3 ms·
It won't try to do ILS. I think the issue is that where GPS is available it can definitely put that plane down. Maybe it's not the world's greatest landing due
by tialaramex 7y ago
It won't try to do ILS. I think the issue is that where GPS is available it can definitely put that plane down. Maybe it's not the world's greatest landing due to GPS inaccuracy, not right on the centre line, tries to put the gear through the floor - maybe the airframe ends up totalled, but if every passenger on the plane walks away it's a huge success given the pilot was incapacitated. Whereas for ILS that gets you down under clouds in mediocre weather, all lined up properly, but (except in airports with Cat III ILS) it doesn't actually put you on the ground. With a trained pilot in the seat that's not an issue, once they can see the runway they can do the rest, but this is for emergencies.
As I mentioned in a previous HN item about ILS, these autoland systems don't get you off the runway. For a grave emergency (pilot dropped dead in flight with their spouse and two kids onboard) that's forgiveable, and this mentions that the product begins broadcasting that the runway chosen is now unusable (because your plane is now parked on it) but this is why Cat IIIc doesn't magically allow JFK to function normally in a blizzard. When the pilots still can't see the runway even after their plane lands on it, that's not useful for routine passenger flights.
- throw0101a 7y ago> I think the issue is that where GPS is available it can definitely put that plane down. Maybe it's not the world's greatest landing due to GPS inaccuracy, not right on the centre line, ... I wonder how this will change when the L2, L5, and L1C signals start becoming used from the GPS III satellites. Also, in the US, non-GPS/Navstar signals cannot officially be used for anything, though I think Galileo was recently (finally) approved by the FCC: * https://www.gsa.europa.eu/newsroom/news/fcc-approves-use-galileo-us https://www.gsa.europa.eu/newsroom/news/fcc-approves-use-gal... (The issue was something like: once officially approved, the frequencies in questions cannot be used for anything else, and are protected.)
- Animats 7y agoThe system, which is from Garmin, includes a radio altimeter, a short-range radar pointed straight down. So it's not reliant on GPS for precise vertical position during landing. This allows the system to do a proper landing flare just above the runway.