3 ms·
For every person who enjoys the extra hour of sun in the summer, there's a person who detests an extra hour of darkness in the morning in winter. And I'll also
by BeetleB 7y ago
For every person who enjoys the extra hour of sun in the summer, there's a person who detests an extra hour of darkness in the morning in winter.
And I'll also find you one who doesn't like late sunsets. Some people do not eat dinner prior to sunset.
Living in northern climates, we have the sun setting at 9pm in summer. No one here is going to be impacted if it sets at 8pm.
Personally, the only people I know who like permanent daylight time are those who live in a system where the clock changes. I've lived in and interacted with people in countries where they have permanent standard time, and they never expressed a desire to switch their clocks by one hour permanently. I think those who advocate permanent daylight time are the ones seeking an unnatural solution.
Let's simply acknowledge that everyone has a preference, and there's no objective winner here. Switching to permanent daylight means your location will be out of whack with the concept of time zones. Most of the world either switches their clock or has permanent standard time. Having your locale be permanent daylight will make for really weird global time zone maps, and will break the notion of "if you travel east beyond a certain point, the time zone will shift by one hour."
- ralph84 7y agoGlobal time zone maps are already really weird. There are plenty of places where traveling east doesn’t change the time zone for thousands of miles, or changes it by something other than one hour.
- baq 7y agoLiving in the EU I can say that the opinion of most people is: stop this madness but if possible align with neighbor countries and perhaps prefer a bit more sun after work, in this order.
- pmontra 7y agoAFAIK France decided to keep permanent DST from 2021. I hope my country (Italy) does the same. We don't center our day around 12:00, it's more like 13:00 or later.
- _ph_ 7y agoWhich would be odd, if true (haven't heard anything like that from my French colleagues). As France is in the same time zone as Germany, even outside of DST, it is basically in a zone of permanent DST. When in DST, it is shifted 2 hours versus the sun position. Actually the true noon for the non-DST middle European time zone is at the eastern border of Germany. So whole Germany and France are "ahead" of the time even without DST.
- thr0w__4w4y 7y ago> "there's no objective winner here" To a large degree I agree with what you're saying (you know what they say about opinions), but the last couple years I've put a lot more effort into improving my sleep habits after reading Matthew Walker's book "Why We Sleep". Tons of science and data-driven conclusions. But what I found incredible, there are studies to back this up, is that in spring, when we "lose" an hour of sleep, the next day after changing the clocks, heart attacks increase by about 24%.[0] Of course on the flip side, apparently there is a ~21% reduction in heart attacks when we set the clocks back in the fall, so maybe it's a wash. Suicide rates also jump in spring on the day immediately after the clocks have been pushed forward. [0] https://www.sciencealert.com/daylight-savings-time-change-kills-people https://www.sciencealert.com/daylight-savings-time-change-ki...