8 ms·
Windows XP minimal-requirement experiments (2006)
- zozbot234 7y agoSomeone should run these sorts of experiments w/ ReactOS. Anecdotally, it doesn't seem to be possible to start a mainstream Linux distribution w/ less than about 128MB of RAM, perhaps due to the initramfs-based boot that's ubiquitous nowadays. And a i686 class CPU is needed.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoI think lubuntu comes relatively close to that requirement, but really it is becoming a needless exercise other than being intellectually stimulating. You could just download the older releases of Linux for such machines
- zozbot234 7y ago> You could just download the older releases of Linux for such machines You could also run Windows 95 in 2019... Both are really good plans if you want to get 0wned.
- ahje 7y ago> Both are really good plans if you want to get 0wned. It is wise to point that out; running an old OS on old equipment or in a VM is perfectly viable, but one should NEVER connect those machines to the open Internet.
- Jaruzel 7y agoThis assumes that the user plans to go online using these OSs. For offline use (legacy/classic gaming, or embedded tasks) there'd be no problem.
- silverdemon 7y ago2019 malware likely won't run on Windows 95. The kind of malware you'd stumble across in your normal online activity will mostly target Windows 10 and back to XP, and will be written to that environment and its APIs. Given the need to minimise size and detectable features. Naturally I would not rely on this for my own online safety. A motivated adversary with a specific target in mind would no doubt learn that a vintage Windows 95 install was present, or maybe just throw everything at it.
- thenewnewguy 7y agoI doubt the initramfs is (completely) at fault, mine is rather small (and I haven't done anything to try to minimize its size): $ lsinitcpio -a /boot/initramfs-linux.img ==> Image: initramfs-linux.img ==> Created with mkinitcpio 26 ==> Kernel: 5.3.7-arch1-2-ARCH ==> Size: 9.87 MiB ==> Compressed with: gzip -> Uncompressed size: 25.97 MiB (.379 ratio) -> Estimated decompression time: 0.184s ...
- microcolonel 7y agoMine (same arch kernel) is twice the size, both compressed and uncompressed, for what it's worth; I have a handful of vfio modules included explicitly, as well as amdgpu; so it's still doable. My fallback initramfs is a little over 128MiB compressed.
- bArray 7y agoYou could chooch along quite nicely in Kolibri OS all the way down to 8MB of RAM it seems and have a relatively okay experience in it [1]. Seems as though something like Puppy Linux will get you going on 64MB of RAM or lower [2]. If you really want to take Linux to the extreme, probably the place to start would be the efforts made to use it on embedded devices [3]. [1] https://kolibrios.org/en/ https://kolibrios.org/en/ [2] http://wikka.puppylinux.com/MinimumSystemRequirements http://wikka.puppylinux.com/MinimumSystemRequirements [3] https://elinux.org/Main_Page https://elinux.org/Main_Page
- ahje 7y agoI still have a very old USB key with Puppy Linux on it from, back a darker time when I didn't have my own computer. I've booted quite a few very old systems with it, probably down to Pentium-era machines, and things usually ran well. I do remember it was quite RAM intensive due to having a relatively large filesystem in RAM. I'd say 64 MB is a minimum if you actually want to use it for anything.
- jraph 7y agoI ran modern GNU/Linux on a laptop with a 333 MHz Pentium II processor and 96 MB of RAM until 2010. I still have the laptop and it probably still works, though I lended its charger and I don't know where it landed. It was a bit slow. You had to avoid opening more than two or three browser tabs and avoid swapping at all cost because of the relatively slow HDD. You had to be patient. The computer was designed for windows 95 and 98. It ran Windows 2000 quite well. XP was slow. I was amazed by the fact that a live CD of Ubuntu 5.04 ran pretty good on it, with an early version of GNOME 2. Late versions of GNOME 2 were unusable on it. It also managed to run mandrake 9 with kde 2 (?) well too. Now, current distributions are removing support for x86-32. Debian would probably be the best bet (or slackware ?), if not a specifically lightweight distro. I tried Arch on it but I would not install a rolling distro on anything with a slow drive today. Too painful because of the updates. I wonder if its silicon motion GPU would still work under X11. I'm not sure the vesa driver worked on it. I remember having issues with X11 with this laptop the last times I used it. I used a pcmcia card for the Wi-Fi that I sill have. I needed to use ndiswrapper to use the windows driver on Linux. It didn't handle WPA. Fortunately, almost all Wi-Fi networks were open or encrypted with WEP. Today, I would probably need to use Ethernet, or the only USB1 port it has to plug a Wi-Fi stick. One web page of today would send this computer to swap hell though.
- mschuster91 7y ago> It was a bit slow. You had to avoid opening more than two or three browser tabs and avoid swapping at all cost because of the relatively slow HDD. You had to be patient. Perhaps try a modern CF card? There are passive notebook-PATA bridges still made and sold for under 5$ IIRC - did this to save an old HP Z2100 from a disk failure recently. The bus is still a bottleneck in terms of speed but latency is a no-issue compared to HDDs.
- Lammy 7y agoI'm a big fan of replacing old laptop HDDs with an mSATA SSD in a 2.5" 44-pin IDE adapter. The JM20330-based ones have had the best compatibility for me. Just be sure to disable any auto-defrag that old OSes like Windows 98 come with by default :)
- cellularmitosis 7y agoI was disappointed to learn that the official builds of golang support "i386", but require SSE :( AFAICT, the lowest requirement which happens to also have SSE is i686.
- shakna 7y ago> Anecdotally, it doesn't seem to be possible to start a mainstream Linux distribution w/ less than about 128MB of RAM, perhaps due to the initramfs-based boot that's ubiquitous nowadays. Depends on what you call a mainstream Linux distro. Maybe if you only include "desktop" style Linux distributions, which don't tend to be the most mainstream use for Linux. dd-wrt is extremely popular. It generally requires somewhere between 2-4MB Flash, and the smallest amount of RAM I saw when going through the supported router list was 8MB. U-Boot is an extremely popular Linux bootloader, that generally runs the mainline ucLinux kernel, which has support for STM32 microcontrollers, where you'll be looking at much, much less RAM. More likely to be measured in kilobytes than megabytes. It could be argued this isn't complete enough to be called a distribution. > And a i686 class CPU is needed. Not at all. Debian, Ubuntu, Gentoo, Arch, all have ARM based versions, before you go diving into what else they support. (Keep reading if you meant the kind of x86) And whilst some have dropped the 486 (Debian even dropped the 586 in 2016 [3]), Gentoo still supports it if you follow along with the mostly manual installation guide. (Though this [0] spells it out in a much easier way.) However, running Linux on a 386 is difficult and unsupported (the kernel dropped support in 2012 [2]), NetBSD still actively maintains a port. [1] As to the 286... Linux never supported it as far as I know. So the upshot is, if you have a 386, 486, or 586 you can still run Gentoo. [0] https://github.com/yeokm1/gentoo-on-486/ https://github.com/yeokm1/gentoo-on-486/ [1] https://wiki.netbsd.org/ports/i386/ https://wiki.netbsd.org/ports/i386/ [2] https://www.pcworld.com/article/2020196/linux-3-8-will-drop-support-for-intel-386-chips.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/2020196/linux-3-8-will-drop-... [3] https://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=showheadline&story=406 https://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=showheadline&stor...
- Zardoz84 7y agoYou can using uLinux . It too small, that you can get a working X11 desktop using a few floppies
- fps_doug 7y agoTried installing Debian 8 or 9 with 128MB a while ago. The installer warned that this wouldn't be enough to finish setup, and sure enough, during installation the OOM killer got in the way. I restarted the installer, spawned a shell and killed some processes that looked non-essential, and this time I managed to finish. Using the actual system was obviously slow given two 233MHz CPUs, but even X11 with i3 worked. I then used it as a secondary screen via VNC. For about an hour. Then I shoved the machine back into the basement.
- peterburkimsher 7y agoTangentially related, it's possible to boot Windows 95 in a browser. https://www.pcjs.org/ https://www.pcjs.org/ I'd also like to ask about single-board computers that can run some version of Windows. I'm quite a fan of the Raspberry Pi, but there are times when I'd like to use software that only supports Windows XP or newer, and WINE doesn't cut it (e.g. iTunes with iPhone drivers, Age of Empires 2, PowerPoint).
- mschuster91 7y agoThere are tiny x86 PCs or Compute-on-Module (Comexpress) available if you are willing to design a carrier board.
- jodrellblank 7y agoThere is https://www.lattepanda.com/products/3.html https://www.lattepanda.com/products/3.html as a single board Win 10 computer, but the Amazon UK reviews are 1 glowing and 3 broken hardware and bad support, so YMMV.
- berbec 7y agoCheck out https://up-shop.org/ https://up-shop.org/ - they sell Intel SBCs. I have a Up Core (quad-core, 4GB ram, 64GB eMMC) running Windows Server 2019.
- shakna 7y ago> I'd also like to ask about single-board computers that can run some version of Windows. I'm quite a fan of the Raspberry Pi I believe the Raspberry Pi 2 and later all support "Windows 10 IoT" now [0][1], but if memory serves IoT has a lot of limitations. It might be simpler to have a minimal distro that boots directly into something like QEMU, that should let you run Windows XP on the Pi. [0] https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/windows-10-for-iot/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/windows-10-for-iot/ [1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot-core/tutorials/rpi https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot-core/tutorials/...
- peterburkimsher 7y ago
- jplayer01 7y agoSo, out of curiosity, what’s the fastest PC that will still work on 95, 98, XP respectively? I recently tried installing XP on my desktop and, despite it being old enough to still be compatible and have drivers available, I wasn’t able to ever get it installed. I’m still trying to figure it out. I certainly don’t remember it being this difficult the last time I tried it... (before 2010?)
- Splognosticus 7y agoIt's not Windows 95, but a while back LGR did try installing MS-DOS 6.22[1] on a modern gaming PC. Things got weird basically immediately but it did more or less work. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bS9hiSwL1KY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bS9hiSwL1KY
- jplayer01 7y agoThat was a great video, thanks. He apparently also did a Win XP video, where he put together his dream PC https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XTnL4Mang0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XTnL4Mang0
- Splognosticus 7y agoAh yeah he's got a fair few of that kind of video--basically one from each major era of PCs all the way back to the original XT. His whole channel is great. He's so enthusiastic about all of this retro hardware and software. Even though I've seen most of them a few times at least it's still my go-to for relaxing YouTube binges.
- DrStalker 7y agoIf he can get DOS installed and CDROM drivers working he should be able to install at least windows 95a. Windows 95b preferred to use its own drivers (or drivers loaded from a floppy disk) for such things, but the early versions felt more like a GUI running on top of DOS.
- nordsieck 7y ago
- EvanAnderson 7y agoSadly, the Am5x86 doesn't support the CMPXCHG8B instruction, so there's no chance of getting XP running on that processor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Jnr 7y agoI used to run Windows XP SP2 on Pentium 2, 128MB RAM, 1GB HDD. I had to remove and disable a lot of stuff to be able to run Skype and Firefox on it.
- noname120 7y agoWindows XP is probably the Microsoft operating system that has had the most community tweaks. For example, there is a stripped down version called MicroXP. Once installed, it only uses 200 MB (!) of disk space and 39 MB (!!) of RAM. It's fully functional, boots in a few seconds, and it feels extremely fast in my experience even on very low-end computers. I have fond memories of this stripped down OS. When I was still a teenager I didn't have unrestricted access to a computer so I salvaged one with 512 MB of memory. The normal version of Windows XP didn't run well on this computer but MicroXP worked like a charm! If you're interested, the official site is down[1] but you can still take a look at the README file[2], and you can find the ISO very easily using the MD5 from the README. [1] http://retestrak.nl/board/ http://retestrak.nl/board/ [2] https://microxp-readme.neocities.org/ https://microxp-readme.neocities.org/