6 ms·
Is this when we now start to wonder what will count as a political ad? Social movements that have a political connection / associated with a particular party o
by duxup 7y ago
Is this when we now start to wonder what will count as a political ad?
Social movements that have a political connection / associated with a particular party or candidate?
- mc32 7y agoI mean social movements are all political. So I guess grass roots will be okay, just not paid or paid endorsements. So no promoting of the Sierra Club by commercial entities... for example. This is going to be s can of worms.
- reaperducer 7y agoProbably. But likely a smaller can of worms than allowing political ads.
- wolco 7y agoGrassroots movements don't spend money on ads. They are the viral.. spread naturally and don't have an ad manager or staff. Once you start paying for ads you are an organization.
- Analemma_ 7y agoThe FEC has pretty clear rules about what constitutes a political ad, and presumably Twitter will be using those. But whether that satisfies the (both literal and metaphorical) parties who've been grousing about political ads on Twitter/FB is a different story. Twitter might correctly point out that a given contentious ad doesn't satisfy the FEC's definition and that still won't stop the complaints. Still, I think they're now in a better spot than Facebook.
- jMyles 7y ago> The FEC has pretty clear rules about what constitutes a political ad, and presumably Twitter will be using those. I know that the FEC maintains guidelines for what Coordinated Communications, but I've never heard of this definition of "political ad" - can you provide a link?
- mgadams3 7y agoI suppose we'll find out on 11/15. Could use elections/votes as a proxy for what constitutes a political ad. If the thing/person being promoted can be voted on/in, it's a political ad.
- Miner49er 7y agoA post from the other day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21380985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21380985 A user who works in digital advertising said they do the following: > You don't take money from clients who are representing/selling anything other than goods or services. You evaluate creative & landing pages for each and every campaign. It's extremely simple. Seems like a mostly good solution. I guess you could still sell political services and goods though? Not sure how you would draw the line at that point, all goods and services can be argued to be political.
- mdorazio 7y agoThat's a good system, but I'm not sure it's actually workable at the scale of Twitter or Facebook's ad platforms. That's a a lot of human review.
- tyre 7y agoOf course it is workable. You approve ads as they come in. If the marginal value of the ads isn't high enough to justify human review, you kill those ads. It might be expensive, but it's not impossible. Using "scale" as an out doesn't fly. Sometimes you have to cut back on growth and/or scale to do the right thing. No human review clearly hasn't worked, so either automate or get humans in there. More likely, start with the latter and replace with the former over time.
- xenomachina 7y agoI'm not disagreeing with you, but I think one thing a lot of people don't realize is just how incredibly long the "long tail" is in self-service ads. I would not be surprised if more than 99% of potential ad impressions fall below the cost-effective-to-manually-review threshold. So requiring manual review on all ads is going to mean a lot more sacrifice than cutting back a little. It could mean a lot of these companies would be profitable at all. It's also unfortunate for the vast majority of advertisers in the long tail that are perfectly acceptable. Automating can help with the more obvious stuff, but there are many ways it can fail in either direction. For example, failing to detect hate-speech dog whistles, or inadvertently suppressing ads from minorities where the language patterns fall outside of what it sees as "the norm". Anyway, like I said, I'm not disagreeing with you. These systems definitely need considerable improvement, but doing that isn't as trivial as it may at first seem.
- rtkwe 7y agoThere'll be a lot of feeling out that line because it's impossible to draw a distinction that will work in every case. It'll be especially hard in cases where particular issues become heavily associated with one party or another though I guess they could just say product ads only, that would probably be a little easier because the line between a political and non-political product is a bit easier to draw.
- cooljacob204 7y agoAn option they have is to just filter it by to only allow companies that are trying to sell a product.
- jld 7y agoMajor League Soccer is going through this problem now. They prohibit political displays in stadium but are now in the business of deciding whether signs that say things like "anti-racist" or "anti-fascist" or "end gun violence" are political or not, and all of the worms that come out of that can. https://deadspin.com/by-banning-protest-signs-mls-is-trying-to-lobotomize-t-1837410237 https://deadspin.com/by-banning-protest-signs-mls-is-trying-...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jMyles 7y agoThe Portland Timbers literally use the Cascadia Flag. I mean, it's a joke to imagine that political messages are banned.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe difference is that it's easy to have "a private org can set its own logically inconsistent policy" (and every possible policy except "everything is allowed" is logically inconsistent) but impossible to have "we will only allow universally agreed upon good things in this space".
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThe latter turns into "everything is forbidden", which is also logically consistent... but not useful or practical.
- colechristensen 7y agoI wouldn't have a problem with expanding that to include social issues. You bought a ticket to see a game, not a billboard. This is a problem I have with modern social movements, when they fail to get audiences in public spaces they seek out captive audiences or to be disruptive as possible to completely unrelated places. Hold your rally in a park or march down main street or a pedestrian way or in front of some place you're protesting. Stop walking down highways and forcing your messages in places which have nothing to do with your cause.
- notatoad 7y agoMy first thought would be that any ad that isn't advertising a product or service for sale should be classed as a political ad.
- gnicholas 7y agoWhat about my side project Read Across The Aisle? We make a free news reader app that helps people keep track of their media bias. That is inherently political (the whole point is to help people become more well-rounded), but running an ad for my free app shouldn't be seen as a political ad since we are devoutly non-partisan.
- notatoad 7y agothey aren't saying they're banning partisan advertising, they're banning political advertising. a non-partisan political ad is still a political ad. that said, just because a product is free doesn't mean ads aren't "selling" it, which exposes the flaw in my criteria: if you're selling a political product, an ad can both be trying to sell a product and be a political ad at the same time.
- gnicholas 7y agoOh I realize that they wouldn't ban my ad. I'm saying that the heuristic you suggested isn't quite nuanced enough. It seems like this move will create lots of controversy and actually make political advertising on twitter more fraught (because it will still happen, but just not above-board). This may end up being a net negative for society if it pushes things into the seedier underbelly (gaming twitter's algorithms so your tweet pops up in the ICYMI section, buying followers in order to appear more influential, etc.).
- roywiggins 7y agoSo- can people sell political bumper stickers or no?
- lukifer 7y agoI'm reminded of the dodge that religious institutions have achieved. In exchange for tax-exempt status, they are forbidden from explicit political stances and endorsements; yet in practice, many churches are highly influential in the political process, as they of course are allowed to take moral stances (abortion being the big one), and encouraging their congregations to "vote their consciences", etc. Seems to me that Twitter advertisements would likely take the same path, where the bought political influence is instead abstracted away into generalized "awareness campaigns", push-polls, etc.
- briandear 7y agoThe Sierra Club has a similar “dodge.” Most non-profits are tax exempt and many have separate PACs that aren’t tax exempt but are indirectly supported by their tax-exempt cohort if only by providing a mailing list from which to solicit donations.
- rexpop 7y agoCoca-Cola is political. Microsoft is political. All firms are political. Politics don't go away just because you ontologize them as "private sector".
- RyanCavanaugh 7y agoMost social networks already have to decide what counts as "adult" content, which has just as much gray area as what counts as "political".
- Mirioron 7y agoYes, but making a mistake on what is and isn't adult content or people seeing it when they shouldn't or vice versa doesn't have much negative impact on society. A private company that lets political gray area ads slip through from one side, but not the other, will likely have an impact on society.
- adamsea 7y agoI believe the process to which you refer is called "democracy" ;)
- novalis78 7y agoThat’s exactly how this is going to be gamed.