4 ms·
Complain about Git, but there are commercial alternatives (I'm thinking of Perforce) that make even less sense.
by icedchai 7y ago
Complain about Git, but there are commercial alternatives (I'm thinking of Perforce) that make even less sense.
- CydeWeys 7y agoAnd there are alternatives that make better sense, too. But the existence of something even worse doesn't excuse something that is merely bad. And git is so much more widely used that its total overall harm on developer productivity is worse.
- icedchai 7y agoYou really only need to know a half dozen commands for basic productivity. I started in the late 90's when cvs was popular. Then we moved to svn. You had productivity issues of all sorts, mainly with branching and merging.
- magduf 7y ago>but there are commercial alternatives (I'm thinking of Perforce) that make even less sense. Have you ever worked with Rational ClearCase? It's a true horror show.
- pjmlp 7y agoI have during several occasions in the past (up to 2007), and while it is a monster, I still felt more productive than using git nowadays.
- panpanna 7y agoRemember, back then companies had to hire dedicated Clear case engineers to get things working properly.
- pjmlp 7y agoYou mean just like we have to reach out to IT to sort out git issues for anyone that strays outside the path?
- panpanna 7y agoNot really a common occurrence here. Does it happen often at your workplace? What kind of issues are we talking about?
- pjmlp 7y agoBasically the usual ones that end up with copying the modified files to a temporary directory and doing a fresh clone followed by a manual merge and commit, because someone messed up their local repository while trying out some git command beyond clone/pull/push/checkout/commit, and now cannot push without messing everyone's else.
- souprock 7y agoClearCase is wonderful if you fit the use case, which is a sizable team on a fast LAN. It's great being able to change a ClearCase config file to choose a different branch of code for just a few files or directories, then instantly get that branch active for just those specific files.