5 ms·
History has consistently shown that the rights tend to arise after the violations, not the other way around. The Magna Carta was written in response to an awful
by whatshisface 7y ago
History has consistently shown that the rights tend to arise after the violations, not the other way around. The Magna Carta was written in response to an awful king, the FDA was established as a response to widespread problems with people getting poisoned, slavery wasn't abolished until millenia after it was invented, and labor organization (leading to such modern niceties as the 40 hour week) did not arise until well after the industrial revolution. Give it time.
- mikelyons 7y agoThere will have to be time, but also immense harm and death before something will be done. It wont just take decades of the discomfort of wondering what they're doing with the data. It will take some sort of massive act against the people done with the data before the outcry will happen, as with any technology. People didn't invent and require seatbelts becasue "you could die" people did die. The question is what will happen, or how bad will it get? The worst fear is some sort of automated genocide.
- dashwav 7y agoI think that one of the pervasive problems of these kinds of technology is that each individual violation can be individually tailored to the person in question. In my opinion, it's not going to be some blanket thing that is immediately obvious, but rather a collection of individual actions taken against individual people in exactly the way that is the least suspicious for that person specifically. Plus with the level of surveillance, those in control of the centralization will also know the dissidents well before they become a serious threat and can take preventative measures should they need to.
- neltnerb 7y agoInteresting point, it's a hard problem to define exactly what the rules should be especially when the violations are so personalized and well obscured. And an awkward transitional period while companies that built their business around the assumption that they could monetize models of their users on behalf of their customers either collapse or totally change their business model. I hate to look at specific outcomes, but perhaps a useful question would be... is there a way to both pay your tolls with a RFID thing on your car or license plate reader and also not give the DOT a complete record of exactly when you go through each toll plaza? What would the counterargument to this be? I have the feeling the counterargument is going to be something inane but emotionally based like "So that police can find your car if it is stolen" (which I strongly suspect is nonsense and that it is totally possible to do make this impossible without you actually giving them some secret code to do so) rather than "so that when we get hacked the mob knows when you're home". Maybe what we need then is a regulatory system where you must assume that you have been hacked by the worst possible opponent and that they have administrator access on your servers. Then have a checklist for what things absolutely must not occur -- like that if Facebook can tell when you're not at home because of your phone's GPS under absolutely no circumstances should this information ever be linked to your home address via any identifier. But as noted, the line is currently comically fuzzy, and where that line should be needs to be a lot clearer. Do I really mind Amazon knowing my purchasing habits on their website, even if they use algorithms to make recommendations or modify prices for me? Personally, not especially as long as it's anonymized in their model well enough to not leak my PII if someone hacks the computer with their datasets. Do I mind if them getting hacked will let someone figure out my shipping address and when packages are getting mailed? Or get my order history? Yes. So I'd say an Amazon employee should be totally unable to access that information and would need to have my explicit permission to access my account information. I don't think that's currently the case, and I think it should be enforced by regulation that doesn't allow them to collect it if they can't or won't do that. Of course, currently I have no power to make that the state of the world, but that's ideally the point of elected officials, to speak for the people. Maybe the appeal to "do you want the mob to know where you work, when you're home, and how many kids you have" is sufficiently concrete to make this more obvious to people? But I kind of agree it's a lost cause after Obama betrayed his pledge to get rid of the Patriot Act.
- rapind 7y agoWhat's the ultimate end game though if you're one of these future (not so distant?) powerful elites in control? You turn everyone else into slaves? Will they remain happy and productive? Will they still invent shiny new things for you if they know they're slaves? Is your only job now to prevent the slaves from figuring it out? Is that even a fun job or is it sort of like a prison? Can you still find meaning? How long can you conspire with your peers until some of them get bored and rock the boat? Sounds like a moronic shit show to me. We either find enlightenment before the earth swallows us up or we don't. I think it'd be cool if we figured it out.
- ohthehugemanate 7y agoThe frustrating this is, we HAVE ALREADY SEEN terrible violations of surveillance and profiling power, in Nazi Germany, Stasi East Germany, Soviet Russia, Communist China, etc. Tens or hundreds of millions have disappeared, suffered, and died. I guess we didn't take the "universal surveillance/profiling is dangerous" lesson from any of these experiences hard enough, despite it entering into major western literature through stories like 1984. I guess the analogy is that Voltaire was writing about abuses decades before they stormed the Bastille. So maybe it takes MORE abuses. It's terrifying to think of how to scale abuse UPWARDS from those examples, though.
- someguydave 7y ago1.) those horrendous actions happened more than a generation ago, people forget. 2.) the lack of a terrible regime on the other side of the planet committing these acts removes the shame in proposing them here.
- renox 7y agoI think that a 'better' example is what happened in France during WW2: jews were deported to concentration camps, how did they know who was Jewish? Because the French government (before the invasion) had a registry/census who kept this information..
- aSplash0fDerp 7y agoThose were some very good points! IMO, we're on the cusp of a level of individual freedoms that were not available in the past (in the western world) and are seeing those that are desparate for relevance, those unable to compete/comprehend or those not involved/behind doing their darndest to stifle the growth and progress. Most of the privacy exploitation sounds like that saying about "C managers" firing "A and B employees" due to their insecurities or more likely, job security/relevance. My only question at this point is... Does chasing the boogie{man,woman,trans} count as exercise?
- JohnFen 7y ago> IMO, we're on the cusp of a level of individual freedoms that were not available in the past I really, truly, wish I could share your optimism. What I think will happen is that things are going to continue to go strongly the opposite direction, until everything gets so egregious that people actually start fighting back in numbers. If that fight is successful, we'll just return to something close to, but not quite, the status quo that existed a couple of decades ago.
- aSplash0fDerp 7y ago>I really, truly, wish I could share your optimism. Lol. If you mix all of the colors, you get black. If you mix all of the data, you get a black hole. I had to come up with that one myself to keep my perspective in line. Hope that helps!
- makotech222 7y agoLove, love, love that all the problems you described are caused by the owner class, until the worker class checks them. If only we had some kind of 19th century theory which described the class system and the problems that arise from it, and suggested a solution that would fix all of this. (Marxism, for those who don't know)
- entee 7y agoI think you’re right but the problem is that this time it’s different: maybe the rights will arise, but for many people it’ll be too late. Assume there is a privacy law enacted, all the data that was previously collected is still around. So essentially people around prior to that law are still somewhat screwed. It’s good for those coming afterwards, so eventually it washes out, but it won’t be like the FDA or slavery where everyone benefits quickly.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago>> The Magna Carta was written in response to an awful king, the FDA was established as a response to widespread problems with people getting poisoned, slavery wasn't abolished until millenia after it was invented, and labor organization (leading to such modern niceties as the 40 hour week) did not arise until well after the industrial revolution. Give it time. > I think you’re right but the problem is that this time it’s different: maybe the rights will arise, but for many people it’ll be too late. This time is not different. Take the FDA example for instance: it's founding (or later gaining the power to oversee drug safety) didn't help the people who'd already been poisoned [1]. The reforms were too late for them. [1] an example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radithor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radithor
- entee 7y agoOh of course, but those who had not yet been poisoned were protected. I guess I'm agreeing with you and adding the caveat that nearly everyone is already poisoned.
- dragonsngoblins 7y agoI guess the hope at this point is that our children won't be. I miss the vibe of the late 90s and early 00s. I remember feeling like sure the world is fucked both socially and environmentally but that things would improve. The bad old lot would be kicked out, the internet would spread freedom and understanding, science would advance and we would all prosper. Hell I remember being a kid back then and being frustrated by all the environmental themes in media back then because of course we should all care about that sort of thing, it was obvious. Same as I remember getting sick of all the "don't be racist/homophobic" very special episodes for the same reason - obviously they were preaching to the choir right? Well now environmentalism seems to have fallen off and the planet is fucked. People are saying white men are to blame for everything or instead saying it is the fault of women and immigrants. The internet is instead a collection of platforms that are safe space echo chambers and is full of toxic culture wars. Science marches on and it brings us drone strikes, China's social credit system, a surveillance state, and the expectation we are always available to answer work emails. I want to get off this ride.
- roenxi 7y agoTo be totally fair, we would have difficulties detecting the opposite (rights preceding abuses) because people would presumably be organising against the abuses. For example, murder is generally highly illegal everywhere without need for particularly violent murdering sprees to prompt action.
- mortenjorck 7y agoOne cannot begin to count the number of murdering sprees ("invasions," "sacks," "pillages") in the history of civilization that very much prompted early societies to legislate against murder.