4 ms·
What was the ethical reason for the taxi medallion system? All it did was create an artificial shortage and a few people got rich buying medallions and the actu
by scarface74 7y ago
What was the ethical reason for the taxi medallion system? All it did was create an artificial shortage and a few people got rich buying medallions and the actual taxi drivers were just as shortchanged by the owners of the medallion as they are by Uber and it was a worse customer experience.
- icebraining 7y agoThe ethical reason was to reduce congestion. Whether that's the real intention and, if it was, whether it was accomplishing that goal is arguable, of course.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIncreasing the price of using a vehicle in the congested region would have been the ethical way to reduce congestion, not making a market controlled by government officials that they could collect rent on.
- akvadrako 7y agoI think it mainly served the purpose of making cabs in demand, so private owners of cabs could make a living wage.
- niij 7y agoIt reduced supply, not increase demand.
- jl2718 7y agoWell there are certainly other motivations for, or effects of laws, and by that measure they may be unjust, and it may even be ethical to break them. However, to create a monopoly on breaking a law seems similar to creating a law to create a monopoly, so it shouldn't be surprising that we've observed both by the same actors. Case-in-point: there were many other rideshare companies shut down before the duopoly emerged, and many afterward that will never get started because of regulations that they sponsored.