6 ms·
> Mashable asked Ring whether the people featured in the videos gave their consent to be used in a publicity stunt. Ring did not immediately respond, and we'll
by godelski 7y ago
> Mashable asked Ring whether the people featured in the videos gave their consent to be used in a publicity stunt. Ring did not immediately respond, and we'll update this story if they do.
That seems like a clear answer...
> "The company is able to do this thanks to a broad terms of service agreement that grants it the perpetual right to use footage shared with it for 'any purpose' it chooses," BuzzFeed wrote.
I always find this odd. Lots of people tell me that they make these TOS to "cover their asses" with the assumption that everyone sues left and right over everything. So do these people realize that that's not exactly what's happening? Do people think of this usage of footage as abuse of the TOS? Because I sure do. I'm not sure how it is really different from copying someone's art and claiming it as your own and (successfully) selling it.
- xmprt 7y agoEven worse, while recording people in public is legal, I think there are specific protections for children under 13 which are the people featured in this Halloween video.
- kd5bjo 7y agoEven for adults, there’s separate restrictions on publishing the video for commercial purposes than for recording it in the first place. I don’t think Ring’s TOS can protect them from claims from the people who aren’t Ring customers themselves. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model_release https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model_release
- DanBC 7y ago> while recording people in public is legal ...in the US. In other places the laws can be different, especially if the camera hasn't been registered.
- ImaCake 7y agoA science outreach job I had (in Australia) took special care to ask for consent for photos for their media page. If no consent forms were received, then they got a fluoro yellow sticker to wear so that photos were not taken. I was told that the reason for this is that some children are hidden from their bio-parents because said parents were bad people. We didn't want to risk the stalkers/bad parents from finding vulnerable children so no photos without a consent form. I think this is the implication that should be considered in this situation and I think this makes Ring either very stupid or very greedy (or both).
- lixtra 7y agoIt could also be completely staged. By keeping the mystery for some time it’s more likely to go viral.
- cryptica 7y agoBut the real reason why it would go viral is because of the underlying data privacy issue. This is not a great long term strategy. I don't know why anyone would want any kind of internet recording device from Amazon in or around their home. Why are people willingly enslaving themselves to corporations? I don't see what the incentive is for people.
- lixtra 7y ago> But the real reason why it would go viral is because of the underlying data privacy issue. This is not a great long term strategy. Many of us would love if it wasn’t a good long term strategy. But fb, google, tinder, uber and others point in the direction that the market doesn’t care.
- mic47 7y agoOr it's just another example of ridiculous journalists expectations: they make inquiry during weekend / Friday evening and expect you to respond immediately. But you know, even people at Ring have lives.... Generally whenever journalist post sensational article, where they clearly didn't give other party enough time to respond, I see it more as an example of shitty journalism, because clearly journalist is more interested in flashy headline and breaking news, than the truth.
- watertom 7y agoGo read the terms for Grammerly. They own the rights to everything you type into a browser that has their plug-in installed. If you types a novel in google docs using a bowser they actually own the rights to that novel. They capture everything that comes into the browser, everything. After having a 2 hour call with Grammerly and their lawyers, it was pretty clear that they believe they own in perpetuity everything you type, bu they look at everything that is sent to the browser. If you work for a healthcare company Or a financial services company Grammerly is seeing all of your data, they think they own it, and can sell it.
- MobileVet 7y agoThis needs more attention... thanks for bringing it up.
- MobileVet 7y agoSo... why did I get downvoted for thanking someone for their post??
- ossworkerrights 7y agoThis should be a post on its own!
- asxd 7y agoI’d be interested to hear more about why this 2 hour call happened, if you’re willing to share.
- brobdingnagians 7y agoNot the OP, but I'm assuming it was due diligence for a company interested in using the product and that read the ToS, then called to clarify. With my current job, I've come to appreciate that there are quite a few large companies that thoroughly read the ToS and take issue with them.
- sinstein 7y agoIs this true? I opened up Grammarly TOS and found this: Ownership All intellectual property rights in and to the User Content are and shall remain your property, and Grammarly shall acquire no right of ownership with respect to your User Content. Link - https://www.grammarly.com/terms#ownership https://www.grammarly.com/terms#ownership
- ThePadawan 7y agoJust to counter your cynicism with my own: I've made the experience that unless they can make profit off you, you threaten to sue them, or take them to the union/board/bureau/cops, no company is ever going to "get back to you immediately".