4 ms·
I'm curious what side you perceive standardUser to be on. They are making the case that this wasn't acceptable under the Obama administration either to younger
by shadowgovt 7y ago
I'm curious what side you perceive standardUser to be on. They are making the case that this wasn't acceptable under the Obama administration either to younger generations, but they lacked the political power and voice to do anything about it. Voice and political power that they are now finding as they age into voting enfranchisement and build political action blocs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- refurb 7y agoGitmo’s a great example. Under Bush it was immoral. Under Obama? Barely heard a thing. Sure standardUser might have thought it immoral all along, but did he attack both parties (when in power) with the same zeal?
- standardUser 7y agoBush started Guantanamo as an extrajudicial prison and stocked it full of prisoners. Obama managed to release many of those prisoners and tried (and failed) to shut it down. Obama got plenty of criticism from the left for things like drone strikes, extrajudicial killings, deportations, the intervention in Libya, the weakness of Obamacare and TPP to name a few. Most of this was during his second term (when that massive group of people I keep mentioning started becoming politically active).
- dashundchen 7y ago> Gitmo’s a great example. Under Bush it was immoral. Under Obama? Barely heard a thing. Anecdotes are just that. Just because you weren't paying attention to it doesn't mean it didn't happen.] Left wing media I paid attention to definitely did not drop the issue of Guantanamo during that time. Just google some common sites - MotherJones, commondreams, Obama, and Guantanamo and you will see the criticism did not disappear for Obama not forcing the issue to an unwilling Congress.
- dragontamer 7y ago> Gitmo’s a great example. Under Bush it was immoral. Under Obama? Barely heard a thing. Your history is off. Obama tried to shut it down until it was overturned by Congress. As soon as the political reality of transferring the prisoners became apparent, all Congressmen blocked the closure of Gitmo. No one wanted to take the prisoners into their own state. No one wanted to be the Senator or Representative to say "I accepted 100 Al-Qaeda detainees into our local prisons! And now our local judges have to put into public trial under our protection, with jury members selected from our State / Cities" So on the one hand, we had President Bush literally open Gitmo. In the other hand, we have President Obama who tried to close it... but failed because of other more powerful political forces. And yet, you draw a false equivalence between the two. EDIT: This hits a political pet peeve of mine. False equivalence and whataboutisms. Instead of seeing the differences, a political group deploys propaganda to get their side to believe that there's a false-equivalence on an issue. And now that you're aware of false-equivalences, I hope that moving forward you'll be better equipped to avoid them in the future. Its an exceptionally powerful propaganda technique. In general, if a group is desperately deploying propaganda to make you believe that two things are equivalent... they probably aren't equivalent.
- masonic 7y agoObama tried to shut it down It originated under Obama, and his party controlled Congress at the time.
- o-__-o 7y ago"On 20 May 2009, the United States Senate passed an amendment to the Supplemental Appropriations Act of 2009 (H.R. 2346) by a 90–6 vote to block funds needed for the transfer or release of prisoners held at the Guantánamo Bay detention camp" [0] [0] - https://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/senate-overwhelmingly-votes-obama-plan-move-guantanamo-detainees-close-prison-article-1.374027 https://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/senate-overwhelmingly...
- refurb 7y agoOf course! Obama tried as hard as he could to close it, but darn that other party wouldn’t let him. Obviously he’s off the hook.