3 ms·
Why is it illegal to offer different prices for the same service (as this article says)?
by rmc 16y ago
Why is it illegal to offer different prices for the same service (as this article says)?
- paraschopra 16y agoRead this: "PRICE DISCRIMINATION AND THE LAW" http://www.imakenews.com/strategicpricing/e_article000649775.cfm?x=b11,0,w http://www.imakenews.com/strategicpricing/e_article000649775...
- jat850 16y agoThe article you linked specifies that the statute in question only applies to goods, not services. Is that applicable here?
- paraschopra 16y agoI am not a lawyer but I think it should apply to digital products. Perhaps not consultancy services, if you are offering a product, it should apply.
- gregpilling 16y agoTo quote the article you linked to : "This complex, Depression-era legislation was enacted to protect small businesses by outlawing discriminatory price and promotional allowances obtained by large businesses. As is the case with the other antitrust laws, the Department of Justice, the FTC, and private parties may each bring Robinson-Patman cases, although the enforcement agencies have not focused on this area for some time. Indeed, the Justice Department has criminal powers in this area that have gone unused for many years, while the FTC today brings few significant cases in this area after being particularly active through the 1970s. Private suits on behalf of businesses (consumers have no standing to sue under the statute) account for most of the enforcement activity. Successful plaintiffs are entitled to the same remedies as those available under the antitrust laws (e.g injunctions, treble damages, attorneys’ fees and costs)." The article lists the very specific reasons a case may be brought, and the various defenses. I do not see how any of this is relevant to your argument that "charging different prices is illegal". I do however agree with your concept that you should try out different prices strategies. I have been amazed in my own experience when I make a package of my products priced beyond any shade of reason (from my view, as seller) and someone goes ahead and buys it. I had a manufacturing company and the 'big' package was to buy $1200 worth of goods and it was sometimes a tough sale. We tried a new 'big' package that was priced a little over $10,000 and it was an easier sale (to bigger customers). Lesson learned - don't ever think you know what the limits are until you test them. You might think that nobody would ever pay $100 per month for your widget, when some division of a Fortune 500 company would happily pay you a $1000 per month. Try it, you may be surprised.
- btilly 16y agoIt refers to the Robinson-Patman act, about which you can find more information at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson%E2%80%93Patman_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson%E2%80%93Patman_Act including a link to the relevant statute at http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/15/13.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/15/13.html. My non-lawyerly reading says that you only need to worry if you're shipping physical goods for resale. And even then you have room to be OK as long as the price differences aren't creating a monopoly, and aren't enough to economically injure the people who receive a higher price.
- mckoss 16y agoNote that selling a product below its cost is required to break the law (aka "dumping"). I would assume this means below its "marginal" cost; which, for digital goods, is nearly zero.
- rmc 16y agoInteresting. That applies to USA. Is there any EU law on the matter?
- gregpilling 16y agoIt is not illegal to offer different prices. Case in point - a lowly 12 oz of Budweiser. If I buy it in a keg it costs me around 50 cents (USD)each. In the bottle it would be closer to $1. At a local bar that has good beer prices and good food it is $3.00 for draft normally, except on Thursdays it is $2 (Bisonwitches, Tucson AZ). If I go to a fancy restaurant it will likely be $4 or even as high as $6. In a free market you are free to charge what you want. Consumers are free not to purchase your item. Rules do vary around the world, so check with your local authorities. I am looking at this from a North American perspective.
- podperson 16y agoAh so it's OK to charge people you don't like (wrong skin color say) more because it's a free market? There's a difference between giving bulk discounts and selling the same product for different prices to different customers.
- gregpilling 16y agoNo, it is not legal to charge people a different price if their skin is purple instead of blue. In the OP example, he is talking about web delivered services where it would be difficult to determine someones skin color anyway. In my example the price of budweiser varies by location and circumstance, not by the color of the purchasers skin.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's not price discrimination, that's discrimination, period, this article has nothing to do with that kind of discrimination so I don't understand why you're pulling it in. And that is illegal anyway, as well it should be. Selling the same product at different price points is done all the time (bulk discounts, account discounts and so on). The issue here is not whether it is legal to sell the same product at different prices, the issue is whether or not it is legal to offer the same product to the same class of buyers at different prices at the same time. And that is legal, even if not always in the best interest of the business: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination I've done it, briefly, to test different price points and I made sure to refund those we tested at a higher level after the experiment was over.
- spot 16y agohttp://definitions.uslegal.com/p/price-discrimination/ http://definitions.uslegal.com/p/price-discrimination/ this doesn't address this case directly, but it seems to say it's only illegal if done to harm your competitors.