3 ms·
... or you DEescalate the situation, because we're talking about policing a crime, not fighting a war. Firearms favor defense, hence the standoff between one g
by mindslight 7y ago
... or you DEescalate the situation, because we're talking about policing a crime, not fighting a war.
Firearms favor defense, hence the standoff between one guy and many police. The solution is not to elevate the stakes of standoffs with bigger weapons, nor is it to make police more armed than the citizenry. In fact, that misguided approach of arming police with bigger weapons is a root cause of this incident.
The whole situation started with basic theft and kept escalating, which is an explicit choice of each party. At any time, the police could have simply broken it off and tracked him down later. But instead they chose to play heroes with their toys, and somehow managed to get indemnified for it.
- dragontamer 7y ago> At any time, the police could have simply broken it off and tracked him down later. You'll let a criminal go free because he forced a high-speed chase, and took shots at an officer with a handgun? Take a guess what the local criminals will do if that hits the news. That's WHY criminals enter high speed chases: because they know that officers sometimes let them go at that point. You have to continue pursuit if the criminal escalates, or else the other criminals will change their strategy.
- mindslight 7y agoYou do realize that police keep investigating crimes and tracking down suspects afterwards, right? Showing up at his home the next day while he's eating dinner and less likely to act as a scared animal is not letting "a criminal go free".
- dragontamer 7y ago> You do realize that police keep investigating crimes and tracking down suspects afterwards, right? You realize that most shoplifting suspects are never caught, right? Some stats suggest a 2% chance of actually catching a shoplifter after the crime. Letting them go at this point means 98% chance that they'll get away. For the officer: keeping up the police chase is your best bet. You keep chasing until the Helicopter comes in, and then the Helicopter can follow the car no matter where it goes. This is why criminals force a high-speed chase, because they can (and often do) get away with it (as long as they disappear before the Helicopter arrives). The mistake for the criminal here was shooting at the Police Officer, which enrages officers to a severe degree. Once you apply lethal force to officers, they'll chase you down basically forever.
- mindslight 7y agoIf the offense is limited to shoplifting, then the lack of desire to spend resources on a full investigation obviously leads to that 2%. So that stat would be relevant for a shopowner who went after a shoplifter themselves, but not this situation - the police expending more resources is already taken as a given. But sure, let a few more incidents of shoplifting escape justice because the perp manages to get away. It would take an awful lot of shoplifting to rise to the level of harm of blowing up a house, or (in other incidents) killing innocent bystanders in a high speed chase. Either way, municipalities and police departments aren't even able to properly weigh those options if they can simply escape responsibility for the damage caused by their choice. Instead, shirking any potential harm pushes them into that same must-act mindset that you're arguing from. Society is not going to fall apart from a little more shoplifting, but it will fall apart when people see the police as a source of chaos and injustice.
- dragontamer 7y ago> If the offense is limited to shoplifting The offenses in this case started with shoplifting, but then quickly turned into running from a police officer, a high-speed chase, as well as firing a handgun towards chasing officers. Are you saying that: 1. Police shouldn't have pursued the shoplifter? 2. Police shouldn't have engaged in a high-speed chase? 3. Police shouldn't have further escalated after taking gunfire? At what point did the Police go wrong, in your opinion?
- mindslight 7y agoI was directly responding to your stat that only 2% of shoplifters are caught after the fact, pointing out how this differs. I have already stated my general judgement for when the police went wrong - escalating into causing some serious public safety hazards. You keep trying to drag the conversation into a simplistic paradigm where the heroes can always do something more to win, with its corresponding blindspot to all the resulting destruction. Watching a movie, nobody really cares when some extras die. But in reality the entire mandate of the police is to protect the extras.