3 ms·
An urban growth boundary is not a policy that fixes this problem. We require streets to be very wide to accommodate car traffic. We require homes to be a cert
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
An urban growth boundary is not a policy that fixes this problem.
We require streets to be very wide to accommodate car traffic.
We require homes to be a certain minimum size.
We mandate lots of parking.
We have minimum lot sizes.
We have set backs from the lot line. This means you can't build row houses. We have places where if you buy an empty lot, you can build a row house matching the ones on either side. If you buy an old building, you can't tear it down and build new because it is grandfathered in and a new building would have to conform to a different set of rules.
We do seem to be lightening up on parking requirements in some cities, but many of these other issues are not being aggressively addressed.
You mostly can't build walkable neighborhoods in the US. This has been true a long time. The New Urbanism movement was about trying to do exactly that and they frequently had to do a lot of research and find loopholes to try to create anything akin to their vision. Their plans were usually denied the first time they were submitted and then they would go through zoning codes very carefully and start renaming things on their drawings to a conforming use that largely preserved their intended layout.
- JohnFen 7y agoI wasn't claiming that UGB were a solution, only that they are an indication that the tide is beginning to change. For the record, over half of the other issues you've raised have been, or are in the process of being, addressed in my current city.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAh, okay. A proxy. I know some things are changing, but we still have a long way to go. We've been building a certain kind of urban fabric a long time and it will take time to remedy the problems that have grown out of that fact.
- JohnFen 7y ago> we still have a long way to go. I agree entirely. What I've seen count as "baby steps". As I tell myself when something is taking far longer than it should, at least the trend line is pointing the right direction. A small amount of progress is preferable to none at all.