 7y agoNeither the canvas API, nor the audio API was designed with the idea of providing funtionalities for user tracking. To me it is a clear misuse and I find the comparision to an exploit fair. I really would like to see somebody sue.
- Mirioron 7y agoHow? The US regulates that websites in the US can't do this. But Chinese website can, Russian websites can. I don't see how you solve this with regulation without breaking the internet. As far as I can tell, the solution ultimately is to consider privacy first as a user and a developer. Browsers and their users need to start providing less information to websites by default and prompt the user to share information. If you try doing this through regulation then you end up with GDPR pop ups. What we need is for the browsers (and OS!) to stop leaking all of our information.
- chungus_khan 7y agoThis runs in direct opposition to the interests of the largest browser vendor though.