4 ms·
I got the impression that it was impossible to opt out. The only solution offered was to ask the ex-client - a third party - to change the settings. That is not
by eesmith 7y ago
I got the impression that it was impossible to opt out. The only solution offered was to ask the ex-client - a third party - to change the settings. That is not opting out.
- throwaway73629 7y agoIf it went to court, I’m not sure what the court would decide. The solution offered was indeed to ask the ex-client to change the settings. The GDPR requires that those controlling personal data must offer a way opting out. What I’m not sure about is whether Heroku would be seen as legally controlling the personal data. Perhaps the ex-client is the one who has this control and who must offer an opt out. It would be interesting to know if any similar cases have already been judged.
- eesmith 7y agoHmmm. I see your point. I don't know if Heroku is the data processor or controller in this case, but I think it's the data processor. Let's suppose the ex-client is the data controller. The first thing is to tell the ex-client to change the settings, which doesn't seem to have been the case here. If the ex-client does not change the settings (eg, perhaps from incompetence), and Heroku know about the issue, then are they obligated as a data processor to inform the ex-client that there is an GDPR violation? That's my reading of the last part of 28.3 GDPR. And if that violation continues? ... I have no clue. No idea either of if this relationship is covered under GDPR.