3 ms·
The ethical constraint is that the _patient_ must directly benefit from any medical intervention. Doctors are not supposed to do things that have a negative re
by tialaramex 7y ago
The ethical constraint is that the _patient_ must directly benefit from any medical intervention. Doctors are not supposed to do things that have a negative result for their individual patient even if they have some hypothetical big picture benefit for society.
So for this reason the story isn't about how it's be great for women if more men were vaccinated, that's an interesting public health statistical consideration but it can't help doctors decide whether to vaccinate men.
Maybe it'd be way more convenient for sixteen family members if Granny dies this week not next week, but the doctor looking after Granny needn't care about that, he's only considering what is best for her.
- belltaco 7y agoI wonder if we read the same article.
- tialaramex 7y agoThe article which explains how this vaccination results in a personal benefit for male patients? And so therefore we should vaccinate boys? Yes, I'd assume so. The parent I'm replying to suggests it's appropriate to vaccinate boys in order to achieve herd immunity. Herd immunity is something public health officials are interested in, but as I explained ethically individual doctors are obliged to focus on the direct benefit to their patient. "Now you are less likely to get cancer" is a direct benefit, whereas "Now somebody else you may not even have met is less likely to get cancer" is pretty hazy.