3 ms·
Okay, this is something that I was thinking about: Are megabytes and seconds really a good indicator for UX quality of a website? Youtube is amazing, it starts
by mrtksn 7y ago
Okay, this is something that I was thinking about: Are megabytes and seconds really a good indicator for UX quality of a website?
Youtube is amazing, it starts playing the video before even the video title is rendered or any other part of the page is loaded. Who cares if it downloads who knows how many megabytes of JS or HTML before the DOM is ready?
On the other hand, after clicking on a tweet link Twitter would show me multiple loading indicator, load the main page then show me some more loading indicator and then show me the tweet text and after a while, I can see the images attached to the tweet. It is often the same for any other "Web App".
On Apple's case, the page actually becomes usable almost instantly. The page would first show me the title on the black background and then the airpods photo would fade in from the darkness and I would be able to scroll immediately. I would say, the experience is closer to Youtube than Twitter.
- detaro 7y ago> Who cares if it downloads who knows how many megabytes of JS or HTML before the DOM is ready? People with limited data caps. If it really did download 60 MB on my phone (it seems like it's somewhat adaptive, so it's quite likely Apple's web designers paid attention and it wouldn't), that'd be 2 % of my monthly data cap, for what's effectively a product page.
- mrtksn 7y agoFair enough but I think you can also appreciate that Apple's job here is to create the best user experience here for the potential buyer. It's not really a website that you have to visit or your children will starve. They probably set the limits to accommodate best the iPhone users who are willing to spend 250$ on a non-essential device that will last about 2 years.
- detaro 7y agoI mean, on desktop it spins up my laptop fans and doesn't even scroll smoothly, so they're clearly somewhat failing at UX. If I pretend-throttle in dev tools it gets better. Then of course I'll probably never buy their product, so my experience isn't that important.
- ambicapter 7y agoThat's weird, b/c I'm on a 2011 macbook pro and it scrolls perfectly smoothly, when there are a LOT of websites on the internet right now where that is not the case (including twitter and facebook).
- jaunkst 7y agoWe have customers in industrial processes that care. Internet is questionable and they are not working overtime for bloated software.
- jammygit 7y agoI was thinking yesterday about how poor the YouTube UX is actually. Just a bunch of personal annoyances, nothing major. The speed and scalability are quite good though