4 ms·
If Tesla does not abide by the terms of the copyright license governing the code they have chosen to use, they are in breach of that license and can be sued for
by gamblor956 7y ago
If Tesla does not abide by the terms of the copyright license governing the code they have chosen to use, they are in breach of that license and can be sued for damages for every instance of copyright violation--i.e., for every car sold--and can also be barred from using that code without a license going forward, meaning that they would be barred from selling cars until they either license the code or reprogram every car using the unlicensed code.
- tzs 7y agoAssuming US law, to get damages for every car sold I believe that the plaintiff would have to be suing for actual damages. That's the monetary harm the infringement actually caused the plaintiff, and profits the defendant made from the infringement. Monetary harm would be hard to prove for purely GPL software. For software that is dual licensed under GPL and a non-free license that you have to pay to get, there is a much better chance plaintiff could make a case for monetary harm. Defendant's profits is more promising, but I believe that it is profits that can reasonably be attributed to the infringing material. Plaintiff's best bet for getting money out of a copyright suit in a case like this is to elect to ask for statutory damages rather than actual damages. Statutory damages are per infringed work, not per infringing copy. Statutory damages are from $750 to $30000, with the exact amount depending on the seriousness of the infringement and the worth of the infringer. The lower end can be lowered to as low as $200 if the court finds the the infringer was an "innocent infringer" (which would require the infringer to not know or have reason to know the work was copyrighted--a very unlikely possibility), and the higher end can be raised to as much as $150000 if the infringement was "willful".
- henryfjordan 7y ago> Defendant's profits is more promising, but I believe that it is profits that can reasonably be attributed to the infringing material. Car doesn't run without Linux, Cool entertainment features don't work without Linux, Battery Management based on Linux? etc, etc...