3 ms·
> Consider the guy blindly opened fire on the police, things could have been a lot worse had he kept the boy. Exactly right. I'm shocked and saddened that the
by fortran77 7y ago
> Consider the guy blindly opened fire on the police, things could have been a lot worse had he kept the boy.
Exactly right. I'm shocked and saddened that the Hacker News community has reduced this to a "shoplifting."
- throwaway_law 7y agoPlus down voting to censor truth rather responding or acknowledging the fact the home was insured and the Police paid the insurance deductible.
- shantly 7y agoThe article just said they offered $5k total to go toward the deductible and temporary housing. It says nothing about how much that actually cost, which was surely more. That wouldn't even cover fairly modest housing for a family during the time it'd take to tear down, clear the lot, and rebuild. The homeowner claims he's out $400k total for various reasons, beyond what insurance covered. Even if he was underinsured (likely), sure, that's on him, but the police did choose to do an absurd amount of damage to the house with all their fancy toys rather than just shutting off utilities and waiting. It's not like the guy took hostages, and there's no indication they even thought he had. For attacking the house to make sense in such a time-insensitive situation they must have thought they had a pretty solid perimeter set up. They chose to wreck the house.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>The homeowner claims he's out $400k total for various reasons, beyond what insurance covered. That is not what the homeowner claimed. He claimed his damages were $400k total, and the house was covered. What wasn't covered were the contents of the home because it was a rental and the renter didn't have renter's insurance. Also there were some runaway costs to the owner in the rebuild because the owner repoured the foundation (which wasn't damaged) in order to build a bigger home. >They chose to wreck the house. And he choose not to rebuild on the existing undamaged foundation and lay a new foundation to build a bigger home, but the damages to make the homeowner whole were otherwise covered by insurance.
- shantly 7y agoAh, good point, I read those were his expenses and didn't catch that was before insurance reimbursement. Looks like the actual damages beyond that are just loss of personal property in the house and whatever it cost to deal with the whole, you know, police-blew-up-my-house situation, which is surely non-trivial but likely well under $400,000.
- icebraining 7y agoI agree that armed robbery is not shoplifting and shouldn't be portrayed as such. But I don't see how that hypothetical changes things; from the article timeline, the boy had left the house before the cops even got there. It's not like he decided to let him leave due to the bombardments.
- throwaway_law 7y agoBefore the police used force the gunman opened fire on the police.