4 ms·
Are you saying that economists should not study subjects that can have negative consequences for some? The fact that productivity increases in big cities is no
by nabla9 7y ago
Are you saying that economists should not study subjects that can have negative consequences for some?
The fact that productivity increases in big cities is not new finding. Economies of agglomeration is well studied subject. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration
This study is modelling just one of the reasons why it is so little better.
- rarecoil 7y agoAgree. This paper is just another attempt at modelling economies of agglomeration. It's a pretty well-studied bit of urban economics. This paper just sounds a little socially tone-deaf. The paper's primary policy points appear to be, using quotes from the paper: 1) CNR workers work better in "cognitive hubs" that specialise in this type of work. 2) "The main culprit of spatial misallocation is the existence of large occupation-specific externalities combined with potential distortions due to land use regulations." 3) Small towns are misguided in trying to lure "tech" to their cities, and should instead find a non-CNR industry to concentrate on that is not already concentrated in a specific city. ("the economics of the problem suggest that, with the appropriate transfers, small industrial cities in the U.S. should attract non-CNR workers and not try to become the next San Jose. The concentration of CNR workers in a few “cognitive hubs” should be encouraged, not scorned.") 4) CNR cities should be subsidizing non-CNR workers outside of the hub, at a UBI (wealth transfer) to non-CNR workers of about $17,000 a year per worker. ("CNR workers, who earn substantially more, end up paying a base transfer of $16,856. One interpretation of this base transfer is that of a 'universal basic income' paid to all non-CNR workers.") We can distill this further, to: a. In general, CNR workers work better around other CNR workers due to positive externalities of location. I think this is tough to deny, with SF/the Valley for tech, NYC for finance, LA for entertainment, Shenzhen for hardware manufacturing, et cetera. b. We should be removing any restrictions that stop this cycle from growing, from land use regulations, to stopping incentives and funding to small towns to create their own 'tech hubs', to just straight paying people to leave the city that are not part of that industry and stay out. It's the latter part of this everyone seems to be latching onto, however it's pretty common in economics to just model incentives as direct quantifiable costs. This also explains what is happening in the Bay Area right now: "Otherwise, cognitive hubs might use other indirect means of pushing out non-CNR workers such as, for example, housing supply constraints, zoning restrictions, or a lack of investment in transportation networks to aid commuting. Such efforts can generate occupational polarization across space without Pareto gains for all workers."
- jacquesm 7y agoThis is the exact kind of thinking that got you Trump. Keep in mind that by the time 'some' amounts to a substantial part of the voting public that the disenfranchised can turn around and throw a spanner in the works. It would be socially much more productive to study how to re-balance society in such a way that the gains are not realized locally. Think of it this way (very much simplified): If cities A and B create are producing 10 units of value each and small towns C, D, E and F are producing 3 each and you relocate all the 'important' (again, simplifying) people to A and B so they produce 20 units of value each while the small towns drop to 1 each you've according to the paper optimized and reduced the waste. After all 43 > 29. But from society's view this is a net loss. It would be much better to see how the small towns go from 3 to 5 each in order to reduce the gap. Of course this is super simplified and in the end wealth distribution is a complex subject but this paper strikes out for me.
- nabla9 7y agoInequality is separate issue. Inequality is best addressed by free healthcare, education and direct money transfers, not by slowing down things that create wealth and increase efficiencies.
- jacquesm 7y agoNonsense. Inequality is best addressed by ensuring resources are spread equally so that chance is distributed equally. If you don't do that then you're simply locking in and further accelerating any advantage already there. That's a positive feedback loop which will eventually lead to vast inequality that no amount of free healthcare, education and money are going to solve.
- cousin_it 7y agoPaul Graham, who started this website, wrote: "Eliminating great variations in wealth would mean eliminating startups. And that doesn't seem a wise move." How would you respond to that?
- 7y ago