3 ms·
This is not parenting advice. He's just talking about his life experiences and his point of view, a thing he seems to do a lot. And he's rich and famous enough
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
This is not parenting advice. He's just talking about his life experiences and his point of view, a thing he seems to do a lot. And he's rich and famous enough that people will read it.
I'm on my third parenting blog. I was a full-time wife and mom for a lot of years. I've really struggled to get any traction with anything I've done.
I think I have really excellent credentials. I homeschooled. I was Director of Community Life for The TAG Project for a time, which was pro bono professional work for a voluntary health and welfare organization dealing with the educational, emotional and social needs of gifted kids.
But that doesn't really translate to a resume, so to speak. I get a lot of flak for trying to say "I know something useful and I have special credentials." People mostly think I am making that up.
We look to famous actors and the like for stuff like parenting advice in part because we have some sense of knowing them and being able to trust what they say. Maybe someday I can address the "parenting information" space better than Sivers, but it takes more than just being a good parent to do that.
You also need to know how to write extremely well, navigate protecting family privacy while sharing inherently private stories and cultivate an audience. There may be more to it than that, but that's a plenty tall order to begin with right there.
If people think it is awful that some rich guy who can afford to spend a lot of time with his kid is talking about that, then maybe go spend time on parenting blogs written by full-time moms or people with less vaunted financial circumstances.
Of course, one of the problems is that people working 9-5 who have children probably can't manage to turn out a quality blog while doing all that. Good writing takes time and effort.
There is no perfect solution here. I was trying to develop a parenting blog when my kids were still minors and people on email lists were interested in what I had to say and I didn't know how to deal with a lot of the pieces of that. I couldn't monetize it effectively or get much in the way of traffic, etc.
So when I got divorced, no, my blogs didn't support me. I got a corporate job instead and continued to fail as a blog writer. I got some success as a blogger while homeless.
This is partly me -- I didn't know what I was doing -- and partly the world. The world didn't really want to help me succeed.
If you want a certain kind of information to exist, then be a good audience. Go give attention, feedback and financial support to people doing that kind of writing. Help them develop their craft.
Sivers is so rich, he can afford to not really care what anyone thinks about him anymore. And he isn't giving parenting advice per se here.
- watwut 7y ago> If people think it is awful that some rich guy who can afford to spend a lot of time with his kid is talking about that, then maybe go spend time on parenting blogs written by full-time moms or people with less vaunted financial circumstances. Right. It is quite similar, isn't it? In more then one way, that is exactly what he does and thinks about. None of what he write about is super exceptional. It is also about him and about what we should do, not about us, he is not telling us that we must do it his way. But also, I guess there is some gender equality in angry responses from people who are not in that situation. He is getting the same "shut up don't talk about what you do" and bad faith reading that chilesspeople and working fathers react with at mommy discussion forums (in my personal experience - moms with one exception either ignored it or read it, but did not seemed to be offended by its existence as much nor as consistently).
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWhen I was growing up, my dad often asked "What's in the fridge?" My mother always got aggravated about that and would tell him he could look in the fridge as well as she could. I grew up and was a full-time wife and mom for a long time. I always knew what was in the fridge. My husband and sons would ask me "What's in the fridge?" It looked like crappy gendered behavior. I got divorced and got a corporate job and got my sons to take over "the women's work." Once I stopped doing all the grocery shopping and cooking and my son took it over, I began asking him "What's in the fridge?" As a general rule of thumb, people usually aren't giving an intentionally bad faith reading. They are just talking about how it looks to them from their position in life. Humans tend to suffer tunnel vision, in some sense. It can be very challenging to get outside ourselves and take on a broader perspective. This is compounded by the fact that most people are raised with either a shame model or guilt model, so they are quick to feel accused, even if that's not what's happening.
- watwut 7y agoI have collegues who use the name of this forum as nickname for stupid in causual discussion "I read it on <name>" is their expression for "stupid". They never read it, don't have kids. They "just know" it is bad. Trust me, what I am referring to is bad faith reading. Reactions completely disproportionate to content, very apparently hostile reactions from people who did not read it, looking for reasons to mock. Reading attention seeking (or external validation) in literally everything. Treating mild disagreement between members as something horrible (no insults or personal attacks, literally just disagreement). Side note: I never start these discussions, for some reason people actively used that as conversation starters. Along with dumb supposed funny remarks about women. I know how to stop it now, but it was puzzling and frustrating and shocking after I came back to work. Why are you conversation starting by insulting people like me? The most apparent public hostility was when said forum was looking for programmer. The Facebook thread under it had people who were neither programmers nor moms talking about supposed super crazy women there. Like "take this job and you will be working for oversensitive anti vaccines crazies". Meanwhile actual forums were like any other and prevalent sentiment was not anti-vacine at all. It wasn't even big topic, trading used baby cloth, craft, cooking and child raising issues were dominant topics. And meanwhile ani vaccine male collegues gets no pushback whatsoever nor is ever used as example of anti vacine person. Does not fit profile I guess.