3 ms·
> But they will still put out a lot of pollution, it's the nature of shipping right now. Which is going to be seriously restricted in 2 months time: https://w
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
> But they will still put out a lot of pollution, it's the nature of shipping right now.
Which is going to be seriously restricted in 2 months time: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/30/imo-2020-the-winners-and-losers-of-a-global-shipping-revolution.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/30/imo-2020-the-winners-and-los...
> Will they put out as much pollution as the airline industry?
This question is so broad it's meaningless. What kind of pollution matters, and where it's emitted also matters. More Sulfur, less CO2, etc..
> For shipping, hard to say. We don't have anywhere close to the number of ships necessary for that kind of passenger scale
As of July 2016, the world had a capacity of 20 million standard shipping containers.
> We'd have to go back to sail ships to make it pollution free.
That's not the only option: battery weight is not an issue in ships; their consumption per tonne-kilometer is so low that solar can contribute a lot, et cetera.
It's still probably most efficient to just burn a clean fuel and then sequester the CO2.
> Just stopping trans-oceanic travel, or drawing it down in a draconian fashion, really does seem one of the best solutions.
Letting perfect be the enemy of the good is one of the big reasons holding the world back from making progress on environmental issues.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>As of July 2016, the world had a capacity of 20 million standard shipping containers. And if we could pack passengers into shipping containers, or even house them on freighters without refitting, we'd be great. But we can't, because people don't want to go from flying on airplanes to sitting on the floor of a cargo hold. So the build outs are still necessary. We need new ships. >What kind of pollution matters, and where it's emitted also matters. More Sulfur, less CO2, etc The goal is to cut down on all pollution. >That's not the only option: battery weight is not an issue in ships; their consumption per tonne-kilometer is so low that solar can contribute a lot, et cetera. It's still probably most efficient to just burn a clean fuel and then sequester the CO2. All of which calls for even more build outs and refitting, in addition to even more pollution expended in pursuance of those activities. >Letting perfect be the enemy of the good is one of the big reasons holding the world back Which is exactly the reason that the very next line designates such a solution, "completely unworkable in today's world."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]