4 ms·
I was with you for your first half. Defaults matter - it's likely this situation was caused by someone who obtained a drone with little effort, and is blissfull
by mindslight 7y ago
I was with you for your first half. Defaults matter - it's likely this situation was caused by someone who obtained a drone with little effort, and is blissfully taking pictures of the fire operations. And then wondering why the helicopters have stopped flying and there's nothing to photograph. Hence the TV ads.
But it's no wonder why many device owners would push back having their devices implanted with inescapable third party controls. The people with enough awareness to do this also likely have a enough awareness to not disrupt emergency air traffic as well!
Generally if someone wants to direct their drone to do illegal things, the common sense assumption is that they're going to make that happen somehow, rather than reacting by trying to bake in technological authoritarianism. It's naive to think that since it's possible to write code to enforce a condition, that this can scale to the level of society!
It could be someone in fire operations themselves that wants to try out using off the shelf technology to improve their operation, but instead stuck budgeting and requisitioning a single "government priced" drone rather self-purchasing a few expendable ones on a lark. Or sure, it could also be some shithead who laughs as they help the fire spread. Despite the amount of hypothetical attention, the latter asshole is extremely rare, and the right way to deal with them is heavy civil and criminal punishment as going around the safety defaults has established their firm intent.
- afiori 7y agoI would actually draw the parallel with cars here; the airspace/roads are similarly regulated and should require a license to use. For sure some uses can be less regulated than other (like bicycles or kites), but drones have demonstrated to be clearly more complex. I realize that we should not be rushed in disturbing a blooming industry and I have a lot of respect for the progress made in recent years, but as things stand in my (uninformed) opinion something akin to license plate registration/piloting license is the best long term choice to protect good actors.
- mindslight 7y agoBroadcasting an identity would indeed be a good way to do post-facto enforcement instead of resorting to technological authoritarianism. However, it's worth remembering that car license plates have become a major surveillance vector in the modern age. It would be straightforward to fix this - imagine RF or eink transponders with a number that changes every minute, with a cryptographic key required to tie the broadcasted nym to anything else, and a public audit trail every time it is done - but government inertia is huge. This regime should really be fixed before it is expanded.
- Faark 7y agoLoosing all benefit for other citizens while just mildly annoying those in power by putting pretend barriers in place? No, thanks. I'd really like to know who owns those 4-5 scrap bicycles standing around near my home, so they can be removed and spots made available. For drones I feel similar... determining the owner of something close by should be possible without going through police.
- afiori 7y agoAs a matter of fact I do not feel it is a good idea to tie civil and/or criminal topics to cryptographic technologies (this does not exclude voting, but that is a completely different discussion). Essentially you are asking to legislate a IoT frameworks that is resilient enough to be used in courts or law.
- reaperducer 7y agoIt could be someone in fire operations themselves that wants to try out using off the shelf technology to improve their operation It's a conflagration. The people in fire operations have better things to do than play with toy "drones." They also know better than to fly in areas where water is being deployed. It's naive to think that since it's possible to write code to enforce a condition, that this can scale to the level of society! We can control technology a lot easier than we can control people.
- mindslight 7y ago> The people in fire operations have better things to do than play with toy "drones." That's a strong assertion, given all of the information one can imagine obtaining about the fire. I don't know the current state of practice, but it seems like even individual ground crews would benefit from cheap overhead views.
- Animats 7y agoThey might, and it would be up to the incident commander, who's also aware of water tanker flights, to allow it or not. Firefighting operations have command and control. They have to.
- mindslight 7y agoDuh, I don't know how that wasn't implicit in what I said. Are people really reading my comment thinking I'm advocating that bystanders go fly drones into fires, tweet the pictures, and congratulate themselves for helping the firefighting effort? If it's not clear, don't do that. I was just pointing out the firefighters, you know the people using their sweat, intellect, and long term health to control the fires, just might themselves cook up some use for consumer drones. For which they would then have to convince their commanders, one of the objections being price, and so giving drone manufacturers an excuse to implement market segmentation would hinder them.