3 ms·
If the offense is limited to shoplifting, then the lack of desire to spend resources on a full investigation obviously leads to that 2%. So that stat would be r
by mindslight 7y ago
If the offense is limited to shoplifting, then the lack of desire to spend resources on a full investigation obviously leads to that 2%. So that stat would be relevant for a shopowner who went after a shoplifter themselves, but not this situation - the police expending more resources is already taken as a given.
But sure, let a few more incidents of shoplifting escape justice because the perp manages to get away. It would take an awful lot of shoplifting to rise to the level of harm of blowing up a house, or (in other incidents) killing innocent bystanders in a high speed chase.
Either way, municipalities and police departments aren't even able to properly weigh those options if they can simply escape responsibility for the damage caused by their choice. Instead, shirking any potential harm pushes them into that same must-act mindset that you're arguing from.
Society is not going to fall apart from a little more shoplifting, but it will fall apart when people see the police as a source of chaos and injustice.
- dragontamer 7y ago> If the offense is limited to shoplifting The offenses in this case started with shoplifting, but then quickly turned into running from a police officer, a high-speed chase, as well as firing a handgun towards chasing officers. Are you saying that: 1. Police shouldn't have pursued the shoplifter? 2. Police shouldn't have engaged in a high-speed chase? 3. Police shouldn't have further escalated after taking gunfire? At what point did the Police go wrong, in your opinion?
- mindslight 7y agoI was directly responding to your stat that only 2% of shoplifters are caught after the fact, pointing out how this differs. I have already stated my general judgement for when the police went wrong - escalating into causing some serious public safety hazards. You keep trying to drag the conversation into a simplistic paradigm where the heroes can always do something more to win, with its corresponding blindspot to all the resulting destruction. Watching a movie, nobody really cares when some extras die. But in reality the entire mandate of the police is to protect the extras.
- dragontamer 7y ago> I have already stated my general judgement for when the police went wrong - escalating into causing some serious public safety hazards. The high-speed chase already appears to meet your criterion. So are you suggesting, that the Police should have not escalated and pursued the high-speed shoplifter? Escalating to a high-speed pursuit innately increases the risk: the police may crash into innocent civilians. The criminal may crash into innocents. Etc. etc. So that's why I'm asking: what is the correct decision, in your opinion, when a criminal floors it and reaches 90 mph in an attempt to evade officers? Should the officers just let them go? --------- If the pursuit was "morally correct" by your judgement, then the next point of escalation was when the criminal started to shoot his handgun at the Police. Should the Police stand-down now that gunfire is involved? Stray bullets have a high chance of harming innocent civilians (even if the criminal isn't intending to kill someone, the risk remains). Should the officers let the criminal go at this point? Etc. etc. There's a series of decisions here which make up the story. I'm trying to figure out how your point of view lines up to the reality of the case. We all can agree that deescalation should be prioritized. But we have a realistic case here. How would you have de-escalated the situation? Furthermore, we have the benefit of analyzing this from the safety of our desks, with all known information. So surely you can come up with a better decision with careful analysis, compared to an Officer who has to make a decision on the spot.
- mindslight 7y ago> what is the correct decision, in your opinion, when a criminal floors it and reaches 90 mph in an attempt to evade officers They've got a suspect description, car description, and license plate. There is no reason to believe the car is stolen, so there is a registered address. There is likely a helicopter on the way, and ANPR cameras will flag the plate. It was a property crime. Yes they should let the perp speed away and catch up with them later, rather than using the situation as an excuse to engage in their own sanctioned criminality. If you call any police station and ask this question in terms of say a hit and run collision and whether you should pursue, they will give you a similar answer.
- 7y ago