4 ms·
> It depends on the industry but there's too many people who are de facto actually at work every waking moment If "at work every waking moment" means "needs to
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> It depends on the industry but there's too many people who are de facto actually at work every waking moment
If "at work every waking moment" means "needs to be able to respond to emergencies", then this is actually the norm for everyone in the world until very recently. Anyone who doesn't have an employer is "at work every waking moment" by this definition. Peasants, housewives, aristocrats...
Given the nearly 100% rate of this for all of history, it seems weird to argue that the current -- much lower -- rate is too high.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoGiven that chauffeuring is driving and we were driving before Uber existed, it seems strange that people expect compensation when driving for Uber and count it as part of their labor time?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoTry to make the correspondences in your supposed analogy explicit. I'll wait. My parent comment is not complaining about excessive labor time. He's complaining about being on call. Is it strange that people expect compensation for being on call? That depends on what you're willing to consider "compensation". No one is clocked in at an hourly rate while on call because the labor laws prohibit that, but that's an artifact. On-call positions are viewed as more undesirable than otherwise and pay compensation accordingly.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoWe all have personal lives where we do things employers would pay for. It doesn't follow from that that employers demanding constant availability is nothing new, we still have those personal lives, so this isn't a swap of fungible work. Even if it were, we aren't required to deal with professional bullshit in personal driving or family emergencies.
- rixrax 7y agoYou mean emergencies such as your hot shot boss calling you 2am because he wants to discuss some bullshit idea he just had? I’ve worked in a couple of places where this kept happening. First time I was junior enough to care and put up with it. Everyone understand: this is not normal. Unless you specifically signed up for pager duty sort of job, no one should put up with this.
- onemoresoop 7y agoOr unless you get $100 every time your "pager" beeps you into duty. Or a day off the next day or some sort of payback...
- spking 7y ago> First time I was junior enough to care and put up with it. I think that's the game at a lot of companies, to just prey on the young and hungry who probably don't know any better and are more likely to put up with bullshit like that.
- WalterSear 7y agoI get the feeling that ageism in hiring is often driven by this.
- yardie 7y agoAs a fully formed adult with responsibilities and kids. There are so many job posts you can tell right away aren't for a certain demographic. People who may push back because they have a parent-teacher conference on the schedule already.
- pmoriarty 7y agoThere's something to what you say. If you're responsible for handling emergencies then you have some incentive for making sure such emergencies don't happen. Thus, developers have incentives to write more robust code and sysadmins have incentives to design more robust systems. But what if your company doesn't give the resources you need to make these more robust? Your team may be too small to do much other than run from one fire to another, or to apply a bandaid fix rather than taking the time to do things right from the start. It's also not uncommon to come in to a company inheriting an unholy mess of spaghetti code which no one at the company fully understands nor has the time to document, redesign, or fix. In these cases emergencies tend to be a regular occurrence, and arguably of the company's own making, but the hands of the people who have to respond to them are effectively tied.
- jodrellblank 7y agoHow do you say the current rate is much lower? By your definiton everyone on Earth still is at work to respond to their home being set on fire, but now many people are also on call to respond to a shopping website being mildly inconveniently down at a time most people are asleep, in a system which is abusively, inhumanely, choosing to define that as an "emergency" and choosing to make that happen as often as possible by squeezing design and engineering and planning resources, because both of those choices (uptime, and fast development) are more profitable, and screw the human factor. It's a totally different scenario. Even in situations where there are lives at risk, medical systems, or power grid control, there are plenty of options for planning in advance, for redundancy, for employing people in different time zones. When a peasant has to respond to their house burning, they're motivated to put the candles out before going to bed. When a peasant has to respond to their email system being down, but they're not allowed to allocate more time or money to fix it, that's worse.