4 ms·
Why don't these pipelines run in wider-pipes, which are typically unused, so that spillage from the inner pipe doesn't immediately leek into the soil? Or some o
by einpoklum 7y ago
Why don't these pipelines run in wider-pipes, which are typically unused, so that spillage from the inner pipe doesn't immediately leek into the soil? Or some other technical solution?
(Yes, I know the answer: It would cost more and oil execs and investors never go to jail for polluting.)
- sandworm101 7y agoThat would be very hard to engineer. (1)Pipes change size with heat. Getting the external empty pipe to reliably keep position over the smaller pipe would be tricky. (2) pipe inspections have to happen. In burried sections this may be a non-issue but wrapping all the valves and above-ground facilities in layers would make inspection problematic. (3) the volume and speed of material in pipes is immense. The void space between pipe layers would have to run continuously for the length of the pipe. Any blockage or constriction would produce a water hammer effect, turning one leak into many. A cracked pipe is bad, but a double-layered pipe exploding because of a crack miles upstream is horrible. What fills this void space? Air? Air plus hydrocarbon in an enclosed/hot environment?
- blattimwind 7y ago> (1)Pipes change size with heat. Getting the external empty pipe to reliably keep position over the smaller pipe would be tricky. It's not like this space has to be particularly small. Double walled pipes are relatively common in many forms. Long-distance heating uses double walled stainless steel piping with insulation between the walls. HV systems sometimes use double walled conduits to have a second layer for the insulating gas (e.g. SF6) in case the inner layer leaks. Double walled pipes are used for lines containing especially hazardous materials. The inter-wall space is often monitored for ingress of "stuff", triggering a controlled shutdown if it is flooded. > In burried sections this may be a non-issue but wrapping all the valves and above-ground facilities in layers would make inspection problematic. This is about risk mitigation, so total mitigation is not required. Protecting, say, 80-90 % of a pipeline would reduce spill risk a lot. Also, the facilities you mention may be suitable to other forms of mitigation (e.g. walls, flood basins). > That would be very hard to engineer. I don't think engineering is the real problem here. Cost and incentives are.
- yostrovs 7y agoCost is at play in everything. Ignoring it for the sake of discussion does nothing. Do compare they price of single wall stove pipe to double wall chimney pipe. Almost an order of magnitude difference.
- falcolas 7y agoAnd yet all oil tankers have to be double hulled, for the exact same reasons. Why not pipes?
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoYes, there are such tight margins in oil extraction the majors barely stay in business. Little wonder they have to cut corners on safety for the sake of a few extra dollars.
- einpoklum 7y agoIf there is a need for oil, enough to merit extracting it with costly means and transporting it over thousands of miles, then surely there's a willingness to pay some more for it.
- mindslight 7y agoCost is at play in everything. If one could perfectly account for the expected costs of a true cleanup, then whether to use double walled pipe would be a boring actuarial decision. The problem is that we don't perceive the oil companies as ending up responsible for the damage they cause, due to government inaction and corruption.
- johnwalkr 7y agoIt’s not very hard to engineer. I used to design underground piping for locomotive fueling. In Nothern Canada where temperature differential is significant. In that case double walled piping is used and the temperature may vary greatly between the outer wall (ground temperature) and the inner wall (outside temperature due to fluid stored in an above ground tank). They are fixed together in some places, and able to slide relative to each other in most places. Fixed points are located in the middle of straight sections and there are C-shaped “expansion loops” that allow the inner pipe to expand or contract relative to the outer pipe. The outer pipe has a vacuum applied by a vacuum pump, and a greater than nominal vacuum leak indicates an issue. Of course, it’s expensive compared to a single pipe.
- einpoklum 7y agoYour post makes me hopeful that this could be possible with some political pressure by public protests. Although - we should never underestimate the power of dark side^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H oil and gas lobby.
- layoutIfNeeded 7y agoWhat does ^H^H^H^H^H mean?
- d33 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backspace#^H https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backspace#^H
- w1 7y agoThey used to do this, before modern coating techniques. The issue is that if any moisture gets inside that annulus (which will happen eventually), you get corrosion. It's also then very hard to inspect the integrity of that inner pipe with traditional techniques, like guided ultrasonics.
- einpoklum 7y agoAnnulus is the outer pipe, right? Well, inspect it infrequently, but not infrequently enough for the corrosion to cause a spill out of the outer (wider) pipe. But actually, scratch that. We're in the modern era now. Send a drone into the outer pipe, and use some sensors (perhaps also video) to detect excessive moisture, or corrosion, or whatever. So it's no longer expensive.
- w1 7y agoAnnulus is the space between the outer and inner pipe. Most new pipelines are inspected currently with "drones", called smart pipeline inspection gauges, or smart PIGs, that use ultrasonic or magnetic flux to measure the wall thickness over the entire length of the pipe [1]. The PIGs are propelled through the pipe via the working fluid in the pipeline. I think creating a similar device to travel in the annulus of cased pipe would be much more difficult. The centralizers used to keep the inner pipe centered in the outer pipe would pose a pretty big obstacle. Plus, there would be nothing propelling it forward, and communicating with the device through a steel pipe would be very difficult. [1] https://primis.phmsa.dot.gov/comm/FactSheets/FSSmartPig.htm?nocache=1315 https://primis.phmsa.dot.gov/comm/FactSheets/FSSmartPig.htm?... [2] https://kwikzip.com/ https://kwikzip.com/ (example)
- phonethrowaway 7y agoThis technique is already used for fuel piping and storage tanks. The area between the double-walled pipes is called an interstice, and that's how leaks are detected. Additionally the interstice drains to a containment sump, so if any liquid is present, the leak is obvious, but there are sensors there too. Fuel is more corrosive than crude oil. However the sludge in crude can cause pitting corrosion over time. These systems are built such that corrosion and leaks are expected and inevitable. Gas stations and places like data centers, or anywhere with fuel storage or dispensers must be inspected monthly for this reason. Source: I work for an environmental compliance company, and built software to model and report on these types of fuel storage, transport, and dispensing systems.