14 ms·
Last year I got a chance to ride in an autonomous vehicle by a Waymo competitor in San Francisco, in and around Market Street. It handled every situation as we
by jedberg 7y ago
Last year I got a chance to ride in an autonomous vehicle by a Waymo competitor in San Francisco, in and around Market Street.
It handled every situation as well as or better than a human would, including trash bags in the road, a truck driving the wrong way down a one way street, and numerous unpredictable pedestrians.
It was that day that I was convinced that we would have driverless tech by 2020, and the only thing that would stop it would be laws and regulations.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoSo, it's now November of 2019, and it seems unlikely that driverless cars will be ubiquitous or even an available option by 2020. If you could go back and change some laws and regulations, which ones would you have fixed to hit the 2020 prediction?
- jedberg 7y agoThis article make it sounds like I was right. The author just took a ride in a driverless car. Which is limited to driving in Arizona due to legal restrictions. But to answer your question, we’d need a whole different legal framework about liability for driverless cars instead of technological restrictions. Like for example, the law ~says~ would say “one person must be designated as legally liable for the vehicle” and that’s it. Drive your driverless car on any road you want. If it hits someone, the designated person is liable.
- rory096 7y agoCan you point me to that law? Do 'legal persons' qualify?
- jedberg 7y agoNo I’m saying that is the law I would write. It doesn’t exist.
- Noos 7y agoWhy would anyone buy a car where they can be held liable for the software defects of the manufacturer? The driver has no control over the software and cannot compensate for it. You're blaming them for putting the thing on the road at all, and the end result would be not to bother.
- alonmower 7y agoWhile I personally wouldn’t that doesn’t stop a bunch of people from kicking their feet up and texting as their Model S’s drive them down 280 every morning. They’re already agreeing to the trade off between convenience and liability. I think you underestimate how much some people value the convenience.
- ghaff 7y agoThat some idiots may misuse their vehicle assistive driving system is different from you having to sign an agreement when you purchase your self-driving car in which you agree to hold the manufacturer harmless and accept full responsibility for [long list of things] that may happen during autonomous operation.
- aptwebapps 7y agoI think there's a difference between agreeing to hold the manufacturer harmless for anything that happens and accepting basic liability for purchasing the car and putting it on the road. I guess jedberg's idea is that there needs to be a place for the buck to start, as it were, wherever it might end up. Currently that is the driver. However, I don't see why it couldn't start with the manufacturer. They could always try to shift blame to the owner if they were misusing it somehow or interfering with its correct operation.
- Terretta 7y agoWhy would anyone buy a dog where they can be held liable for the genetic disposition of its parents? The dog has a degree of autonomy or self-agency, and can make decisions that put its owner at legal risk. Someone else brought it into the world, but you, ultimately, made the purchase. You made it yours, the problem’s on you.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe manufacturer of the car/software must be responsible for any accidents is causes. There is no other way.
- jedberg 7y agoWhy? Car manufacturers are usually indemnified when someone uses their car improperly. It’s not so black and white. That’s why we need laws to spell it out.
- BurningFrog 7y agoWith self driving cars, the only entity who "uses" the car is its software. The owner/user isn't in charge of any of its actions, and can therefore not be help responsible for them.
- ar0 7y agoActually the article states that the driverless rides are limited to a subset of the total Waymo test area in Phoenix, which has nothing to do with legal restrictions but with how confident Waymo is in their technology. And, yes, some (maybe a big) part of Waymo being in Phoenix is the regulatory environment, but I bet a lot is also that there is no snow and other challenging weather conditions.
- chibg10 7y agoThe designer of the software should be liable for bugs that cause life and property damages. This makes sense morally, and the costs incurred from damages should be factored into the costs of pricing a driverless car. This protects the consumer from being responsible for damages they have no control over, provides meaningful competitive incentives for driverless car manufacturers to improve safety, and doesn’t hamstring the industry’s development.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoShould the driver not incur some responsibility for putting on the road a car that is known to be worse than a human driver in many situations?
- notatoad 7y ago>seems unlikely that driverless cars will be ubiquitous or even an available option by 2020 this is moving the goalposts. the parent never said it would be ubiquitous, he said "we would have the tech". Waymo is currently offering driverless rides to the public, therefore we have the tech. no, it's not ubiquitous, and there's a lot of caveats, but it exists. driverless cars are a thing.
- aeturnum 7y ago>it exists. driverless cars are a thing. I think what you're saying is true as far as it goes. Also, if you allow cars that can only drive in a limited list of places, we've had driverless cars for 30 years. So do with that what you will. For me, I would say that when anyone can order a self-driving car to go from any point on a road in California to any other point on a road, we're clearly there. One city seems far too small.
- adrr 7y agoWaymo is approved for full driverless in California. They ordered 20,000 Jaguar IPaces with delivery starting in 2020. One thing they don’t have is approval to charge for the taxi service.
- jedberg 7y agoI would be ecstatic to be proven wrong on regulations holding it back. :)
- jfoster 7y agoI think the other thing that can hold it back is time & cost. How quickly can they produce the vehicles? What's the unit cost? What's then the total cost to build a fleet big enough for the parts of the world that are ready for this? Even Alphabet may not want to front up the entirety of the capital that would be required to scale up Waymo around the world. They also currently only have two passenger vehicle models that can be outfitted, so they are currently also limited by how quickly those manufacturers can produce those vehicles for them. How quickly can they add a model? Probably takes at least 6 months.
- Yrs751 7y agoI think it's depend up to 1. Creativity and skill of man power, 2. Tool and facility that support to man power, 3. Capital money. That's all
- xivzgrev 7y agoI think we are still a ways from scaling. There is still a real risk of catastrophic failure as they get more real world experience. I think it is going to be quite measured, continuing to slowly roll out to actual people over next 5-10 years.
- rorykoehler 7y agoWaymo is potentially the world most valuable company some time in the not too distant future (before the commercial space industry really takes off). I doubt they will hesitate to scale once the time comes.