2 ms·
> They could have "sieged" the house and waited for him to come out when he ran out of food. Both 2nd amendment activists and anti-gun people make the same mis
by dragontamer 7y ago
> They could have "sieged" the house and waited for him to come out when he ran out of food.
Both 2nd amendment activists and anti-gun people make the same mistake here: the physical presence of a gun changes everything. Guns favor the offense, not the defense.
The solution is always the same: if the opponent has a weapon, you bring bigger weapons to subjugate them. APCs will allow you to move forward without risk of getting shot at, while heavy weapons like grenades and rocket-launchers destroy the cover and concealment of the defender.
The first step is recognizing the root of the problem. The handgun. Remove the gun, and the heavy-weapons wouldn't have been necessary. But as long as the general citizenry has access to firearms, it is necessary to give bigger and better weapons to law enforcement.
----------
Consider this: how would YOU form a perimeter around the house safely and effectively? An APC is the natural weapon: thick plate to provide immunity to small-weapons like handguns. If the local police only has one APC however, that's not enough to form an effective perimeter: you can only cover one side of the house.
So you put men around the house, and hope that they don't get shot. And those men remain at risk throughout the duration of the siege. Thick body-armor doesn't protect the head, and it still gets hurt to get shot at.
- whamlastxmas 7y ago>And those men remain at risk throughout the duration of the siege. It's almost like police officers signed up for a career that puts them at risk. They need to accept this risk and act like more civil servants than bullies with dangerous toys. There also needs to be more focus on deescalation than "fuck it let's just bomb him" which would also make officers much more safe.
- dragontamer 7y ago> It's almost like police officers signed up for a career that puts them at risk. That's how you lose Police Officers. Workers prefer to work in safer jobs, and are even willing to take pay-cuts to work in a safer area. A US-police department is in constant competition with rival cities for the same pool of applicants. If your local police department gets a reputation of not backing its officers, your officers will LEAVE to other cities. Period. There's a reason why all cities back their Police Departments with as much support as possible. Its a necessary part of attracting the best candidates. Some Police Officers have degrees in criminal law theory, college-educated. Other police officers are just high-school graduates with some muscle. When police departments struggle, they lose the higher-quality officers to their local rivals. Which means either fewer officers, or being forced to hire low-quality officers. ------------- The fundamental issue here is that Police Departments are too small, making the politics of "local rivals" a toxic culture. Police departments need to be forced to merge together and cover larger areas. A nation-wide police force would probably be too big, but we can start by eradicating all town-level police forces (less than 20,000 citizens) and merging them into a larger regional area. As long as there are Police Departments that only protect $1-Million homes (where virtually no crimes are committed), you'll have the quality Police Officers leaving the dangerous areas where they're needed (ie: typical inner cities) and working to move towards the richer areas. You gotta fix the fundamental politics: the underlying driver of the culture.
- rootusrootus 7y ago> Workers prefer to work in safer jobs Police officer isn't a bad choice, then. It does not even break into the top 10 most dangerous jobs in America.
- dragontamer 7y ago> Police officer isn't a bad choice, then. It does not even break into the top 10 most dangerous jobs in America. Police officer in an area with $1 Million homes in gated communities is even better. If you're a college-educated, high-quality Police Officer, there's basically no reason to work in the inner-city Ghettos. There's always a suburbia which is safer, quieter, and simpler to work at. If you can't work in rich-suburbia, then working in those cities with military-grade weapons is still better than inner-city ghettos.
- shantly 7y agoIt's exactly the same for teaching. Around here the nicer schools even pay worse because they get the best applicants anyway! The job's way easier, more pleasant, less full of horrors that haunt you for years after, and you don't have 3rd graders swearing at you and threatening to stab you with alarming frequency. Well worth 10-20% lower pay.
- MFogleman 7y agoPretty big fallacy bro. Its not in the top 10 most deadly jobs in America. "Danger" is a relative term. If a squad of 20 soldiers get in a gunfight every day over 3 months, and none of them die, was their job less dangerous than the 20 guys who work in an office, where Jerry was killed by a vending machine tipping over? The FBI tracks Law Enforcement Officers Killed and Assaulted (LEOKA)[1]. There are around 540,000 police officers in the US, and about 58,000 recorded assault. Now, there are lies, damn lies, and statistics. Some of those assaults are undoubtedly some Kelly Thomas type BS where the cops beat the crap out of a guy and got blood on their uniforms and counted it as assault. There are also likely assaults that don't get listed/reported. E.g. a man who just murdered someone is running from the cops, car chase ensues. 10+ cop cars behind the suspect, who starts shooting at officers. This did not get recorded as 10 assaults, though 10 cops were shot at. Also keep in mind that these statistics are of all reporting agencies. Every Mayberry town with 100 citizens, 1 sheriff, and 1 deputy. Every command staff and supervisor who are effectively just managers with a badge. The cops who do entirely admin work and don't wear their vest anymore. The High Tech Crimes guys who don't respond to calls, but do computer forensic analysis in pedophile cases. These are all less likely to be assaulted than the cop doing a solo patrol, responding to calls. _____ [1]1https://ucr.fbi.gov/leoka https://ucr.fbi.gov/leoka
- mindslight 7y ago... or you DEescalate the situation, because we're talking about policing a crime, not fighting a war. Firearms favor defense, hence the standoff between one guy and many police. The solution is not to elevate the stakes of standoffs with bigger weapons, nor is it to make police more armed than the citizenry. In fact, that misguided approach of arming police with bigger weapons is a root cause of this incident. The whole situation started with basic theft and kept escalating, which is an explicit choice of each party. At any time, the police could have simply broken it off and tracked him down later. But instead they chose to play heroes with their toys, and somehow managed to get indemnified for it.
- dragontamer 7y ago> At any time, the police could have simply broken it off and tracked him down later. You'll let a criminal go free because he forced a high-speed chase, and took shots at an officer with a handgun? Take a guess what the local criminals will do if that hits the news. That's WHY criminals enter high speed chases: because they know that officers sometimes let them go at that point. You have to continue pursuit if the criminal escalates, or else the other criminals will change their strategy.
- mindslight 7y agoYou do realize that police keep investigating crimes and tracking down suspects afterwards, right? Showing up at his home the next day while he's eating dinner and less likely to act as a scared animal is not letting "a criminal go free".
- dragontamer 7y ago> You do realize that police keep investigating crimes and tracking down suspects afterwards, right? You realize that most shoplifting suspects are never caught, right? Some stats suggest a 2% chance of actually catching a shoplifter after the crime. Letting them go at this point means 98% chance that they'll get away. For the officer: keeping up the police chase is your best bet. You keep chasing until the Helicopter comes in, and then the Helicopter can follow the car no matter where it goes. This is why criminals force a high-speed chase, because they can (and often do) get away with it (as long as they disappear before the Helicopter arrives). The mistake for the criminal here was shooting at the Police Officer, which enrages officers to a severe degree. Once you apply lethal force to officers, they'll chase you down basically forever.
- jack_h 7y agoI'm actually kind of appalled that you think a handgun justifies not only arming police departments with military surplus, but also the use of them. Unlike in a military conflict where the combatants are actively trying to create casualties in enemy forces and all the horrors that entails, the police have a lot more things to consider. That's why in a high speed chase police tend to back off and track the suspect from the air rather than endanger the public more. However, by your logic if they knew the suspect had a handgun they would be justified in using a surplus drone or gunship to just destroy the vehicle with little regard to anything else. Force escalation is not defensible for civilians, why on earth is it acceptable for the police?
- dragontamer 7y ago> I'm actually kind of appalled that you think a handgun justifies not only arming police departments with military surplus, but also the use of them. My argument is a bit more subtle than that. The military surplus culture is IMO due to local-police departments trying to out-compete their local rivals. If you're a Police Officer candidate, with a criminal law bachelors, aiming to join a Police department... which one do you pick? * Dangerous area with military-grade weapons for officers? * Dangerous area without military grade weapons for officers? That's where the fundamental issue comes in. Police departments want to attract the best candidates, and the military surplus items provide an aura of protection, as well as assurances of a "Police-culture".
- shantly 7y ago> And those men remain at risk throughout the duration of the siege. Assaulting the house seems to me many, many times more personally risky than hanging around a block away behind cover watching the house for a day or three.