3 ms·
If anyone thinks Github boycotting ICE will change anything of ICE's conduct, that to me is some kind of Delusions of Grandeur. The money involved are a tiny pa
by BurningFrog 7y ago
If anyone thinks Github boycotting ICE will change anything of ICE's conduct, that to me is some kind of Delusions of Grandeur. The money involved are a tiny part of a forgotten section of their budget.
If they don't think it will change anything, we can agree that this boycott is purely symbolic and will accomplish nothing.
- yazboo 7y agoIt’s not “nothing” to refuse to profit, directly or indirectly, from behaviors you find unethical.
- BurningFrog 7y agoWhat I mean is that it does nothing to help the victims of ICE. It only helps some rich people feel morally superior. That doesn't impress me much, but I see others find it important. To each their own, I guess.
- codyb 7y agoThis feels like a pretty defeatist attitude to me. Just because your portion of ICE’s budget is insignificant doesn’t mean you have to support ICE. And even if it is purely symbolic, lots of symbolic actions do more than nothing. At the very least it may improve employee morale to not support ICE which may increase Github’s employee retention rate, which may not be a big deal for ICE but may be a bigger deal for Github. And finally, death by a thousand cuts is certainly a thing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 7y agoUsername checks out. No, but you really don't want to be a collaborator either. If other parties are willing to step up then they can be addressed if and when that time comes. Principles always were a 'circle of influence' thing.
- awinder 7y agoNowhere in the article is the viewpoint that they’re going to change ICEs conduct mentioned. Inventing opposing viewpoints is one of the lowest rhetorical devices, and I really wish people would post with more care around here. As for “only being symbolic”, no, it wouldn’t. It would allow workers to be in an environment where their work supports their values. A lot of these workers are going to leave the org to go work for a company that doesn’t so conflict with their values, as is absolutely their prerogative in a free labor market. This is actually a mature way to let GitHub understand the full costs of their actions, so that they can make an informed decision. There’s literally no problem here, this is a functioning labor dynamic.