3 ms·
The idea that the measure of. A person is their job is a relatively new idea, really back to the industrial revolution. Something that recent should be relative
by gumby 7y ago
The idea that the measure of. A person is their job is a relatively new idea, really back to the industrial revolution. Something that recent should be relatively easy to flush out of society (“relatively” meaning only a few decades.
This kind of reductionist world view is what screws up efforts to provide UBI, universal health care etc.
- rayiner 7y ago> The idea that the measure of. A person is their job is a relatively new idea, really back to the industrial revolution. Only in the sense that specialized “jobs” are a product of the industrial revolution. But the idea that people are defined by their work goes back basically to the dawn of time. Many English last names come from peoples’ trades (Smith, Miller, etc.). In hunter gatherer societies, rituals for adolescent males often revolve around hunting and war. Men who couldn’t do those things were a burden on their community, unless they fit some other social niche (spiritual leader, etc.).
- gumby 7y agoThere were "professions" (i.e. religious calling) and of course aristocratic rank and power, but these village jobs typically did not connote social rank. Yes though we are talking about Europe, not, say, India. Source: I have a degree in European history and specifically studied non-aristocratic social systems of late feudal France and England. But my assertion is just as applicable to the non-landholders of the American colonies and early United States, as is well attested in the contemporaneous literature.
- toasterlovin 7y agoIs your position that there was no hierarchy of status or prestige below the aristocracy in a feudal society?
- gumby 7y agoNo, all human groups of almost any size have hierarchies of one sort or another though they can be fluid or dynamic. That appears to be a property of higher primates anyway. Ignoring the De Jure (or De Bello) aristocratic and 2e Estate ranks, jobs were pretty loosely connected at best to one's "rank" in medieval society, in particular in the countryside. Certain jobs had a cap ex element (miller in particular, but smith too) but that would likely have been the property (and investment) of the local squire or lord, not the property of the operator. Even the jobs you named such as cooper, baker etc tended to be tied to urban societies (towns really), and a farrier was sufficiently specialized to be in the court, but not to have any sort of special grade or rank. In the later Middle Ages as the growth of the guilds and cities began to challenge the aristocracy, rank still depended more on wealth than job (an inversion of the aristocratic order, and that of the Roman republic and empire, where you became wealthy though power rather than the other way around as today). But even there we're talking about a small number of people; being a baker or miller wasn't really a self identity in the way we think of it today. And there were people assigned job-related surnames as a tool of scorn (Goldschmidt -- goldsmith) where there were jobs reserved for specific outcasts (i.e. jewish people in Europe): again they had those jobs as part of bing an outcaste group; they didn't become outcastes by having those jobs.