3 ms·
> Physics, as currently understood from available experimental evidence, 100% allows time travel to the past, paradoxes included. General Relativity, which is
by pdonis 7y ago
> Physics, as currently understood from available experimental evidence, 100% allows time travel to the past, paradoxes included.
General Relativity, which is where the term "closed timelike curve" is used, does not allow paradoxes. A spacetime with closed timelike curves in it (for example, the Godel universe) still has only one thing happening at each event.
The real problem conceptually with such solutions is that they appear to contradict free will: since only one thing can happen at each event, if you experience visiting that event multiple times, you cannot freely choose what to do at that event.
- adrianN 7y agoLuckily "free will" as would fit a layman's interpretation of the term is already incompatible with physics, so the existence of CTCs doesn't pose additional problems.
- pdonis 7y ago> "free will" as would fit a layman's interpretation of the term is already incompatible with physics That depends on which layman you talk to and which theory of physics you are using.
- ralusek 7y agoI think most people would interpret free will to mean something that is perfectly compatible with any definition of determinism. If I decide to raise my right hand, I raise it. Don't get pedantic in regards to disabled people. It doesn't matter if the universe is completely deterministic, that doesn't mean that I'm not the entity that decided to raise my right hand. The deterministic universe may have produced me, but the software I'm running is me. The reason I raised my hand is because of me. Sure there are an infinite number of factors that have fed into the circumstances of my birth, and everything that's happened to me, but everything that I do is specifically as a consequence of my free will. I am the software, deterministic or not.
- mr_mitm 7y ago> you cannot freely choose what to do But that's already the case. It could be my free will to walk on the ceiling, but the laws of physics won't let me.
- pdonis 7y agoYes, and in the case of a closed timelike curve, the laws of physics won't let you do something different the second time you are at a particular event in spacetime than you did the first time. Both are straightforward constraints from the point of view of the laws of physics. But that still does not mean they look the same to us, intuitively speaking. For example, the laws of physics won't let you walk on the ceiling at all, whether your worldline is a closed timelike curve or not. But if your worldline is not a closed timelike curve, then, intuitively, it seems like the laws of physics will let you choose which direction you want to walk on the floor. However, if your worldline is a closed timelike curve, and you come around again to the event in spacetime where you chose to walk to the left last time around, the laws of physics will not let you choose to walk to the right this time; they constrain you to walk to the left again, since from the standpoint of the laws of physics you are at the same event in spacetime and that event can only happen one way. To many people that seems like a much stronger constraint than the constraint that you can't choose to walk on the ceiling.