3 ms·
It would be great if a bunch of libraries pooled their single copies, split the files apart into individual pages, and wrote an app that allowed members to auto
by mindslight 7y ago
It would be great if a bunch of libraries pooled their single copies, split the files apart into individual pages, and wrote an app that allowed members to automatically check out one page at a time as they read.
Of course the real answer is sci-hub and the like. Libraries have always fought the good fight for public access to information (threatening signs by the xerox [sic] machines notwithstanding), but they're chained to playing by the rules of an obsolete copyright system that gets continually worse. They will only be able to truly re-focus after larger society moves to Free copying, such that basic access is taken for granted.
- smnrchrds 7y agoThe big problem with the e-books is that they are not sold, they are licensed. I would be very surprised if the license allows the libraries to do what you suggest. In general, with licenses, the licensee is given as few rights as possible and all other rights are reserved for the licensor.
- mindslight 7y agoTrue true. That's a large part of what makes the copyright regime steadily worse. Though I've got to wonder about buying paperbacks and self digitizing. Google did a decent job destroying much of that angle, but I would think there could be a little opening left if you destroyed the originals such that you were completely format shifting. Then the same idea of one viewer at a time could be applied, with the system moving the work between devices rather than copying. If you lost your device with checked out pages on it, you'd get a library fine... You'd probably still get hit with an eventual legal kneecapping, but it's fun to think about.
- gnicholas 7y agoAlso, one company (overdrive, a rakuten subsidiary) controls Ofer 90% of the US ebook lending market. This makes innovation in the space even less likely.
- carlob 7y agoWhich is why I refuse to buy ebooks while they are at the same price as paper books. Unless publisher get their act together I will keep buying a hard copy and then pirating the ebook. I think this should be a right just like ripping CDs.
- kranner 7y agoIf it's just about being able to keep your copy forever, you could buy the ebook and strip DRM. How does ebook price vs hardcopy price matter here?
- pritambaral 7y ago> strip DRM As your parent says, they're already pirating the e-book. The difference is in how it appears to the publisher. If an e-book is bought and then ripped, the publisher doesn't become aware of the latter but they still see an e-book sale. > If it's just about being able to keep your copy forever It's not just about that. It's also about not supporting a sale one is opposed to on principle.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- carlob 7y agoSibling poster replied for me better better than I would have myself. Regarding price I wanted to add that a physical artifact that I can resell or pass down for generations is worth much more than the bits it encodes. I also think we have a somewhat different definition of forever.
- Zanni 7y agoI think it's important to distinguish between scientific papers, which the authors want to make as publicly accessible as possible, and fiction (and non-fiction) books, which the authors are trying to make a living from. There are a lot of issues with current copyright law, but "free copying" isn't a solution that's going to appeal to working writers.
- mindslight 7y agoWhether authors approve or not, that is the reality we're headed towards unless the copyright cartel actually manages to stuff the Internet back in the box.
- ghaff 7y agoIf that’s the case then many authors simply won’t write. Some books are written for reasons that aren’t primarily about royalty checks. But largely eliminate those checks and far fewer books will get written.
- toyg 7y agoHave you seen how many books are published at any given time? Maybe “writing fewer” might not be such a bad outcome after all. (It’s not going to happen, btw. The existence of things like self-publishing and vanity publishers is proof that supply will continue to outstrip demand, probably forever. Economic incentives are fundamentally secondary in this particular activity.)
- scarejunba 7y agoIf I have to choose between paying $15 to read the next Sanderson in a heavy DRM'd Kindle vs reading some random self-published book I think the choice is obvious to me. Not all of those guys are Hugh Howey.
- enriquto 7y ago