3 ms·
I think it's reasonable to turn the philosophical question around and look at it from the other direction. Why should a person interacting within society have
by shadowgovt 7y ago
I think it's reasonable to turn the philosophical question around and look at it from the other direction.
Why should a person interacting within society have the option to opt out of surveillance?
We don't imagine that in pre-industrial-age communities, people believed in a right to not be seen by, say, the butcher or blacksmith when they went in to buy meat or metalwork, or a right to not have their commerce recorded in books of accounting. And people weren't immune to town gossip---the low-speed, high-latency, low-accuracy equivalent of having your disparate data points aggregated. Has society changed or has what it means to be seen changed? Is gossip qualitatively different now because it's fast, low-latency, and high-accuracy?
Framed from this angle, I think the question is less about opting out and more about "How much gossip is it polite to engage in before people should see one as an asshole for being that nosy?"
- kgwxd 7y agoTo me, it's the lack of personal responsibility. Once it's automated, there's basically no single person to call an asshole.
- danShumway 7y ago> Why should a person interacting within society have the option to opt out of surveillance? A non-exhaustive list of a few specific reasons: - Private, unregulatable actions are historically large components of social change, particularly for minority groups. - Historically, powerful groups (both governments and societies as a whole) have used surveillance to harass critics and undesirable parts of the population. - People have a natural tendency to self-select and avoid honestly engaging with controversial ideas when they know they're being watched. I tend to sum most of that up into a more general point: People have the Right to Hide because society can be cruel, vindictive, and arbitrary, and because people have the right to protect themselves from others in the same way that a deer has the right to camouflage itself from wolves. Opting out of society is not a real choice that anyone here can realistically take, so a just society must balance collective and individual rights. That means respecting individual rights of privacy and self-autonomy.
- swader999 7y agoYeah it would crush dissent, limit change, make us weaker as a species.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> Private, unregulatable actions are historically large components of social change, particularly for minority groups I agree but I'd note there's reasons not to maximize that effect universally. Some balance is important; the Klu Klux Klan in the US is a minority group. Apart from that, I generally agree with your assessment of the benefits of the ability to have a private life.