2 ms·
The distinction is longstanding, from a simpler time. The problem is that the police are taking more and more advantage of it. Indemnifying police for the dama
by mindslight 7y ago
The distinction is longstanding, from a simpler time. The problem is that the police are taking more and more advantage of it.
Indemnifying police for the damages they cause makes it so they have no reason to even consider them. We'd expect these externalities to grow larger over time, because there's no incentive for them not to. Wait for the suspect to come out, or play commando? It's all the same to them.
The current situation is a weird reverse-lottery wherein only a rare unlucky victim is expected to bear the burden of a societal cost. Police departments should be civilly responsible for damage caused by their actions, end of story.
This story, casualties from high speed chases, arrests of innocent people. These are all damages created by explicit choices by police, and thus whomever is enabling/funding the police departments should be responsible for them. If cities/insurers/taxpayers don't like having to pay for what they're enabling, then they will institute policies to reign in the police to keep them from doing such things!