5 ms·
I remember reading something somewhere about the real issue with risk and playgrounds... that modern playgrounds often hide risk, whereas older playgrounds it w
by cortesoft 7y ago
I remember reading something somewhere about the real issue with risk and playgrounds... that modern playgrounds often hide risk, whereas older playgrounds it would be more obvious. The idea is that there were clearly places (high up, requiring climbing skill) in the old playgrounds that kids would slowly work their way up to conquering. Because the risk was obvious, kids would approach it with caution and build up skills to get there. In contrast, a lot of injuries occur when 'safe' playgrounds have kids try to do things not designed for, but because of the way they are made don't appear to be dangerous bus actually are. Giving kids the ability to assess risk accurately, and develop the skill to take that risk, is the important part.
- jacobolus 7y agoOne of the problems with de-risked playgrounds is that kids crave a certain amount of risk, and if there is nothing to do that seems a bit risky, kids (especially older kids) will start looking for ways to make the playground more exciting, doing things that the playground designers didn’t anticipate and didn’t consider the safety of. My understanding (based on some news article I read a couple years ago; take this with a pinch of salt) is that in practice, the injury rates from de-risked playgrounds are not materially lower than injury rates from older riskier playgrounds. The main difference is that the new playgrounds are less fun.
- siddboots 7y agoI agree with the argument, but I'm skeptical of the claim that "injury rates from de-risked playgrounds are not materially lower". If these playgrounds are more expensive to build and deliver no benefit at all, surely they would have been abandoned long ago.
- mike_hock 7y agolol as if that's how the world works
- greedo 7y agoThey make parents and administrators "feel good." That's a significant benefit, one that drives a lot of purchasing decisions.
- wirrbel 7y agoNot only that. They give them a paper trail that they made safety-focused decisions. That especially applies to administrators.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 7y agoYour faith in the rationality of the world is a bit too strong.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PeterStuer 7y agoThe derisking for the playground owner/exploiter still works regardless.
- atoav 7y agoOf course this is anecdotal evidence, but me and my 3 brothers grew up with a lot of silly or dangerous stuff: climbing on trees, skateboarding, snowboarding, trampolines, jumping down stairs, jumping over ramps with the bike, jumping from cliffs and bridges etc. Our parents would just let us do our stuff. And although we were bruised all the time only one of us broke a bone once. In the same time my friend with over-careful doctors as parents broke arms/legs roughly four times. And other kids with paranoid parents had similar problems. Our parents thought us early on that we need to judge these risks ourselves, while these other kids would be extremely scared of harmless stuff at one point and overconfident in other more dangerous situations.
- nollbit 7y agoPerhaps your friends parents were over-careful because their kids kept breaking bones? Kids are different. Mine is very risk-averse and has essentially never hurt himself bad. I was the same way as a kid. His friends are daredevils who hurt themselves constantly. Also, when it comes to "our parents in the past would let us do anything and I came out ok" sounds a bit like survival bias to me. In Sweden, far fewer kids die today than in the 70s, so perhaps there's some merit to bicycle helmets, safer playgrounds and not letting your kids eats whole grapes unattended before the age of five or so etc.
- watwut 7y agoOr maybe the parents became over paranoid, because their kids where prone to injure themselves and even broke logs multiple times. Maybe the parents were not so much paranoid as reacting to their kids either doing dumber stuff or being more clumsy or having weaker bones.
- voldacar 7y ago> If these playgrounds are more expensive to build and deliver no benefit at all, surely they would have been abandoned long ago. human beings are often not rational
- afarrell 7y ago> If these playgrounds are more expensive to build and deliver no benefit at all, surely they would have been abandoned long ago How does that follow? For something to be abandoned, there needs to be social agreement that it is a bad idea. This is meaningfully different than something being a bad idea.
- Spooky23 7y agoThey do have a benefit — ada compliance. Fun is less important than not getting sued.
- etatoby 7y agoBy "older kids" you mean "moronic young adults," I agree: https://youtu.be/JA7jc4rpTns https://youtu.be/JA7jc4rpTns
- rmwaite 7y agoBut that moronic tendency is pretty much guaranteed based on hormones and emotional development.
- tcbawo 7y agoThere is a park near me with a metal bridge only a couple feet off the ground. There are gaps where children can fit through to climb up/down. Just outside and perpendicular to this particular bridge is a set of metal stairs. I witnessed a toddler fall off the bridge and narrowly miss hitting his head on the metal corner of the stairs. It probably could have killed him. The mother was sufficiently spooked that they immediately left. Everyone is just worried about limiting liability. In this case, smarter positioning of stairs would eliminate some risk. Considering how these sets are so modular, I'm surprised there isn't more oversight about deployment.
- WalterBright 7y agoBack when I was a boy, the local park had an old steam locomotive set up for the kids to play on and around. It was quite popular. Being all iron, angles, and sharp corners, there was nothing safe about it, but I don't recall anyone getting hurt on it.
- jchallis 7y agoDennis the Menace in Monterey? Now the train is fenced off...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m_mueller 7y agoThey still have one in Tokyo, in a playground called Higashi-choufu. My son played there from age 1 to 2.5 when we had to move. It was quite well done with sharp pieces removed from the conductor stand. Children could play there or climb back in the coal wagon and slide down its angled floor. He never hurt himself, but I banged my head a couple of times due to low overhangs...
- magicalhippo 7y agoThe rules we have here in Norway, which is a variation of a EU thing IIRC, allow kids to get hurt, but not permanently. There are a lot of dangers which are non-obvious, especially to a kid. Crevices where the rope for tightening the hood can get stuck, potentially strangling them. Stairs where a kid can get their head through but not their body. Swings where they can lose their fingers thanks to the chain mounts or similar. Lots of similar things. I have a friend who design playgrounds, and he operates on the principle that there's two kinds of safety. It's the objective safety I mention above, and there's the subjective safety which you mention. Kids should have objectively safe playgrounds, but they should be allowed to challenge their subjective safety feeling. The objective safety has mostly to do with the design and maintenance of the equipment. The subjective safety is more due to the design of the playground itself and the elements in it. One example is a climbing wall. With the right layout, sufficient impact sand or rubber on the ground around it as well as proper maintenance, it can be objectively very safe but still allow kids to feel they push their boundaries.
- GuiA 7y agoYour comment made me think of a great comment on the topic I had read here a few months ago. After some digging around, I found it, and it turns out to be a post of yours, too! :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19924858 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19924858 Very cool, thanks, keep posting!
- chipperyman573 7y agoThanks for finding this for me, I was about to look for the same thing. It's interesting how memorable that comment is.
- cortesoft 7y agoHaha I wonder if this is the comment that I was remembering when I commented above!
- stevenwoo 7y agoThe slide in your linked article resulting in a lawsuit was 12 feet tall. I recently played at a kids (something like 4-10) park that has a climbing feature that one can get to the top of that is a bit taller than that. It was fun but I was thinking the whole time, this could never go over in the USA. https://goo.gl/maps/bF6bSSQ93SbUuHs96 https://goo.gl/maps/bF6bSSQ93SbUuHs96
- lazyasciiart 7y agoThat's not entirely true. a) because kids are bad at assessing risk, even when it is obvious. Have you never seen a kid stuck somewhere they could climb up to but not down? My five year old sister managed to climb ten feet up a wall above a concrete floor, and then stayed there weakly sniffling 'help' until one of us noticed she was out of sight. b) because the old playgrounds often suffered from hidden dangers like rusting metal that could break off as splinters under the skin, which happened when I was about ten. I got a tetanus injection and then spent a week or more regularly soaking my foot in hot water to make sure any remaining rusty pieces weren't lingering in there.
- frenchy 7y ago> Have you never seen a kid stuck somewhere they could climb up to but not down? Goodness, I've instructed mountaineering courses, and I see plenty of adults who do this. The main difference isn't that the adults are smarter, but that they stopped trying to have fun.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoAdults aren’t necessarily good at it either, no. I was responding to this idea that old dangerous playgrounds were really “safer” > Because the risk was obvious, kids would approach it with caution
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Giving kids the ability to assess risk accurately, and develop the skill to take that risk, is the important part. Unless the playgrounds magically changed brain development so that kids got well-developed executive function much earlier than human children develop that under normal circumstances, there is no conceivable playground design that could do that. And older playgrounds weren't, in any case, designed to do that, or with the risks built in intentionally for any particular purpose. They were built with less structured consideration of risk, which made the actual risks (and the obviousness of them, even to adults) essentially random.
- dragandj 7y agoAs one of the kids who grew up in relatively unrestricted playing environment (read: no purpose-built playgrounds, the whole city/town/village was our playground) I am wondering how today's kids manage to develop any skill in the physical world, since parents are constantly around and the kids are super-dependent on the supervision and restrictions.
- xg15 7y ago> Unless the playgrounds magically changed brain development so that kids got well-developed executive function much earlier than human children develop that under normal circumstances, there is no conceivable playground design that could do that. I'm not an expert, but I find it quite likely that, yes, playgrounds do magically change brain development. I think it's well-known in developmental psychology that your experience of, interaction with and reasoning about the world around you shapes how your brain develops.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I'm not an expert, but I find it quite likely that, yes, playgrounds do magically change brain development. They don't change it enough to make executive function develop early enough to make that story plausible, which we know because some of the studies on how and when executive function develops which make it implausible occurred with people who grew up with those old playgrounds. Pretending children are just smaller adults is as much of a problem as excessively infantilizing them, if slightly less popular of a problem the last couple decades.
- calewis 7y agoI’d love a link but this argument makes total common sense. Learning where your boundaries are, and pushing them a bit, is such an important developmental step.