7 ms·
Take Better Screenshots
- kranner 7y agoTo OP -- in the spirit of the article -- it's an uphill task to separate the content from the witticisms here. IMO it would have been a better read with fewer jokes.
- new2628 7y agoThe guy is a writer, I think his goal was to entertain more than to inform.
- gawi 7y agoI agree. I gave up and went straight to HN comments.
- exikyut 7y agoTo _you_, this person wrote https://www.stilldrinking.org/the-episode-part-1 https://www.stilldrinking.org/the-episode-part-1 (and 18 more parts, which I only put down because my body required sleep), https://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks https://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks, and everything over at https://www.stilldrinking.org/essays.php https://www.stilldrinking.org/essays.php. ((Who gets the reference?))
- kranner 7y agoI'm not sure how that is relevant to this essay, which I found almost unreadable.
- rcarmo 7y agoThis piece is so littered with ads (one per paragraph) that it is impossible to read without an ad blocker.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat's, sadly, the Web these days. Even with adblockers, I see the "advertisement" lines remaining in articles. Often every paragraph or two.
- progval 7y agoWith Javascript disabled, I don't see them at all
- dredmorbius 7y agoDepending on the site, I do. This LA Times article has two "advertisement" lines. The ads themselves don't appear. JS is disabled. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-10-31/homes-burning-in-san-bernardino-as-fire-sweeps-into-neighborhood https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-10-31/homes-bu...
- exikyut 7y agoWith /etc/hosts blocking, I still see them, and I like it. It's like a TV that's gone to ads and then glitches out and the show comes straight back on.
- c22 7y agoMore and more often with JavaScript disabled I don't see anything at all!
- 7y ago
- makapuf 7y agoScreenshots for asking help are not the same as screenshots for showing to people. A screenshot is a good way for someone who does not know to send something he does not see himself to someone that will see it. You will capture more than you know in a screenshot, and that's the point. So grab large and you might capture an interesting point that, if you knew was important, you could have communicated as text. But of course be careful you will send more than you think (again it's the point) and try not to include sensitive info as in the last article's screenshot.
- indentit 7y agoI see a lot of cropped screenshots on support forums, when really it would be better if the poster took the screenshot of the whole window, and then just highlighted the area they are worried about with a red square (or if you are a StackOverflow user, a freehand red circle ;)). Often the answer lies outside the area the poster thinks is relevant and if one could see it immediately, it would save lots of questions and back and forth. That said, automatically annotated screenshots would be useful, or even better: if someone invents a screengrab tool that would semantically tag all parts of the image based on the data available so its not just a plain image. I.e. screengrab a GUI window and all the text displayed in that window could be added as metadata like titlebar/button/label text and then it becomes searchable. I guess it would need an API that the developer of the app would have to explicitly implement though for most useful results like debug state information...
- vthriller 7y agoRe: annotated screenshots, there once was a module that allowed making snapshots of GTK windows as PDFs: https://github.com/nomeata/gtk-vector-screenshot https://github.com/nomeata/gtk-vector-screenshot Edit: here it is in action, with selectable text: https://www.joachim-breitner.de/various/pdf_screenshot_3.pdf https://www.joachim-breitner.de/various/pdf_screenshot_3.pdf
- indentit 7y agowow, that's awesome - thanks for sharing! :) I'm surprised it's not more popular though, but I guess it has remained undiscovered like it was for me until now, or it's simply not as useful to others as I would think. Maybe because not all apps are GTK3 apps, or people don't want pdf's because they can't be inlined on a issue ticket like plain old images can, for example?
- vthriller 7y ago> people don't want pdf's because they can't be inlined on a issue ticket like plain old images can Well, this module can also produce SVGs, which, I guess, can be inlined in some issue trackers. But, aside from being GTK3-only, the main reason this sort of thing didn't become popular is simply due the fact that even JPEG screenshots are just good enough and get the job done. Virtually nobody has any need to search for text in older screenshots; selecting text—well, you can't copy-paste from most of real error windows, so you're going to re-type its content anyways; and nobody is bothered with other people's font sizes, aliasing preferences, JPEG artifacts or whatever.
- myroon5 7y agoRelated: https://github.com/jordwest/news-feed-eradicator https://github.com/jordwest/news-feed-eradicator
- RussianCow 7y agoHow is this related?
- myroon5 7y ago"Actually, the end of the Facebook feed would be great"
- miki123211 7y agoMy advice is to avoid taking screenshots wherever possible, particularly if you want to share something in a public setting. The're an accessibility nightmare and may make your content unreadable for certain groups of people, screen reader users in particular.
- bauerd 7y agoWhat's the alternative?
- bipson 7y agoLearning to describe your problem. Specific knowledge aside, I am always astonished that people not being able to coherently read and write is getting worse. That's something YouTube, Snapchat, Instagram and Facebook don't teach I guess?
- bauerd 7y agoThe two are not exclusive
- thrower123 7y agoExactly - together they make a wonderful synergy. I die a little inside every time I get a bug report that is just a couple sentences saying that something didn't work. I also die a little every time I get a bug report that is just an out-of-context downsampled screenshot of some dashboard, where it has been shrunk so the text is not readable, and there is nothing highlighting what the issue is. I have to really, really fight back the urge to send back a message with nothing but a gif of the Jerry Maguire "Help me help you" scene
- baq 7y agoi can do that very well thank you, i just don't have the time budget. i also don't have time to spend on deciphering the problem from a description from even a well-spoken user if a single screenshot would be self-explanatory. of course it's useful to be able to describe the problem, but most of the time there's no ROI and opportunity cost is prohibitive.
- bureaucrat 7y agoNo, I favor full screen screenshots because people tend to not include important things when they crop.
- jmkni 7y agoAlso you get to spy on people a little
- dsego 7y agoAs a dev, the worst offenders are not sending the url and a screenshot with new copy annotated within the image file (and an obligatory arrow to content it replaces).
- pjc50 7y agoThe downside of uncropped screenshots is information leakage from e.g. your bookmarks, open tabs, unrelated emails, IM popups etc. Another commentator mentioned annotated screenshots, and now I'm wondering about the "semantic screenshot"; imagine getting a copy of someone's desktop frozen in time with the ability to re-stack windows, check what's currently available on menus, etc.
- greggman2 7y agoI turned off the default Username in menu bar on MacOS so I had one less thing to take off my screenshots.
- bdcravens 7y agoTangential to screenshots, but when doing presentations, I've taken to creating a second user on my machine to prevent notifications, etc I'd rather not show.
- TacticalTable 7y agoMacOS seems to turn on Do Not Disturb when plugged into unusual external displays or sharing my screen online, which has always been a big help.
- devinplatt 7y agoMy favorite example is that time Kanye shared a screenshot on Twitter and didn't crop out his Pirate Bay tabs for pirating Deadmau5's music software, Serum. https://twitter.com/deadmau5/status/704876167157907456?s=20 https://twitter.com/deadmau5/status/704876167157907456?s=20
- dspillett 7y agoOr even better, if you can reliably reproduce the problem perhaps record yourself doing so using something like https://www.cockos.com/licecap/ https://www.cockos.com/licecap/
- artsyca 7y agoThat's because this article is not about screenshots, it's about the human condition with a dialectical analysis centered on the banal medium of the screenshot vis the existential angst we suffer as human beings now that the floodgates of communication have been busted wide open yet we still have very little of substance to relate This is a person who truly gets it and knows how to paint a picture with words. Try taking a more visceral approach or listening to Baba Ram Dass in order to truly appreciate the mastery of verse contained in this blog post
- squeaky-clean 7y ago> Then there are the well-meaning spirits who discovered the developer console and send these with worried emojis: All too true. The worst I've ever gotten was an email titled "Problem!" (or similar), the body was several of the grimacing and throwing up emojis, and attached was a screenshot of a (long and ugly) SQL query without the attached results. When I asked if they could send the results over, or at least a copy-pasteable version of the query, they said they had closed SQL Workbench already along with the query and results...
- exikyut 7y agoIf a tree crashes to the ground but nobody is there to see it, did the tree actually fall? In this situation I think there was never a real, valid problem in the first place.
- chx 7y agoAh yes, the famous stilldrinking.org where http://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks http://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks comes from :D It's the best essay written about programming, ever. Just one quote: > This file is Good Code. It has sensible and consistent names for functions and variables. It’s concise. It doesn’t do anything obviously stupid. It has never had to live in the wild, or answer to a sales team.
- wool_gather 7y ago> This educational blind spot leads Person Q to take a carefully framed picture of the 2 percent of their visual field that signaled a problem and email it to Person X, assuming Person X will immediately grok the necessary portion of Person Q’s life experience that motivated them to send it. Bravo; I have never seen a more perfectly succinct illustration of the fundamental problem of human existence. It's a struggle to remember that nobody else is inside your head, but damn, that realization makes everything easier to deal with.
- owaty 7y ago> Spot them all: the URL, the problem, the browser, how many tabs are open on that browser, the fact that this person has an unusual number of Facebook tabs open and probably isn’t overly invested in their job, some other applications that are open, that they leave system credentials in text files on their desktop, the time, the operating system, that they have a serious investment in someone named Alex, and whether the wifi is connected. And that is precisely why I would crop my screenshot to only the relevant part.
- crispyporkbites 7y agoYou know what would be helpful? A button in the web browser that the user can click, which creates a full page screenshot and dump of a bunch of helpful data points for debugging (e.g. URL, cookies, history, console logs, network requsets, assets, RAM use, IP address, user agent etc etc.) Basically a neat way to export a pseudo-stack trace from the application environment with screenshot and all potentially useful info.
- mook 7y agoFirefox at least does the screenshot part. https://screenshots.firefox.com/ https://screenshots.firefox.com/
- letsgetsilly 7y agoShareX provides the best windows-based screenshot in my experience. https://getsharex.com/downloads/ https://getsharex.com/downloads/
- ASalazarMX 7y agoFor me, Greenshot is the most convenient. Not only you can select what area you want, you can edit the screenshot (proverbial red circle, text, etc.) before saving it. https://getgreenshot.org/ https://getgreenshot.org/
- dwags 7y agoChecking out the browsers / desktops of my coworkers when they are sharing screens is fun. We still make fun of one guy who had google bookmarked in chrome.