3 ms·
Being able to automate forms can absolutely revolutionize some businesses. Many business owners have no idea the extent to which automation is feasible here. I
by bob1029 7y ago
Being able to automate forms can absolutely revolutionize some businesses. Many business owners have no idea the extent to which automation is feasible here. I have seen fully manual paper process (printers/scanners/pen & ink/shredders/etc.) go into 100% digital realm and the impact it had on the business. It really is incredible the difference it makes. The most interesting factor was the fact that now that the inputs are captured in a computer, we can run business rules against those inputs computationally. I.e., prevent generation of forms you would have to otherwise manually revise and resubmit after the fact. Then someone figured out you could start plugging in other business systems to your rules engine and tracking state...
I think it is a fun and compelling challenge to see just how much of the business you can put "on rails" with computers and various integrations. I have some background in semiconductor manufacturing, and the degree of automation I witnessed there got to me in a really deep way. Experiencing a massive factory that can literally run for hours-to-days without a single human inside is something else. I feel a lot of businesses can strive towards similar goals. Being able to fully-automate manufacturing of silicon chips is an incredibly opulent affair, but if you can simply automate a paper-bound business process that is on a hot-path (I.e. used many times a day), it could potentially save a struggling business.
- selestify 7y agoHow frequent was actual human intervention required? Every few hours?
- bob1029 7y agoDepends on lots of factors. Most maintenance is preventative in that context, so its hard to pin down a specific thing that would break down first or how long it would take. If something does break unexpectedly its usually treated as a big deal every time so it never happens again.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hamstrungtw19 7y ago> Being able to fully-automate manufacturing of silicon chips is an incredibly opulent affair, but if you can simply automate a paper-bound business process that is on a hot-path (I.e. used many times a day), it could potentially save a struggling business. That's funny. I work at a very large fab, and of all the places I've worked, this is the one that's most in need of the sort of in-office hot path optimizations you mention, and doubly worse is that it's the least susceptible to allowing someone to do anything about it. (In fact, it's regressing. This month saw a fab-wide rollout of a document management system that has caused a ~10x increase in wall clock time for attaching files to emails or through forms on the intranet. Now consider what that means when the company exhibits a pathological form of the passing-MS-Office-documents-around-to-each-other mindset...)
- motogpjimbo 7y ago> Being able to automate forms can absolutely revolutionize some businesses I once worked for an insurance brokerage whose in-house CRM had started years before as an effort to automate paper-based forms. The company's business model was based on having their sales advisers fill out insurance policy application forms on their customers' behalf and originally this had been done using pen-and paper, which was obviously time-consuming and laborious. At some point, someone in the IT department had had the idea of scanning the application forms to image files and writing a simple PHP application to insert those images onto web pages with HTML <input> tags superimposed over the form fields, thus allowing advisers to fill in the forms using keyboard entry. They quickly realised that once forms are filled in digitally, (a) you can store the form data into the database and retrieve it later for further editing, (b) some of the data can be filled in automatically from the customer's records and (c) when generating quotes across multiple insurance providers, the common parts of each insurer's form can be filled in from data previously entered elsewhere. While the idea of superimposing HTML input fields over a scanned paper form isn't one I've encountered before or since, that company was turning over $3M per month by the time I joined, so there is clearly mileage in the idea. Incidentally, it turns out that basing your entry forms around scanned paper forms completely kills dead any of the interminable bikeshedding that takes place around UX design with complicated, multi-section forms.
- phonon 7y agohttps://www.codeproject.com/Articles/466362/Blend-PDF-with-HTML5 https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/466362/Blend-PDF-with-H...
- cr0sh 7y ago> While the idea of superimposing HTML input fields over a scanned paper form isn't one I've encountered before or since, that company was turning over $3M per month by the time I joined, so there is clearly mileage in the idea. You can also do this with PDF files, if you have Acrobat (or at least, it was possible - last time I played with it was several years ago - 2009-ish). You've probably seen "editable" PDF files - where there are fields you can type stuff into - much like a paper document that you'd put in a typewriter to "fill out". Well, it's actually possible (in Acrobat) to set up a "form submit" (virtually identical - IIRC, it was an actual HTTPS POST message) that you could point to a web endpoint. Add a button to the bottom of the page to submit the form, and it could also capture and handle errors (like if the service to receive the POST is offline, or has an error, etc). I forget was Adobe called it - but it worked rather well. I worked for a web app company who was contracted by a doctor's group to redo their website, and part of that was automating the forms. They wanted some way that a patient could download and use their standard PDF forms, to both enter and upload the information, or print it and fill it out manually and return it, if they were more comfortable with that. They didn't want an standard web form, or anything like you mentioned - because they might change the PDF for manual copies. Instead, we supplied them a template and taught them how to use it (and not to change particular parts - the parts handling submitting/errors and such) - so they could continue to use it. The backend was a PHP/MySQL system, everything was HTTPS, and IIRC we encrypted the data on the backend. I'm not certain that it was completely HIPAA compliant, but it was certainly as compliant as "form filled out with pen and filed in folder). So yeah - there's clearly a market for this kind of thing...
- dreamcompiler 7y agoAs a counterexample it's easy to get this wrong as well. In my EMT career we switched from doing run reports on paper to doing it on the computer. It was a nightmare. No attention to good UI principles had been paid. In the section on "What drugs did you administer?" we had to choose from a scrolling menu of perhaps 100 items for each drug we used (including oxygen which we used on everybody). Simply typing in their names would have been easy, but no. Every data element was like that. A report that took me 20 minutes on paper took 45 minutes on the web version. Classic enterprise software. Edit: Above was an attempt at digitization while this thread is about form automation. Understood. My point is that there was a lot of automation that could have been employed but wasn't. With that and good UI principles, the org could have made us more efficient. They chose not to because what they really wanted was a searchable database of patients treated so they could get more funding. EMT productivity was never a consideration.
- dragonsngoblins 7y agoI imagine this was partly an attempt at data normalization. If you'd been allowed to type it in they would have had to worry about differences in spelling, capitalization, etc. I'm not saying the solution they used was a good one mind, but I bet that was part of the motivation to implement it that way
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI expect you're right, but there are better ways (e.g. autocomplete) to achieve that.
- dragonsngoblins 7y agoOh most definitely. I didn't want to imply they went about it in an even half reasonable way, just that the motivation of designing the interface like that had nothing to do with optimizing for time spent filling it in
- Master_Odin 7y agoBad UI is basically consistent in all descriptions of all healthcare software. After working for a couple first responder outfits, I'm increasingly positive the companies who make this software do not have anyone on staff who have actually worked in the field, nor are they willing to interview people who have.