5 ms·
>Is this an error? I asked around for a comparable estimate at the national level. As of 2017, that estimate is 2.5 km. So, 1.5 miles per person per day. Either
by coldtea 7y ago
>Is this an error? I asked around for a comparable estimate at the national level. As of 2017, that estimate is 2.5 km. So, 1.5 miles per person per day. Either way you count it, the Dutch hardly bike at all.
An average of 1.5 miles per person per day sounds huge.
What's the American average? 0.05 miles?
What's the baseline from where the author justifies the "hardly bike" line?
There are 17 million people in Netherlands, and 800.000 in Amsterdam.
If half of the people in Amsterdam go about 5km per day (they wouldn't need much more, it's not a huge city, and they'd mostly go to/from work/school/home) that's 2.5 km per person per day -- the number they post.
Half of the people of a city biking everyday is HUGE, and dwarfs any US town 5x easily.
Heck, merely 10% of the population biking every day would be huge, and that's easily within the number given.
I'd say the same holds for other Dutch cities and villages.
So what are we are comparing with?
- SilasX 7y agoYeah, those are my thoughts exactly. The relevant measure is what fraction of adults bike for travel every day (or close to it). Pretty sure the Netherlands crushes the US by that metric.
- icebraining 7y agoRelevant for what?
- SilasX 7y agoFor gauging what could justifiably be called "how often the population bikes" without becoming clickbait.
- MiroF 7y agoExactly - doesn't take a genius to realize 2.5 km per day per capita is huge.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago2.5km per capita per day is huge. 2.5km per cyclist per day is tiny. The difference between those two statements and the specific details and societal implications thereof is the whole point of the article.
- MiroF 7y ago"average Dutch person bikes per day" I took that to mean per capita. Are you telling me they meant per cyclist?
- Scarblac 7y agoIn the Netherlands that difference isn't that huge, there are 17 million people, 13.5 million of those own bicycles (there are about 23 million bicycles total).
- coldtea 7y ago>2.5km per cyclist per day is tiny. Not really. It would be tiny if it was describing hobbyist biking fanatics etc (who are expected to bike much more). But when the "per cyclist" is used to describe regular people who bike to home/work/etc (because the country has a bike culture), as a per day number it's big. Because then it can be compared to the tons of regular people who don't bike at all in other countries. In other words 2.5km per day "per capita" and "per cyclist" could be equally huge, when the percentage of cyclists is big in the population, because the "per cyclist" suddenly doesn't mean: "Bike fans in Netherlands do an average 2.5km per day" but: "Shitloads of people in Netherlands have a bike and do an average 2.5km per day on it"
- SamBam 7y agoYou're comparing the average Dutch person vs a hypothetical average American to say it's a huge difference, but obviously the "average American" is going to be orders of magnitude lower as the vast majority of Americans don't bicycle regularly. The article already points out that a much higher proportion of people in the Netherlands bike. "The Dutch hardly bike at all" refers to an individual cyclist compared with an individual cyclist in the states. To someone who does bicycle regularly, 1.5 miles is, indeed, hardly anything at all. I bike 1.5 miles in each direction to my train each day (so twice that average) and don't consider myself to bike far at all. I guess at worst you can say it's a click-baity title, as it's appearing to go counter to your expectations of a heavy biking culture (which it is) to say that any one cycling individual doesn't actually bike far, but that shift in perspective is the point of the article.
- wodenokoto 7y agoThat still doesn't give you a 3 mile daily average. You have to discount weekends, holidays and bad weather days. You also cannot compare average biking distance for a whole population with the average biking distance of the biking subset of another population. That is like comparing life expectancy of musical conductors with the life expectancy of the general population. > I guess at worst you can say it's a click-baity title That is being extremely generous.
- jiofih 7y ago> You have to discount weekends, holidays and bad weather days That’s part of it, in the Netherlands you might cycle even more on weekends and holidays to go somewhere, and there is no ‘bad weather’ (it’s already bad most of the time).
- SamBam 7y agoIf the Netherlands were known for being "a country of musicians," because almost every Dutch person played the piano, would that be a fair stereotype of the country? If, on average, they only played the piano once a week, just to play a single scale, would it be fair to have an article whose title was "The Dutch barely play at all"? All three things would be true: 1. The Dutch were famous because most of them played the piano 2. The average Dutch person plays significantly more scales than the average American (who probably play <0.005 scales) 3. The Dutch "barely play at all." Honestly, I don't see why this title is bothering you so much. Most people's image is of the Dutch biking everywhere.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou've completely missed the point of the article. The point is that the Dutch use bicycles a lot because their urban infrastructure means many of their trips are the right length for a bike to make sense over either walking or driving. The Dutch are not insane fitness nuts biking 25 miles to work daily. They just have a built environment where taking a bike actually makes sense because they aren't going terribly far, just far enough that the hassles involved in taking a bike (like locking it up) are worth it.
- thiagomgd 7y agoThe title completely misses the point of the article
- stetrain 7y agoOnly if you don't enjoy clever titles.
- Footkerchief 7y agoCleverness at the expense of clarity is pretty much the essence of clickbait.
- jiofih 7y agoYes, I yearn for the day every news piece reads like a financial report, and creativity doesn’t get in the way of my act of information consumption.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI assumed before reading the piece that the entire point was that miles traveled by bike were low on a per person basis. The point of the title is PR. It's an attempt to rebut the assumption that this is hard, so fat, out of shape Americans have no hope of aspiring to create a bicycle culture like the vaunted Dutch, who must all be super athletic as one of their many godlike virtues. There's nothing all that special about the Dutch people. They aren't all Olympic athletes. They aren't all brainwashed hyper virtuous types making hyper virtuous choices at enormous personal expense and suffering. They just have a built environment that helps make it easy for little old grandmas to take their bike somewhere. If you want to argue that it's a bad title for HN, sure. I totally agree. But the title wasn't written for HN and it's a perfectly fine title for it's intended purpose for most audiences.
- pwinnski 7y agoDid you read the rest of the article? The entire point of the article is that by one measure, the Dutch hardly bike at all, while by another measure, the Dutch bike all the time, and that the difference is that there are destinations that makes a mile or two round-trip plenty in Dutch cities, but not in American cities.
- MiroF 7y agoYou're totally missing the point of the above comment. The entire article is premised on "by one measure, the Dutch hardly bike at all," but 2.5 km/day/capita is fucking huge.
- pwinnski 7y agoIf I draw circles around my home at .75km or 1.25km, I get almost entirely other houses, and roads. Lots of roads. In most of America, a 2.5km round trip gets you almost nowhere useful. It's almost nothing. On an American scale, it's hardly anything at all. The average American[0] drives more than 59 km per day, so even at the most generous number from the article, that's 4%. That's the point of the article, the entire point. [0] https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/01/25/the-average-american-drives-this-much-each-year-ho.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/01/25/the-averag...
- JohnFen 7y ago> An average of 1.5 miles per person per day sounds huge. I thought that it sounded really small, but my point of comparison is my own personal bicycling habit -- my daily bicycle commute is about 10 miles round trip. Yes, I'm an American.
- ehnto 7y agoI agree, 2.5km is great considering not everyone needs a bike to commute without a car, not everyone rides every day, only able bodied people can ride, and not all people who do ride have far to go.
- Scarblac 7y agoIt's surprising because the number of bicycles in the Netherlands is easily larger than the number of citizens, and the country is famous for being bicycle crazy with really great infrastructure for cycling. Given that, 0.75-1.5 mile per day doesn't sound like a lot. Of course the US cycles far less, but it's reputation is of being the most car centric country in the world.
- JohnFen 7y ago> merely 10% of the population biking every day would be huge, and that's easily within the number given. The US city I live in is far more bike-friendly than most, and I assume that it has a higher percentage of bike commuters than most (but that's my personal assumption). The city has automated bike counters scattered around, and annually does a manual bike count where they tally the number of parked bikes that are publicly visible, in an attempt at estimating the percentage of commutes that are done by bike. The most recent figure they published (last year) put their estimation right around 7%.