7 ms·
They should be dreading it. For an American company, or really any non-Chinese company to bow down to China's censorship regime is unacceptable. I hope Congress
by ineedasername 7y ago
They should be dreading it. For an American company, or really any non-Chinese company to bow down to China's censorship regime is unacceptable. I hope Congress doesn't let the issue die. It's an increasing trend that will be harder to curtail the longer it persists.
- Mirioron 7y agoWhat's Congress going to do? The reason China has so much influence is because Chinese companies are willing to invest in (western) video game companies (or at least Tencent is). Most game developers aren't exactly swimming in money and if a Chinese company offers them more resources then many of them are going to take it even if it comes with strings attached. Another reason is access to the Chinese market. Congress can't really do anything to stop companies from complying with the Chinese government so that they can publish their games in the Chinese market.
- ineedasername 7y agoThere are already regulations that dictate how companies must regard and comply with laws and regulations of other non-US jurisdictions. This could be a similar thing. Or maybe not, maybe there is a better way. The point is, this is a long term issue of national security. US companies bolstering a foreign authoritarian regime by facilitating it's propaganda and censorship gives aid an comfort to a regime incompatible with our values.
- bcrosby95 7y agoThe latter is the reason why China has so much influence. Tencent only owns 5% of Blizzard. Heck, Blizzard only gets around 6-8% of their revenue from China. But they're looking at it as an avenue of future growth. Just like every other international corporation.
- Mirioron 7y ago>The latter is the reason why China has so much influence. When specifically talking about Blizzard, yes, but not when you think of companies like Riot.
- arcticfox 7y agoIf China wants to enforce global censorship by using their market as a hammer, America should use their market to enforce global (or at least bilateral) freedom of speech. It's an intl trade issue, it's impossible to expect every company to stand up to the CCP when they use access to one of the biggest markets in the world as a weapon
- Mirioron 7y agoAs a European, I would like to see that, but I think the EU would have a problem with the US demanding free speech, let alone most of the other countries outside the west.
- PavlovsCat 7y ago> I think the EU would have a problem with the US demanding free speech That's because you reduce it to the word "freedom of speech", and then expand it again, to all sorts of other things. Call it freedom to criticize governments, totalitarianism, murder, and so on, and there will be no issue. https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-a-million-people-are-jailed-at-china-s-gulags-i-escaped-here-s-what-goes-on-inside-1.7994216 https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-a-milli... Most people don't want to be treated like this. So, either they are against it, or they don't get to speak anything on the matter, being hypocrites. A double standard is no standard. It really is that simple.
- ianleeclark 7y ago> If China wants to enforce global censorship by using their market as a hammer, America should use their market to enforce global (or at least bilateral) freedom of speech. China has an interest in their global censorship, American companies don't have the same impetus towards free speech. China has roughly 4x the population of the United States, and, as their GDP per capita raises, they will increasingly start to fulfill the American role: vacuuming up trade surpluses. It would be a poor business decision for Western companies to not seek the larger, emerging market. These companies don't have nations, they just have the pursuit of shareholder value. You're fooling yourself if they're going to express any sort of value system contrary to that stated goal.
- cogman10 7y agoI don't think this is something that needs regulation. The capitalist solutions of boycotts and protests seems to be sending a pretty strong signal to blizzard. At the end of the day, while china is a huge market, it isn't the whole market. That does mean, however, if you think that Blizzard's actions are immoral, then vote with your wallet. This doesn't work in every case (particularly where companies have practical monopolies on essential goods and services), but at the end of the day, Blizzard is a company that peddles luxury products.
- ineedasername 7y agoConsidering that Blizzard has not backed down from their stance that their actions were correct, I don't see how this is sending a strong signal. If they think current and potential revenue from China exceeds anything lost as a result of this issue, then they aren't likely to take any lasting message from boycotts and protests.
- nsporillo 7y agoWouldn't American boycotts only signal that domestic revenues are declining, making international growth seem even more appealing to maximize shareholder value?
- filoleg 7y agoI doubt shareholders will see it this way, when NA and EU make up a combined 88% of your revenue, with the whole Asia-Pacific region making up only 12% [0]. 0. https://investor.activision.com/news-releases/news-release-details/activision-blizzard-announces-second-quarter-2019-financial https://investor.activision.com/news-releases/news-release-d...
- RomanBob 7y agoIt's a private company. How is it unacceptable for them to run the company whichever way they want?
- ineedasername 7y agoClearly that it's my opinion that such behavior is unacceptable. There is no legally unacceptable behavior here. But private or not, why couldn't a company's behavior be regarded as unacceptable? There's plenty of things that, while legal, are not things people would be comfortable with a company actually doing. Plenty of people find Facebook's actions unacceptable. Are those not legitimate opinions, backed by reasoned arguments? Absolutely they are, even if there are reasoned opinions on the other side as well. What you seem to be saying is simply that you don't find unacceptable.
- ineedasername 7y agoAlso: This is a long term issue of national security, making the behavior of a company subject to a bit more scrutiny: US companies bolstering a foreign authoritarian regime by facilitating it's propaganda and censorship gives aid and comfort to a regime incompatible with our values.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- z3phyr 7y agoIts a company, and should only do business. It should have no right to dictate other people's politics, platform, governance policy and speech. They have no right to stop what other persons speak because they are not the government. Businesses should have no power except to sell their products and services (Not even indirect power that helps them sell their products and services better)
- hnbroseph 7y agosomething is unclear to me - by 'how is it unacceptable', are you asking how people could possibly disagree?
- true_religion 7y ago
- balls187 7y agoWho is the "they?" The rank and file employees who by all accounts had nothing to do with this decision, and don't support it? I generally agree with the position against censorship on behest of an authoritarian government, but I find the harassment of Blizzard employee's appalling. The employees by and large who are attending BlizzCon want to do so to celebrate their hardwork and interact with their fanbase. I hardly think they deserve to feel dread.
- iamaelephant 7y ago> Who is the "they?" The rank and file employees who by all accounts had nothing to do with this decision, and don't support it? If you're referring to GP's comment "They should be dreading it" then yes, obviously. They are and absolutely should be dreading this event. I would be. Wouldn't you? > I generally agree with the position against censorship on behest of an authoritarian government, but I find the harassment of Blizzard employee's appalling. No one has said anything about harassing Blizzard employees. What on Earth are you talking about? > The employees by and large who are attending BlizzCon want to do so to celebrate their hardwork and interact with their fanbase. I hardly think they deserve to feel dread. Too bad. They should be dreading this event. Blizzard have publicly fucked up in a very big way, and now the people that represent Blizzard are going to have to deal with that.
- Harvey-Specter 7y ago> No one has said anything about harassing Blizzard employees. What on Earth are you talking about? > Too bad. They should be dreading this event. Blizzard have publicly fucked up in a very big way, and now the people that represent Blizzard are going to have to deal with that. What do you think the Blizzard employees are going to "have to deal with" if not harassment at BlizzCon?
- hnbroseph 7y agoprotest activity. questions. demands for a commitment to human rights. support for democracy and the people of hong kong's efforts. maybe just annoyed at having to do lots of video editing to hide it from the CCP overlords.