6 ms·
You've completely missed the point of the article. The point is that the Dutch use bicycles a lot because their urban infrastructure means many of their trips a
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
You've completely missed the point of the article. The point is that the Dutch use bicycles a lot because their urban infrastructure means many of their trips are the right length for a bike to make sense over either walking or driving.
The Dutch are not insane fitness nuts biking 25 miles to work daily. They just have a built environment where taking a bike actually makes sense because they aren't going terribly far, just far enough that the hassles involved in taking a bike (like locking it up) are worth it.
- thiagomgd 7y agoThe title completely misses the point of the article
- stetrain 7y agoOnly if you don't enjoy clever titles.
- Footkerchief 7y agoCleverness at the expense of clarity is pretty much the essence of clickbait.
- jiofih 7y agoYes, I yearn for the day every news piece reads like a financial report, and creativity doesn’t get in the way of my act of information consumption.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI assumed before reading the piece that the entire point was that miles traveled by bike were low on a per person basis. The point of the title is PR. It's an attempt to rebut the assumption that this is hard, so fat, out of shape Americans have no hope of aspiring to create a bicycle culture like the vaunted Dutch, who must all be super athletic as one of their many godlike virtues. There's nothing all that special about the Dutch people. They aren't all Olympic athletes. They aren't all brainwashed hyper virtuous types making hyper virtuous choices at enormous personal expense and suffering. They just have a built environment that helps make it easy for little old grandmas to take their bike somewhere. If you want to argue that it's a bad title for HN, sure. I totally agree. But the title wasn't written for HN and it's a perfectly fine title for it's intended purpose for most audiences.
- RaiseProfits 7y agoThe title is incredibly bad at anchoring this, selling the dutch as biking less frequently than other cultures rather than comparing average biking distance to average biking distance.
- stetrain 7y ago> biking less frequently than other cultures Huh, I missed that in the title. My first guess was that their other public transit was good enough that not much biking was needed, which isn't far off the mark.
- akgerber 7y agoEven in those parts of the US where we live at similar or higher density versus the Netherlands, biking is far less common because the motoring community has seized most of our streets for car storage, crowding out the kind of bike infrastructure that's required for most people to feel comfortable cycling short trips. (Banning cars would also be a solution, as 'bike infrastructure' is really infrastructure to protect bikes from cars, but it's not necessary when there's large amounts of street space that could be repurposed from car storage) US rail stations also generally have less, and less secure, bike parking versus equivalent stations in the Netherlands, reducing their catchment areas to a mile-wide 'walkshed' rather than a few-mile-wide 'bikeshed'.
- earthboundkid 7y agoI live in Baltimore and for many of the trips in my daily life a bike is faster than a car because I don't get stuck in traffic and I don't have to look for parking, but biking has other disadvantages. Most seriously, the safety of biking is highly questionable, since there are very few bike lanes, so you end up weaving among cars that do not give one crap about your safety. In addition, since Baltimore is harbor town, there's a pretty good slope and going up hill is no fun. That said, I see a fair number of rent-a-scooters every day. It seems like they could become popular enough to force the creation of more protected lanes.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoIn San Francisco there's a good chance your destination will not have a safe, designated place for biking. That increases the chances of it getting stolen by quite a bit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- on_and_off 7y agoI am in San Francisco, last mile vehicles are a good solution to the theft problem since you are going to carry them with you. It does nothing for the fact that the roads are often in a pretty bad state and more importantly that you share the streets with cars. I already had an asshole bump his car on my legs apparently voluntarily. I know that some riders wear gopro constantly in order to document this kind of occurrences. And even aside from these extreme morons, inattentive drivers are pretty dangerous. I can't wait for the day where there will be a dedicated segregated bike lane on market. That will be a good start.
- agumonkey 7y agoStill the titles conveys quite a different idea. I don't think anybody confused dutch biking with hard mountain bikers.
- jiofih 7y agoThat’s the plot twist in the article, it’s just creative writing and sets the tone for the argument that comes next. It only disappoints people who expect to gain knowlege by skimming over headlines.
- agumonkey 7y agothat wasn't my case either :)
- SilasX 7y agoFor non-fiction, I don't want clickbaity "creative writing", I want clear facts and arguments.
- jiofih 7y agoYou might want to browse Reuters.com or BBC (might be too much) instead? “Hacker News” is not exactly the place to stifle creativity.
- SilasX 7y ago"Everyone talking past each other because of unclear articles" stifles creativity too. And HN isn't mutually exclusive with reading Reuters and BBC (at least if you plan to go to the links being discussed here): https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=reuters.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=reuters.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=bbc.co.uk https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=bbc.co.uk
- agumonkey 7y agocreativity in ideas, not in representation
- komali2 7y ago> The Dutch are not insane fitness nuts biking 25 miles to work daily. I feel like the difference in % of people even in the Bay Area that bike 15, 25, and 45 (all the way from SF to MV) is minuscule. Everyone I talk to either doesn't bike at all, or has something like a .5-3 mile ride as their whole commute or part of their commute.
- coldtea 7y ago>The Dutch are not insane fitness nuts biking 25 miles to work daily. They just have a built environment where taking a bike actually makes sense because they aren't going terribly far, just far enough that the hassles involved in taking a bike (like locking it up) are worth it. Is that the whole story though? The Dutch are much more fit in general than the median US population (regarding obesity, etc). So them biking more is not necessarily only due to better cities. Also, their cities are also not an accident of nature they had to make do with: they built them that way, like the US cities were built for cars. So their biking more is not a mere accident of how they cities are. Rather both their cities and their biking are intentional. Third, even in places with similar population density and distances, the US has let bikers as several people have mentioned. So while "it's more convenient to bike" is part of the explanation, it doesn't tell the whole story.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNowhere have I claimed that it tells the whole story or that there aren't other factors. The whole story isn't going to be told in a single article. It's unreasonable to expect that it should be. This article has a particular point and I think it's a good point. It actually has two main points: 1. The built environment is a large factor. 2. The high numbers of cyclists in The Netherlands is really a whole lot of people making fairly short trips on a regular basis. The first is a big problem that will take years to remedy. The second is about an erroneous impression that serves as a psychological barrier to adopting better policies. A lot of Americans tend to be all "Why bother?! It's hopeless!" It's not hopeless. Even your average fat American can probably bike a mile or so. Biking regularly is no doubt a very large part of why the Dutch are healthier, not the other way around. You need biking infrastructure to help foster a healthier lifestyle. You don't need to wait until Americans all magically wake up one day with super athletic physiques before you biking more is viable in the US.