3 ms·
When you admire the more interesting parts of history, without taking into account the ugly, nasty side of them, you get shitty political movements (It is incre
by vkou 7y ago
When you admire the more interesting parts of history, without taking into account the ugly, nasty side of them, you get shitty political movements (It is incredibly popular among xenophobic nationalist assholes to admire the Roman Empire, the Crusaders, the Spartans, the Vikings, as some kind of cultural ideals that we should aspire to...)
For some reason, though, they always envision themselves as being warrior-kings, or some equivalent thereof in such societies, instead of members of a slave caste...
- gorgonical 7y agoI agree and in one of my replies I acknowledge that. It's okay to admire but you have to understand what you are admiring and its context. A very good recent example is that the Nazis were the first government to acknowledge that smoking is bad, and they had strong animal rights positions as well as decent policies on environmentalism. Nobody would argue that these footnotes mean we can overlook what they did, but what they did doesn't invalidate (emphasis) the good they did. It definitely outweighs it! If we weren't allowed to admire then what do we do? Even saintly figures have blemishes.
- glennpratt 7y agoMaybe you don't need to admire historic figures to acknowledge good policies? This doesn't seem very complicated. We constantly try to abstract good decisions into "good people" and that seems like a mistake.