6 ms·
Many people have pointed to privacy and data issues, but there's also the plain reality that the US has been shown to be willing to use its economic leverage fo
by Barrin92 7y ago
Many people have pointed to privacy and data issues, but there's also the plain reality that the US has been shown to be willing to use its economic leverage for political ends over the recent few years, so having key data stored in the US becomes an increasingly geopolitical risk even for European allies.
I think these mercantilist plays we're seeing from the US are going to cause a lot of long term harm to the tech companies. For national security reasons alone you cannot rely on US cloud infrastructure if the man or woman in the white house is likely to pull the plug at any moment.
- chance_state 7y ago>the US has been shown to be willing to use its economic leverage for political ends over the recent few years Are there specific examples you're referring to? Because this is how geopolitics and diplomacy has worked since the dawn of civilization. This isn't something unique to Big Bad USA.
- Barrin92 7y agoThe entity list program against Chinese companies, the pressure on Europe to reject Huawei infrastructure (and accompanying threats in particular when it comes to natsec data sharing), the attack on the German car industry, on French agriculture, the list has been getting pretty long. And while it's true that this has been the state of affairs for most of civilisation, it wasn't for the last ~70 years. Up until recently, the US was willing to underpin global free-trade without using economic politics as leverage for short-term or one-sided political goals. Which is precisely why US tech companies have become the first choice in much of Europe and indeed around the world. Now the question is being posed if that is still a good decision. Without this interference, Europe would not think about investing billions and billions into its own cloud infrastructure, and China would not be ditching Android. It could have been smooth sailing for US companies for a long time. If this continues I'll give it 10-20 years before there's a major decoupling even between the US and Europe.
- bcrosby95 7y agoHas this mostly been a Trump thing? Or was it going this direction before him? I was going to comment about Trump and Brexit showing us how quickly things can change in a democracy. But I'm too ignorant to know if that's a fair analysis of the situation.
- mattrp 7y agoThis has been long coming. At least 15 years ago I was at a global Cisco conference and I met the regional manager for emea and Northern Africa. His biggest hurdle was getting companies in his region to buy from a US vendor. In contrast, China would show up with loans, equipment, services and it was not just a company, but a team effort. We often see things through the perspective of the Cold War where Western Europe was effectively a satellite state of the United States. It ceased to be that when the Berlin Wall came down. Historically Europe has had stronger ties with its eastern partners (don’t forget the whole reason Colombus even came to America in the first place was to find a route to eastern markets). So it would not surprise me in the least that Europe would over time revert to its historical alignment regardless of who the American president is.
- chibg10 7y agoI have no idea what relevance trade history from hundreds of years ago has to modern geopolitics and economic globalization. Historically, Europeans didn’t know North America even existed and the USA wasn’ta country
- freeflight 7y agoThe very same economic globalization that turns out to be rather destructive to the environment? I wonder if such problems might not end up forcing us to reconsider our trading priorities to account more for geographical distance, instead of just taking that as a given.
- 7y ago
- simion314 7y agoThe first and recent thing I can think of is Adobe disabling their software in a South America country and did not even offered refunds at that time. This is important, some dude in White House can blackmail you or all your software will no longer work. You will say something military alias but we seen economic wars between US and Eu / Canada
- iknowalot 7y agoIf you show the world your ass enough, this is what happens.... The BDS movement against the USA is beginning, when de-dollarization is in vogue, it will hit the US economy like a Mac Truck. Buy gold & bitcoin.
- freeflight 7y agoThis is from not even a month ago [0], at least a spawned a really useful discussion around open source alternatives. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21184623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21184623
- throwGuardian 7y agoYou seem to believe the reverse, i.e. EU or it's member nations willing to use its economic leverage for political ends, does not happen? Isn't that rather naive?