5 ms·
Its a dangerous path - saying that one race is smarter directly implies that another race is dumber. That sort of dialogue is completely taboo at least in the
by colordrops 7y ago
Its a dangerous path - saying that one race is smarter directly implies that another race is dumber. That sort of dialogue is completely taboo at least in the US.
- dependenttypes 7y agoTaboos are a way to hinder progress and science. I will not fall into that trap. I could be wrong ofc, but I was under the impression that it is widely accepted in the scientific community that intelligence is at least partially affected by genes. > saying that one race is smarter directly implies that another race is dumber Note: I said on average.
- LegitShady 7y agoThe issue is not the average, but the extremes. When you have two identical distribution curves but one's center is shifted, the effect on the ends of the distributions are exaggerated. A standard deviation increase in the average leads to a huge difference in demographics at the extremes. The population with lower mean will have the majority of the lower tail of the distribution, and the the other population will dominate the upper tail. In the highest 1% they will appear enormously over-represented. In the middle is where it matters least, because near average people for both populations might have very similar iqs. For a paper on the issue of specifically ashkenazi (rather than 'jewish') IQ I recommend this one from the University of Utah: http://web.mit.edu/fustflum/documents/papers/AshkenaziIQ.jbiosocsci.pdf http://web.mit.edu/fustflum/documents/papers/AshkenaziIQ.jbi... Note the increased IQ is specifically for askenazi jews, as opposed to say sephardic jews. The paper identifies historical social issues that would make selection for intelligence a strong factor in ashkenazi history, explores possible genetic causes identified through unique mutations not present in adjacent populations, and goes into depth on IQ and IQ heritability. A high level summary available from the economist behind a paywall but viewable here: https://outline.com/XnhPWd https://outline.com/XnhPWd I hope you find it interesting. I think its scientific enough that few people should find it controversial, except those who believe that IQ is not a useful measurement of intelligence, which I don't think is an opinion you share given your previous posts. The controversial part would be Jordan B Peterson talking about it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQHH6o9ual8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQHH6o9ual8 No matter your feelings on him, worth a watch.
- CamperBob2 7y agoThe problem is, because some misguided prejudiced people made up the bogus concept of "race" and used it to justify various forms of discrimination, we're no longer allowed to criticize the very real concept of "culture." The people with the greatest influence over our language have succeeded in merging the two concepts, walling them both off from polite discourse for reasons known only to themselves.
- democracy 7y agoWhat about Obama's American exceptionalism speech? Seemed to be accepted fine.
- markdown 7y agoDo you really not know the difference between nationality and race? There are people of every race and creed in the US.
- democracy 7y agoI do actually, but in this context it doesn't really matter. Does any - not first generation immigrant - say I am 10% Irish, 10% Jewish from Russian Empire, 50% Welsh and 30% Italian? Maybe some people do but in reality you say you are an American. And for most of the world that's how it sounds anyway.
- _emacsomancer_ 7y agoMyths can be powerful things. Doesn't necessarily make them true.